Research in Motion has clung on to its market leadership, and its high valuation, for far longer than most pioneers manage, and often apparently against all odds. But now its days as the dominant force in corporate mobile email must surely be numbered, with Nokia and Microsoft both bringing out their sharpest weapons to take over a market that promises huge growth, as well as being the key foundation stone of the broader wireless enterprise. Nokia agreed last week to acquire push email specialist Intellisync, with a price tag of $430m that demonstrates how vital this market is to the Finnish giant’s pursuit of the mobile enterprise sector. And both Microsoft and Nokia are starting to offer aggressive pricing on corporate email systems, promising ‘a new economics’ that a specialist company cannot hope to match, let alone one with the interminable legal wranglings that still afflict RIM.
RIM made a smart move a couple of years ago when it agreed to license its server-based push email software independently of its BlackBerry devices, and appeared to have a real shot at setting a de facto standard for mobile email, with most of the major handset makers joining the BlackBerry Connect program and even Microsoft opening a gate into its monolithic Windows world with support for BlackBerry clients from Exchange. In the mean time, the BlackBerry PDAs themselves survived far better than anticipated, even breaking into some key European carriers such as T-Mobile from their largely North American base.
But various factors will prevent RIM making BlackBerry into a standard, licensed by all. The most obvious is the ongoing uncertainty created by the patent lawsuits, particularly the battle with NTP (see inset), which has threatened to end in an injunction against BlackBerry sales in the US. Although Nokia has licensed the patents in question from NTP, many other licensees have not, and the threat of legal action and additional costs has undoubtedly been a brake on third party launches of BlackBerry services.
Even more importantly, Nokia and Microsoft ‘ in particular ‘ have no desire to rely long term on a third party product for a technology that is so critical to their strategies. Sales of homegrown server software will generate greater revenue and greater account control. Microsoft is defending its enterprise turf as the large corporations start to mobilize their activities, and pushing Windows and .Net as the key middleware platforms to support a wireless enterprise. Nokia, for its part, aims to snatch a large share of the territory occupied by the PC for the smartphone and, beyond that, to offer a full mobile enterprise solution, gaining control itself of the server software and middleware. In as many as 90% of cases, broad mobilization programs within large companies begin with wireless email, the simplest and most readily justifiable application, which then provides the launchpad for a wider range of functions based on mobile web services and service oriented architectures. In other words, the company that controls the email middleware has a strong chance of controlling the whole wireless system as it evolves over the coming years.
With so much at stake, Nokia and Microsoft needed either to buy RIM or sideline it, and the former option, though often rumored, would bring with it the baggage of patent lawsuits. And both companies are in a strong position to render RIM irrelevant over time. The qualities that once put BlackBerry ahead of the rest of the market have been matched and even overtaken by other offerings. Its economics are looking increasingly unattractive. And Nokia and Microsoft both have the market weight and the broad range of products to create a full enterprise platform that RIM could not attempt on its own.
And although RIM’s market share in an immature market has been impressive enough to attract the big names to license its software, in terms of the potential user base it has only a small showing that could easily dwindle, making BlackBerry Connect an interim solution for most of the large players while they assembled their own offering. Although BlackBerry accounts for about half the world’s corporate mobile email accounts, these are currently numbered at only 1% of the whole corporate email sector ‘ and Nokia and Microsoft are after the other 99%.
So Nokia, fresh from launching its Business Centre system in September, promising ‘mobile email for the masses’, has now snapped up Intellisync for $430m, gaining a server platform that can communicate with a wide variety of client devices including BlackBerry and interoperate with other key email servers, notably Exchange. As with Business Centre, the software will not be confined to Nokia phones but will further the Finnish company’s aim of setting software standards across multiple platforms in a bid for Microsoft’s middleware territory.
Intellisync has focused on delivering turnkey solutions to carriers, rather than marketing directly to the enterprise. It lies at the heart of Verizon Wireless’ recently announced BroadbandAccess service on EV-DO, which includes the Intellisync push email service. Although Verizon offers BlackBerry support as an option, it aims to provide a superior offering through Intellisync for those companies not wedded to BlackBerry software ‘ a sign of why RIM is in such a bad situation. Verizon’s offering includes Wireless Sync Workgroup, which offers push email, calendar and personal information to as many as 20 users and can synchronize between PCs running Microsoft Exchange or Lotus Domino, and the Palm PDA or smartphone.
The Wireless Sync Enterprise Server provides the same services for larger enterprises with thousands of users. It also offers device management tools, including the ability to disable handsets if they are lost or stolen via over-the-air software commands.
