Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

Qualcomm shifts its focus to content delivery to keep core customers

Korea has always been critical to Qualcomm’s fortunes, but just as Samsung and the major operators once helped establish CDMA as a major technology, recently it has seemed that the Koreans could also be the US chip designer’s nemesis, as they focus on their own platforms such as Wi-Bro/WiMAX, the T-DMB mobile television system and the WIPI content environment. But whatever happens in its patent battles, it is hard to write off Qualcomm’s technologies, and while it battles its enemies in the intellectual property law courts, it is also scoring points in key markets for some of its most important new systems. Brew, its content aggregation and delivery platform, is the key spearhead to take Qualcomm into unfamiliar territories such as Europe, where it recently scored a breakthrough deal with O2. Brew is also looking like a way to keep its feet in Korea, along with another technology that is not dependent on CDMA, the Media-FLO mobile television network, reflecting how Qualcomm, like its customers, is becoming increasingly oriented towards content delivery rather than pure networking.

The Korean operators and vendors developed their own alternative to Brew, WIPI, in 2003 as a move to reduce royalties. In April 2004 all three mobile operators said they would adopt the platform. The Seoul government had been seeking to mandate WIPI but held back on a decision under pressure from the US administration, which had complained that the selection of a single national standard would prevent Qualcomm from competing and would break trade agreements. At that time, Brew was the main content platform in Korea, with 32m users, and KTF alone was estimated to pay $2m-$3m a year in Brew royalties. This is already being eroded and now Qualcomm is seeking to regain some ground by promising a version of Brew to run on top of WIPI. While this would be somewhat cheaper for the operators ‘ cutting the royalty payment at least in half ‘ it would preserve the technology’s position in the market, especially important as Qualcomm now positions it as a major springboard for increased influence in operator accounts. KTF is keen to adopt Brew on WIPI, suggesting that the homegrown technology has failed to keep pace with Qualcomm’s recent aggressive enhancement of its own platform to meet many key operator requirements such as highly customizable interfaces, user-defined navigation and multimedia delivery.

The other area where the functionality of Qualcomm’s technologies, and their appeal to many operators, could outweigh resentment at its licensing strategies, is in mobile television, where the FLO system is widely credited with being more advanced in user experience terms than its rivals. As Nokia is reported to be infiltrating China, widely expected to use T-DMB, with its alternative DVB-H mobile TV system (see separate item), Qualcomm is getting close to the second largest Korean cellco, KTF, which says it is considering using FLO (or possibly DVB-H). Given recent outspoken statements from Korean majors against Qualcomm’s notorious royalties charges, it would be a major coup for the US company to sign up a Korean customer, especially as it has already won over the US’ Verizon Wireless for FLO.

KTF, in which Qualcomm is a shareholder, and which was the first adopter in the world of Brew, would face opposition to its choice from the government, which is set on reducing the country’s royalty burden to US suppliers, and which wants to establish its favored terrestrial DMB system around the world. Indeed, it is possible that KTF is talking up its interest in FLO in order to put pressure on the government to make policies on spectrum and pricing for mobile TV that would be more attractive to operators. TJ Chae, KTF’s strategy planning director, said recently: ‘It doesn’t make sense that the government demands mobile carriers to cooperate unconditionally to its DMB policies in the name of national interest. We are considering the adoption of Qulacomm’s FLO or Nokia’s DVB-H in line with meeting global standards.’ He claimed the T-DMB business model would not bring any profits to mobile carriers.

A more certain win, and another that has been won in the teeth of rival bids from DV-H, is with Verizon Wireless, which will announce a mobile video and television service over Qualcomm’s 700MHz MediaFlo network in the US next year and expects to offer the services in around half its CDMA EV-DO territories. It will be the first US carrier to use the MediaFlo network to deliver television, although Sprint Nextel is also widely expected to adopt the system (Verizon had been toying with DVB-H, and using the network being built by Nokia and Crown Castle. Since this is, like MediaFLO, technology independent, this remains an option for Sprint Nextel). Being the first adopter will bring many benefits, allowing Verizon to take the key role in deciding future directions for the MediaFLO network. The company said it would work with its partner to ‘determine which markets will get the MediaFLO services first’ ‘ which will mainly be those already established with its 3G EV-DO network and with multimedia services such as the streaming video offering VCast. However, MediaFlo could also be used to take mobile video to markets where there is high demand but EV-DO has not yet been deployed, since it is an independent network.

