The US triple play wars are just about to expand to the mobile platform, with a move by the US cable operators that is sure to shift the goalposts in US telecoms once again, with Sprint Nextel as the key catalyst. The three biggest cablecos are on the verge of uniting in their long rumored alliance to become a single Mobile Virtual Network Operator (MVNO) with the ability to bundle internet access, voice, mobile voice and TV services into a single contract.
Comcast, Time Warner Cable, and Cox talked openly at this year’s National Cable Television Show in April about the need for a wireless platform to compete with Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless, and said at the time that they could not decide whether they should buy, build or partner in order to get a wireless operation. But Sprint was curiously invited to the show and spent time encouraging the audience to partner with it. Now it appears to have its wish and a new era in US telecommunications is about to be born. Sprint has made no bones about ‘sticking it to its US mobile competitors’ by using the marketing power of Comcast, Time Warner and Cox, and is prepared to submerge its brand behind the respective cable operators, in order to create a huge surge in subscribers to its network.
Sprint’s merger with Nextel may have been one reason that the deal has taken this long to iron out, but now that transaction has been completed the enlarged operator is in pole position to take a huge bite out of Verizon Wireless and Cingular. Sprint Nextel has been positioning itself as the first and only converged telecommunications operator that will offer up services that appear the same regardless of whether they run over Sprint PCS, Nextel, wired infrastructure or a new WiMAX network. Consistent with that vision is a future where emerging dual mode handsets, which sport both Wi-Fi and cellular connections, drive down the amount of time that consumers spend attached to the expensive cellular network.
Only a company committed to converged IP-based services would contemplate this undermining of expensive cellular minutes The final upshot is a world where all the advantages of a cellphone ‘ screen, videoconferencing, camera, phone book, email, entertainment ‘ define your handset, but where that handset attaches to any Wi-Fi network it is authorized to work with, on a single monthly flat rate payment. Consumers can own a single handset, use it at work where it is billed to the broadband network through Wi-Fi, and at home, where it is billed to a broadband line, again over WLans, and at hotspots. In a world which is rapidly, in the US at least, filling with free or cheap hotspots, this leaves precious little time to use expensive cellular services when the customer is in none of these three locations.
Also, cable operators already offer music and games portals and can point these at their future mobile customers, further depriving cellphone carriers of one area of salvation expected from advanced content regimes. Over 75% of all landline closures in the US (that’s 6.6m of 8.8m losses a year) are losses to mobile phones. The rest are to VoIP. Home users like the convenience of the mobile device, but not the size of the monthly bill from using phones from their home. If the cable operators can get their message across, and they have consistently managed this in signing up 2m broadband lines a year, then they will force all the US cellular operators to either drive prices down on the cellular networks, making them far less profitable, or to offer MVNOs of their own or introduce similar dual-mode handset operations, all of which will have the same effect.
If this all happens this year, then by the middle of next year, the Bell incumbents will be forced into dramatic action. Verizon would be shrinking and unprofitable if it weren’t for its wireless operations and if they become less profitable and cease to grow, its share price will fall even further than it has today.
But the winner here may not be the cable companies as much as Sprint Nextel itself. The next battleground may well be for Wi-Fi hotspot relationships, which suddenly have a key role to play in driving down cellular costs once they are opened up to mobile customers. One of the factors stopping this in the past was the lack of a quality of service protocol in existing hotspots. Now, with dual-mode handsets due out from Nokia, Samsung, Motorola and others by first quarter 2006, if there is not enough bandwidth at a hotspot, the load will seamlessly fall back onto the mobile operator without disrupting calls.
This means that expanded Wi-Fi activities and, in future, WiMAX services ‘ possibly also in conjunction with Sprint ‘ are on the cards for the cablecos. By doing the deal jointly, these players have kept some of the leverage in their own hands and can speak with one voice when ordering for Sprint services. US cable operators rarely compete with each other anyway due to the fact that they are based on original exclusive licenses and have minor areas of service overlap. But this may eventually come back to bite them. If this MVNO deal is successful, then there could be some antitrust issues here. It’s unlikely that Comcast can collude to keep all mobile customers in its region for itself, and there may eventually be a need for some FCC statement here about competition within the membership of such an MVNO.
But these are not insurmountable problems and the potential of further churn reduction in a quadruple play (or is it a quintuple play if we count hotspots?) over a triple play, should make this the most significant telecommunications step in the US since the invention of broadband.
However, one problem that will keep this deal on ice for at least a few months are the technical issues of offering integrated services across varying infrastructures. The cable operators operate very little of their networks in pure internet protocol, and an integration strategy will need to be adopted for this (will the 3GPP Internet Multimedia Subsystem, for instance, operate on a cable network to integrate services). Telcos and cellcos can interoperate using IMS and create services such as videoconferencing, fairly simply across mobile and fixed lines, but the same for cable will require a whole host of new technical compromises. Billing is perhaps the first thing that needs to be integrated and expect flat rate billing bundles to be the first approach that the cable operators try once this deal is finally announced and begins to get off the ground.
We would also expect to see Europeans follow this lead immediately with copycat moves from either Liberty Global, NTL or Premiere in the next six months. France Telecom already owns Orange, so is less likely to move the same way and British Telecom already operates an MVNO with Vodafone in the UK. Cablevision, the fourth largest US cable operator, which tends to be something of a loner compared to the others, will either be invited to join the party or will look for something similar of its own in short order.
BOX
The cable companies are stepping up their interest in wireless networking in other directions too, including through investments in potentially valuable technologies. Last week, Comcast’s venture arm, Comcast Interactive Capital, took the lead in a $20m Series C round of funding into BelAir Networks, one of the leading providers of Wi-Fi mesh systems for metrozones. While rival start-up Tropos has gained higher profile in the larger US metrozone projects, partnering with Earthlink and Google among other providers, BelAir is seeking to remedy that imbalance by growing close to the cable operators, and has released two products for cablecos, featuring an interface to the cable standard DOCSIS 2.0.
The new funding for BelAir, which brings its total to date to $44m (with McLean Watson Capital and existing investors also contributing), is expected to be heavily focused on improving the cable integration, potentially creating a platform that would enable the cablecos ‘ like ISPs such as Earthlink or cellcos like T-Mobile ‘ to control rather than compete with public access metrozones, and to offer new bundles to their customers, with hotspot access included, a proven method of reducing churn.
BelAir also introduced two carrier grade mesh products for multiple system operators (MSOs) and cable operators that feature a DOCSIS (data over cable service interface specification) 2.0 interface. DOCSIS is the format typically used for cable network transmissions.
The new BelAir50 and BelAir100 radios can be installed anywhere in an existing cable network. BelAir50 is a single radio node for a mesh network that uses 802.11g technology. It supports Wi-Fi client access and wireless backhaul in the 2.4GHz band. BelAir100 is a two radio wireless mesh switch that adds point-to-point backhaul capability using 5GHz.