Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

19 December 2005

Vodafone buys Telsim, as cellco ambitions shift to Middle East and west Asia

Saturation in traditional mobile voice markets, new competition from IP-based operators and the slower than hoped growth of cellular data revenues are all driving large cellcos to seek new markets, and moving the key battlefields away from the European Union, North America, Korea and Japan towards the Middle East, Africa and central Asia. These previously obscure markets, largely neglected by the international players, are becoming attractive because of their growing economies and high expansion potential, as illustrated by Vodafone’s decision to buy Turkish operator Telsim.

Vodafone may be shifting its geographical sights ‘ with recent ventures in eastern Europe and Africa signalling a change in the old strategy of being number one in all established cellular markets ‘ but it will not go unchallenged, and in many areas it will come up against unfamiliar competitors. While its traditional rivals, such as Deutsche Telekom/T-Mobile and NTT DoCoMo, are also looking towards new territories, there is a new breed of would-be international giant mobilizing from emerging economies such as Russia, South Africa and Turkey itself. Often well funded and aggressive, these will be the new tigers of the cellular market, aiming to gain a headstart in immature markets that will start to drive 3G growth around the turn of the decade.

Vodafone shareholders reacted with their usual nervousness at news of the Telsim purchase, for which the cellco paid $4.55bn, beating off five other bidders (four from the Middle East, MTC, Etisalat, Orascom and Emaar, plus Russia’s Sistema). Far from applauding a brave move into a growth market that will be further enriched should Turkey join the EU, they were scared that this was a return to the mobile giant’s old habits of major acquisitions, especially when Vodafone admitted it would have to spend up to $1bn upgrading the operator’s network, and the share price fell 2% on the news, especially when CEO Arun Sarin said the deal would dilute Vodafone earnings in the short term.

However, despite its chequered past (see inset), Telsim has much to offer. It is Turkey’s second largest mobile carrier and fits firmly into the criteria Sarin outlined with plans to offset slow growth in established markets by chasing operators in Asia, Africa and eastern Europe, with strong growth potential and existing market share. Turkey is an increasingly attractive territory, as shown by the movements of other carriers into its market. For instance, Telef’nica was considering taking a stake in Turk Telecom, while Finland’s TeliaSonera recently upped its interest in leading cellco Turkcell to 64.3% following a deal with Cukurova Group, under which it purchased a 27% stake for $3.1bn (although this deal is under dispute with rival bidder Alfa of Russia). Turkcell has 23.4m subscribers and recently launched one of Europe’s first push to talk services, using Nokia solutions. It is the only Turkish company listed on the New York Stock Exchange and has 70% market share.

Indeed, despite short term challenges of upgrading the network and getting Telsim back on its financial track, the deal is less problematic than those ‘ such as the recent purchase of 10% stake in India’s Bharti ‘ where Vodafone takes a first bite through a minority shareholding. Too often it has then found itself frustrated when it tried to increase the stake, as has happened in France, or stuck with a successful venture but insufficient influence and branding, as in the US.

Now it will be keeping an eye on a new range of potential competitors and/or challengers in its chosen emerging markets. Some carriers to watch:

MegaFon and Altimo, Russia:

Finland’s TeliaSonera and Russia’s Altimo (formerly Alfa) are in dispute over ownership of a 25% stake in Russia’s third cellco, MegaFon, which Altimo – part of the group controlled by Russia’s second richest man, Mikhail Fridman ‘ wants to merge with the number two mobile operator, Vimpelcom, which it controls, to create a market leader and challenge current leader MTS.

Despite the consolidation in the home market, itself one of the fastest growing in the world, MegaFon is also looking to new territories, especially in former Soviet central Asia. Most recently, it said it would bid for Uzbekistan’s mobile operator Buztel-GSM. It is likely to face competition from VimpelCom, which says it is interested in ‘all CIS markets, in every mobile operator that is put for sale.’ A source estimated Buztel’s price at $60m to $70m. Altimo currently controls Buztel, having acquired it from Indonesia’s Bakrie Group a year ago, and will now auction it off. Mobile penetration in Uzbekistan, which has a population of over 26m, amounts to 4%. Reportedly, Buztel’s subscriber base stands at 3,000 people.

Altimo has also accumulated stakes in Ukrainian cellco Kiyivstar and wants Vimpelcom to acquire Ukraine Radio Systems, a move so far blocked by fellow stakeholder Telenor of Norway. The Russian company wants to expand to take a stake in a western multinational, rather than continue to make only piecemeal investments in single-country operators. It formerly suggested swapping its stake in Vimpelcom for a share in Telenor, but this was rejected by the Norwegian government.

MTS, Russia:

Leading Russian cellco MTS is the largest operator in eastern Europe and is also looking east for new subscribers, aiming to create a single brand across Russia, the Ukraine and formerly Soviet Asia.

It recently bought a 51% stake in Kyrgyzstan’s largest mobile operator Bitel for $150m, from Kazakhstan’s Alliance Capital, and it has an option to buy the remaining 49% by the end of 2006. However, it may face challenges from Altimo, following a ruling in April that the Russian group, through a subsidiary, actually owns Bitel. Bitel’s subscriber base stands at over 470,000 people. Bitel controls 87% of the Kyrgyz market, which has penetration of 9%. Kyrgyzstan’s population is 5.1m and Bitel is the only GSM operator with revenue of $22.8m and ARPU of $11 a month.

