Allied Telesyn plans to bring its mobile IP hand-off technology, already available in Asia, to Europe and the US, claiming superior support for unbroken voice over WLan to other approaches including the recently ratified 802.11e quality of service extension for the Wi-Fi standard.
Although the IEEE 802.11 taskgroups and Wi-Fi Alliance are working on further extensions for fast hand-off between access points when users are on the move, allowing for unbroken voice or video calls, this work will not be completed for up to a year. In the meantime, various proprietary approaches are available, such as Meru’s QoS-optimized enterprise Wi-Fi switch system, but efficient mobile IP remains one of the key technical hurdles to the dreams of making Wi-Fi or WiMAX a fully mobile system to the same extent as the cellular technologies.
Telesyn’s solution was developed by Japanese company Root and acquired by Allied Telesis Holdings KK earlier this year. The system is based on Root’s proprietary Layer 3 Roaming technology and it hands off IP connections in wireless networks in similar way to GSM or CDMA systems, allowing ‘ assuming enough access points and an on-train mobile router are in place ‘ unbroken voice and video streaming at vehicular speeds (at a claimed maximum of 300 kilometers an hour, a theory unlikely to be tested in the real world).
It will work with any access technology such as Wi-Fi or WiMAX. The WiMAX Forum is working towards a high mobility implementation of the 802.16e standard, but this will initially support speeds of less than 80 kilometers per hour. Another IEEE standards group, 802.20 or Mobile-Fi, has been working on high speed mobility but this effort has been largely overshadowed by WiMAX’ shift into the mobile arena. Initially, Telesyn will mainly target its solution at operators that have made an investment in Wi-Fi which they need to preserve while adding mobile functionality. Such hybrid solutions could provide an alternative to the wait for 802.16e, or work with it in future.
The system is being tested in the Hong Kong subway and on a high speed train route between Singapore’s downtown and airport. Allied Telesyn is also conducting trials with several undisclosed city carriers in Scandinavia and Germany, and is in talks to pilot the technology with a large European waste management company.
Key components of the system are the home agent server, which keeps track of the moving objects as they move between access points and runs hand-off, plus the authentication server.
Such innovations will be important to addressing some of the limitations of IP networks in a highly mobile environment, which can afflict 802.16e and other platforms, and meeting these challenges will be essential to the success of future networks, whether mobile WiMAX or the increasingly IP-centric 3GPP2 cellular roadmap. High speed agents are one of the most important approaches, as explored by Root.
IP was not devised for mobility and has problems in that environment because its identifiers and addresses are the same, used both to identify the user and deliver the packets. One aspect cannot be changed without altering the other. This is fine in a fixed environment but makes it hard to track moving users, a process that slows down routing through the network, leading to inefficiencies.
The main solution to date has been the Mobile IP protocol as defined by the IETF standards body, and which was first deployed by Motorola and Nextel in their iDEN network. It is now extensively used in enterprise networks and in CDMA ‘ hence the more advanced stage of CDMA, compared to the GSM technologies, in supporting VoIP over cellular. In Mobile IP, the client keeps track of its original address and also has a ‘care-of’ address assigned to it as it moves through the network. The Mobile IP Home Agent keeps track of both and sets up IP tunnels to forward the packet, without the hosts or intervening infrastructure needing to be aware of the process.
The main downside of Mobile IP is that it is relatively slow. Companies are working on fast mobility agents, which use local tunnelling to speed things up, but some scientists at the large mobile vendors are arguing that, ultimately, a whole new routing protocol should be devised to optimize performance in future networks, especially those supporting video and television. So far, research into new router alternatives has been limited, but it will be necessary to reduce encumbrances on the IP networks.