Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 November 2005

Cisco’s Scientific Atlanta buy could boost its appeal in wireless too

Cisco’s decision to acquire set-top box maker and video systems integrator Scientific Atlanta (SFA), for $6.9bn, has more wireless connotations that at first met the eye.

As when it made the far less strategic acquisition of Denmark’s television and DVD maker Kiss earlier this year, we may question why Cisco wants actually to own the end user devices, when its dominance of IP networks gives it serious influence over the makers of IP-supported electronics gear anyway.

On the surface, the SFA deal was about a broader overall strategy of extending Cisco’s consumer business, and potentially its influence over service providers. Its core enterprise market, while going through a major shift to IP convergence that should greatly benefit the doyen of IP routers, does not have the growth potential of the other two sectors. The carriers’ convergence moves, and the fact that they are often adopting IP for the first time, present an opportunity that dwarfs that of the corporate sector ‘ although one Cisco has not, so far, been exploiting very effectively.

And the consumer market is increasingly the key driver for new communications technologies ‘ look at the way it has demanded ever faster Wi-Fi platforms, while the enterprise sector has been sluggish in embracing wireless networks. That fact made the acquisition of Linksys ‘ the first Cisco purchase to be allowed to retain its own brand and operating identity, a pattern that will be repeated SFA ‘ a stroke of genius underestimated at the time. True, the consumer market nibbled into the Cisco margin, but it allowed the giant to consolidate a strong market lead in WLans by exploiting the real growth area, at a time when companies that had banked on the enterprise wireless space, like Proxim, were falling into trouble. And now Cisco will use Linksys to spearhead expansion into another growth market where it has never been strong, the small and medium business (SMB) ‘ a sector that could not be attacked with Cisco-branded products for fear of eroding their price and credibility in the corporate world too.

It is less obvious that Cisco needs a set-top box, any more than a Kiss flat screen TV, to help spread into broader markets. But SFA is more than a box maker, and is expert in video distribution, a strength that could be incorporated into Cisco’s core IP technologies to make them more attractive to the consumer and the triple play carrier. On the consumer front, the SFA set-top and Linksys WLan can be integrated ‘ increasingly, consumer Wi-Fi is sold embedded in other devices, not just PCs or dedicated access points ‘ to produce a home platform that could be augmented in future with other technologies in which Cisco takes an interest, such as UltraWideBand fast media networks.

For carriers, CEO John Chambers made the case as he announced the deal. ‘Video is emerging as the key strategic application in the service provider triple play bundle of consumer entertainment, communication and online services,’ he said. ‘The combination of Cisco and Scientific-Atlanta brings unmatched experience and innovation in delivering large scale video systems and networks, and the addition of Scientific-Atlanta further extends Cisco’s leadership in the service provider market. Moreover, Cisco’s international presence and IP leadership will also create strategic synergies that accelerate the combined growth opportunity.’

It’s true that SFA is a beginner outside of the US, and Cisco can probably help here. It is already being called upon in many IPTV rollouts for core router capabilities, so why not, it argues, push the rest of the IPTV offering, and, like Microsoft and Alcatel, go end-to-end. Also filling a gap in the end-to-end triple play is the completion of the acquisition of VoIP provisioner Digital Fairway last week.

However, SFA currently derives almost all of its revenue from the cable TV community, not IPTV, although it has a piece of the SBC Communications contract to introduce IPTV to 18m Americans. And cable is still a long way from being fundamentally IP driven. But Cisco will be a handy helper once cable decides to go down that route, especially as it becomes more serious about IPTV and the major telco market. Many IPTV systems are ultimately routed by Cisco gear, of course, and at the IBC conference earlier this year it told us that it is now prepared to configure its core routers to be asynchronous to support wired or wireless networks that are laboring in getting video traffic out to the edge, rather than traveling equally fast in both directions. Cisco said then that it pictured a world where its Carrier Routing System (CRS 1) is configured with a kind of super head end behind it, delivering dynamic multicasts throughout the internet and caching them at key points.

Given that one of the key elements that SFA makes are those head ends, the part of an IPTV system that receives satellite feeds and recompresses and cleans them, and then sends them on their way, all in real time, the SFA deal seems to fit in with this view.

Apart from the synergies with Linksys in the home market and with the central IP equipment in carrier land, there is another Cisco activity that may blend comfortably with SFA’s boxes and video systems. This is the recently announced mesh system, with which Cisco is looking to revive its current metro network market and push out a string of start-ups in the increasingly high profile municipal metrozone space. Mesh has been seen as a simple and relatively inexpensive way for cable operators to expand their wired networks, as well as to offer access to mobile services without investing in a 3G network or MVNO deal, through bundling subscriptions to hotspots and citywide hotzones.

‘Wi-Fi mesh technology offers new service and revenue opportunities for the cable industry,” said Phil Belanger, vice president of marketing at mesh specialist BelAir Networks, recently. The company has created a cable-ready node supporting the DOCSIS 2.0 cable interface that can be installed anywhere in existing networks, allowing operators to use their cable plant to deploy Wi-Fi networks for municipal networks, campuses, multiple dwelling units and other sites that are expensive to cover with cable itself.

Another mesh player, Tropos, actually has a partnership with SFA on similar lines, and is working with the set-top maker to adapt its MetroMesh routers so that the Wi-Fi can be plugged into a hybrid fiber-coax (HFC) cable system. Like the BelAir project, this move is mainly aimed at allowing cablecos to penetrate the municipal wireless market in the same way that ISPs like Earthlink are doing.

These municipal networks are becoming important as the basis of a new approach to telecoms, allowing companies to offer voice and data services without access to landlines or cellular spectrum, as Google’s proposal to build the San Francisco network illustrates. The metrozones are also attracting significant funding for public safety and other municipal activities such as traffic management. Therefore, this is a market, once seen as marginal, that Cisco can no longer ignore, and a third growth area in which its new acquisition may prove a useful lever.