Nokia’s self-confessed aim is to ‘bridge the gap between the world’s 650m corporate email accounts and the elite of only 10m or so who have mobile access to their business email inboxes’ ‘ another indication of how small RIM’s market grip really is.
And Nokia has the ability to be very flexible on its pricing. Although it will continue to support BlackBerry where required, the two-year old agreement is clearly not set to take center stage in the Nokia enterprise strategy. ‘We have a contract with them, and we will support them when we see fit,’ said Nokia CEO Jorma Ollila.
But the world’s largest cellphone maker is virtually giving away wireless corporate email services to customers who deploy its Business Center server, in a bid for market share that will drive handset sales as well as future expansion of the corporate systems into other areas of mobility. ‘We’re making such a big leap with a different architecture that it enables different economics,’ Ollila said at the Intellisync announcement.
RIM is increasingly disadvantaged by its pricing, and will need to address that. Once, it was justified by the increased ARPU that its email software typically generates for operators, but that is being matched by rival applications now, with lower costs for carriers and enterprises. A 20-user license for BlackBerry Enterprise Server is around $5,000.
A standard version of the Business Centre will cost €1,800 for a server licence. Each licence covers 400 people. The Professional version of Nokia’s new software requires the purchaser to pay an additional one-time fee, per user, of €55, which includes a perpetual licence for each office worker. This compares to Blackberry’s cost-per-user, which work out two to four times more expensive.
Microsoft is taking a similar approach, offering free upgrades to corporate customers using its Exchange Server 2003 for Outlook software (a potential base of about 126m email accounts). ‘There is no additional cost, no middleware, no service fee. The only thing that might come up is a new device running Windows Mobile 5.0,’ said Microsoft Windows Mobile European product manager Hardy Poppinga.
Both giants are opening up their server software to third party devices in their quest to become a corporate standard at the back end. Microsoft has licensed its ActiveSync protocol, which allows handsets to synchronize information with Exchange servers over the air, to Nokia, Symbian, PalmOne and others, and it now supports BlackBerry clients. This protocol was also licensed by PalmOne. Microsoft’s main aim is to strengthen Exchange and its core technologies, like .Net Compact Framework web services, in the mobile enterprise, rather than to seize control of the email end devices.
These strategies, and the head-to-head they will create between Microsoft and its Finnish challenger, could still produce a highly priced acquisition bid for RIM. But in its heyday, RIM was so overvalued that potential predators looked elsewhere, to build a platform based on buying one or more of the multitude of push email specialists in operation. And now it is starting to lose its advantages, with Nokia and Microsoft eyeing a huge email base that they believe is ready to mobilize, but which has no legacy commitment to BlackBerry. RIM has created a market and the popularity of its devices will keep generating loyalty and new enterprise or carrier deals for a while, but its day in the sun is over.
BOX
Last week, RIM told its shareholders to reject a mini-tender offer from TRC Capital to purchase up to 0.5% of RIM’s outstanding shares. TRC offered to buy up to $1m of the shares for $57.91 each, an almost 3% discount from the November 1 closing price of $59.61. TRC has a history of mini-tender offers, and is clearly looking to get a piece of RIM on the cheap.
RIM co-CEO Jim Balsillie claims to have a ‘workaround’ that would skirt the NTP patents at the center of the patent case, and that would be completed soon. ‘Our customers can be calm that there won’t be an interruption of service,’ he said.
NTP successfully sued RIM in 2002 over infringement of its patents and won an injunction in 2003 to halt US sales of the BlackBerry and shut down RIM’s services in the US. That injunction was stayed pending appeal. An appeals court in August scaled back the ruling against RIM, but upheld some patent infringement claims. The case has now moved back to the court where it was first heard. NTP has said it wants the injunction reimposed. RIM wants the court to enforce a disputed $450m settlement reached in March that fell apart in June.
The US Patent and Trademark Office earlier this year completed a re-examination of eight NTP patents and issued initial rulings rejecting all eight patents. This could lead to a strange situation where RIM is found guilty of infringing patents that NTP is eventually ruled not to own (though the Patent Office process could take some years to complete).
Judge James Spencer said it is not likely he will delay the NTP patent case against RIM in order to wait for a verdict from the Patent Office. A settlement is once again likely, but the $450m original deal could be inflated to up to $1bn, according to analysts. This would not kill RIM, which has $1.2bn in cash and should earn $500m on $2bn revenue this financial year, but it would be a major blow combined with increased competition from powerful challengers.