The main uncertainty in terms of launch timing is that Qualcomm needs to existing TV broadcasters to vacate Channel 55 in the 700MHz spectrum that it has licensed, something it will probably negotiate during 2006 in return for carrying local broadcasters’ programming such as public interest, news, weather and public affairs bulletins. But a major operator deal will certainly ease the process of signing up more big name content partners such as film studios.

On the royalties front, Qualcomm has a harder job winning friends, and once again, Korea is set to be the key battleground. The country’s major handset makers, Samsung, LG and Pantech, claim their 1993 contracts for CDMA patents will expire in August 2006 and they will no longer be subject to royalties charges. Korean manufacturers were the first to sign up for CDMA and so are looking to free themselves of the charges at an early stage. They pay the US company 5.8% of phone prices and 5.3% of local sales, according to the Korean government, which estimates that Korean companies have paid Qualcomm $964m since 1997.

Steven Altman, Qualcomm’s president, defended the royalties model in a speech last week, claiming it actually stimulates competition in the handset sector. “I find it hard to believe 130 companies would agree to sign our patents if they weren’t fair and reasonable,” he said, adding that the company has 60 agreements with companies for its W-CDMA technology and 130 overall.

Altman denied that Qualcomm’s business practices have harmed the market for 3G handsets, asserting that handset prices have fallen dramatically over the past year as competitors from regions like Korea and China have used Qualcomm’s technology to position themselves in the W-CDMA market. He noted that some 3G handsets were sold for as little as $124, in limited volumes, compared to around $436 in 2003. He also talked up the company’s claims to have fundamental technology in W-CDMA and its upgrade HSDPA. “W-CDMA is CDMA, not W-GSM. It’s based on a lot of the fundamental technology that Qualcomm invented,” he said, also claiming that HSDPA is partly derived from CDMA EV-DO technology. Qualcomm collects royalties of 4-5% on the wholesale price of a W-CDMA handset.

Qualcomm will continue to maintain its patents claims and seek to extend its intellectual property reach to new areas such as China’s TD-SCDMA, HSDPA and even enhanced GSM. In all these areas, its cases rest on its pioneering efforts in data and multimedia over cellular networks, which are becoming the key growth engines for cellcos and handset makers. As such, it will attract rising levels of hostility with its policies, as it stakes claims over areas far outside its CDMA heartland. It also shows Qualcomm planning for a future when it will almost certainly have to reduce its royalty percentages ‘ though probably after a protracted battle with the EU and others ‘ and when CDMA will start to lose overall market share in the pre-4G world. By that time, though, we will have seen another transformation in the company, one powered by technology as much as patents ‘ making content delivery, rather than physical networks, the heart of the strategy.

BOX: The FLO Forum standard

Just as Qualcomm starts to score wins for its MediaFLO network and the FLO (Forward Link Only) OFDM-based technology that supports, it the FLO Forum ‘ the industry group backing the would-be standard ‘ has ratified its air interface specification (AIS).

This will allow for future testing and certification of multivendor FLO systems and devices for interoperability, an important step in attracting operator uptake.

The AIS includes a complete description of the physical layer, which uses OFDM and advanced forward error correction techniques, and a complete description of the stream/control and media access control (MAC) layers.

The technology enables the delivery of multiple multimedia streams over the standard TV channel bandwidths while ensuring robust performance in mobile fading links, and low terminal power consumption. The AIS will be forwarded to standards development organizations for inclusion in new international standards.

But Qualcomm has denied claims in Korea Times that some companies would not need to pay royalties after 2006. Qualcomm said in a statement that there is no date on which a license under all of Qualcomm’s patents becomes royalty free.