Qualcomm has finally joined the Wi-Fi Alliance, the industry organization that promotes and certifies the Wi-Fi standards. This is the culmination of a gradual progression towards supporting the WLan platform, which the chipmaker once vocally criticized, and reflects its need to sustain the future of its core CDMA architectures by ensuring integration with other technologies that operators are favoring. It also raises the issue of whether Qualcomm will seek to dominate the Wi-Fi roadmap as it has that of 3G, and to gain patent rights in this market.
Qualcomm’ attitudes to Wi-Fi have largely reflected those of its key customer base, the CDMA operators. Wi-Fi was initially seen as a threat by the cellcos because it could support semi-mobile VoIP, eating into cellular voice revenues and rates by allowing users to make low cost calls from hotspots. This danger intensified with the prospect of whole urban areas being blanketed with WLan coverage. Some major Verizon customers, notably Verizon Wireless, remain resistant to the need to support integrated 3G and Wi-Fi, claiming the limitations in coverage and mobility of WLans outweigh the attractions for high value users. But most cellcos have accepted the demand for dual-mode handsets and the move towards supporting multiple networks, and Qualcomm must follow suit to keep CDMA attractive. Plus, technologies such as UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) allow wireline carriers to offer converged fixed-mobile services, opening up the possibility of broadening markets for Qualcomm’s handset chips to a new class of providers.
By embracing Wi-Fi rather than resisting it, Qualcomm can ensure that it retains the lead in dual-mode CDMA/Wi-Fi handsets and, as it builds up its W-CDMA business, in that side of 3G too. In CDMA, it is in an unparalleled position to understand how to integrate that technology and allow it to interoperate with other networks, and so can keep out other would-be entrants to the sector such as Texas Instruments. And in W-CDMA, where its chip sales are low to date, it will need to be highly competitive in the elements operators are demanding, such as incorporating Wi-Fi and 3G capabilities into single-chip or very compact, low power packages.
This will be essential to allow it to challenge other chipmakers with expertise in Wi-Fi, such as Broadcom, which sees the rising need for dual-mode architectures as a way to translate its huge success in 802.11 into the cellular market, where it has fared less well. This provides a key context for the ongoing legal battle between Qualcomm and Broadcom, with the latter alleging unfair business practises and antitrust against the CDMA giant. Broadcom, which has a real chance of significantly increasing its market share through dual-mode activities, is keen to keep Qualcomm and its aggressive tactics out of the W-CDMA and dual-radio markets.
It is significant, then, that among the tit-for-tat patent infringement lawsuits that Qualcomm has brought against its challenger this year, is one that is not related to CDMA but to Wi-Fi. The company is seeking to broaden its patents business to cover more technology bases, no doubt knowing that, eventually, it will be forced to pull back the levels of royalties it can charge on its core intellectual property. Therefore it has recently staked royalties claims in GSM and other areas that involve delivering data over mobile networks, the main area in which Qualcomm claims technological pre-eminence. There is speculation that it will also start to make similar demands in the OFDM world, through its acquisition of the Flarion Flash-OFDM platform and intellectual property, and in Wi-Fi.
It will almost certainly seek to assert intellectual property control over how Wi-Fi and other networks interoperate with CDMA-based technologies ‘ the heart of the patent it is disputing with Broadcom.
“Those who believe that Qualcomm’s intellectual property portfolio is limited to CDMA have overlooked the breadth of our business activity and the extent of our research and development from which our intellectual property is generated,” said Louis Lupin, senior vice president and general counsel for Qualcomm, in a statement at the time the complaint was filed against Broadcom. “Our intellectual property rights are broad, and we will not hesitate to assert their full breadth when appropriate.”
Qualcomm’s intensified involvement in Wi-Fi, then, while a credibility boost for the technology in the mobile world, may also prove a doubled-edged sword, putting new pressures on vendors and chipmakers already suffering under spiralling pricing and over-competition. It is not surprising though ‘ the company’s involvement in Wi-Fi has been increasing for over a year.
Last summer, Qualcomm incorporated WLan into its mobile chipsets. It said its Mobile Station Modem chipsets would support Philips Electronics’ Wlan module, which was designed to be one of the lowest power options on the market and so suited to handsets and other space-constrained devices. The company said the offering would allow handset makers to combine 802.11b and 802.11g with either CDMA2000 or W-CDMA technology.
The chipmaker had also submitted its own proposal to the IEEE for consideration as the basis of the upcoming 802.11n fast Wi-Fi standard. This was rejected and it took its support ‘ and presumably its potential patent claims ‘ to one of the two major factions, the TGn Sync group led by Intel and others. The unusual sight of Intel and Qualcomm on the same side was short-lived, with the larger company forming, with Broadcom and others, a breakaway initiative called Enhanced Wireless Consortium that could seek to bypass the IEEE altogether. One of the side effects, should the EWC be successful but remain outside the bounds of the IEEE, would be to create a standards platform with no Qualcomm involvement once again, an outcome that would go against the very grain of the CDMA leader’s business model.