Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 December 2005

Samsung and Sprint sued over patents

Many aspects of the increasingly heated battle over wireless patents are simply ridiculous, with companies seeking to exploit all kinds of formerly obscure intellectual property. Latest on the bandwagon is a holdings operation called Lavaflow, which is claiming no less than the patent for the clamshell handset design and the touchscreen interface that is fundamental to every smartphone.

The company, owned by John and Christina King, has slapped a lawsuit on Samsung and Sprint Nextel, claiming that it holds a patent for a “foldable wireless communication device functioning as a cellular telephone and a personal digital assistant” and a “cellular telephone having a touch screen user interface’. In particular, the Kings have singled out Samsung’s i500 smartphone.

The Kings seem to have a weaker case than most ‘ they filed their two patents with the US Patents and Trademarks Office in December 2002, four months after the FCC approved Samsung’s i500. The i500 was a landmark model, but was not the first clamshell with a touchscreen ‘ the Kyocera PDQ, also mentioned in the Kings’ filing, though not the subject of a suit as yet, came earlier, for one.