This brings MTS’ footprint to six countries, in which it always uses its own brand, all of them in the formerly Soviet Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS). The others are Russia, Belarus, Turkmenistan, Ukraine and Uzbekistan. The company now aims to enter all the other CIS states – Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Moldova and Tajikistan. MTS’ subscriber base was 54.11m users at the end of November.

MTN, South Africa:

MTN is smaller than incumbent cellco Vodacom in subscriber numbers but has the highest revenues and profits. The third mobile operator in the country is Celtel.

MTN is determined to expand its presence in and beyond sub-Saharan Africa, a strategy that may have caused its growth to slow in the home market. It recently spent $128m on a 44% share of Botswana’s Mascom and also sees the Middle East as a strong ground to grow its footprint. This led it to acquire a 49% stake in a cellular license in Iran, in a joint venture with IranCell for which it paid almost the whole license fee of $300m. It will also contribute $150m towards equipment costs, showing how badly MTN wanted an early move into this market, where its high bid outmanoeuvred Turkcell, which had already agreed to buy the stake. However, there are high risks in penetrating new markets ‘ the incumbent, TCI, is powerful, and it is likely that IranCell will have to give about 28% of its revenues to the government under the current regulatory regime.

Celtel, South Africa:

Also in South Africa, but looking for a pan-African presence, is Celtel, soon to be acquired by Kuwait’s MTC for $3.4bn.

Celtel provides service in 13 African countries as compared to MTN’s eight and Vodacom’s five and all three aim to gain a number one spot in sub-Saharan Africa, before the international giants get really active in the continent (although that may not be a long grace period, given MTC’s move and Vodafone’s ownership of a stake in Vodacom as a springboard for African expansion). With the riches of MTC behind it, Celtel is now in a strong position to ramp up its ambitions in further countries, though it will also face challenges from the north African operators, looking to move south. Most powerful are Orascom of Egypt, Etisalat of the United Arab Emirates and Orange, which is active in the Saharan states.

Celtel will look to go north in response ‘ it and MTN have both been shortlisted to bid for a 35% stake in Telecom Tunisie and are also known to be interested in getting into Algeria. Celtel has also expressed interest in Libya, Ethiopia and Angola. Celtel has also agreed to acquire a majority stake in Madagascar’s mobile telecom operator, Madacom, for an undisclosed amount.

All this expansionism is pushing up prices – the cost of buying cellular operators in Africa has doubled in the past four years and purchasers are now paying a multiple of eight times ebitda.

Vodafone made the highest sealed bid and then won the short second round bidding process at a televised auction. The reserve price was $2.8bn.

The Middle Eastern players:

Orascom of Egypt, MTC of Kuwait and Etilasat of the United Arab Emirates are all well funded entities looking for international success. Etisalat has mainly shifted into neighboring countries, for instance with its ownership of Saudi Arabia’ second GSM operator Mobily, but its bid for Telsim shows it has more far reaching ambitions.

MTC has purchased South Africa’s previously Dutch-owned Celtel (see above) and has more than 3.3m customers in Kuwait, Bahrain, Jordan, Iraq and Lebanon. It also has a partnership agreement with Vodafone and in Kuwait and Bahrain the company is known as MTC-Vodafone. Including Celtel its user base will be 8.5m.

Another ambitious venture is Egyptian firm Orascom, which earlier this year acquired Wind Telecommunications in Italy from conglomerate Enel in a €12bn ($14.45bn) deal.

Wind was transferred to an investment fund owned by the founder of Orascom Telecom Holdings, Naguib Sawiris, whose idea is to merge Orascom’s African and Middle East holdings to create a pan-Mediterranean telecoms firm. The company also has operations in Pakistan but is narrowing its geographical focus to its core target areas.

For instance, last week it agreed to sell its controlling 65% stake in Congo-based Libertis Telecom for $66.6m in cash. Sawiris said: ‘This transaction will help us concentrate on our core assets in Algeria, Pakistan, Egypt, Tunisia, Iraq & Bangladesh; enabling us to build value and increase returns in our existing assets and in new larger markets.’

Developing nations:

Seeking to lend academic justification to its developing economy plans, Vodafone earlier this year commissioned a London School of Business study on mobile telephony in emerging nations. Some key findings were:

An increase of 10 mobile phones per 100 people boosts GDP growth in the developing world by 0.6% a year.

Between 1995 and 2003, the number of mobile phone users in 55 of the 102 poorer countries in the study surpassed the total fixed line subscribers.

In that same period, mobile phone penetration went from zero to 36% in Albania, zero to 30% in Paraguay, zero to 21% in China and zero to 9% in India.

The United Nations goal of providing 50% of the world’s population with access to a phone by 2015 has already been achieved, a decade early and almost 80% of the people in the world now live within range of a mobile network, with an overall penetration rate of about 40% (in 10 countries penetration is now over 100% because of multiple phone ownership).

Telsim’s history:

Telsim certainly comes with a chequered history. The telco, and other assets of its former owners the Uzan family, were seized by the Turkish Savings Deposit and Investment Fund (SDIF) last year, following the collapse of banks controlled by the Uzans and massive fraud perpetrated by the family. Among those defrauded were Telsim’s main equipment suppliers Motorola and Nokia, which loaned the company $2bn and $1.5bn respectively. Not only did Telsim fail to pay back the money, but it was found in a string of legal actions to have fraudulently induced the vendors to make the loans.

As previously agreed with the SDIF, Nokia will now receive a settlement payment upon completion of the sale of about 7.5% of the purchase price, while Motorola will get a cash payment of $500m and the right to receive 20% of the proceeds from the sale of Telsim assets over $2.5bn. After the completion of the transaction Motorola will receive an extra cash payment of around US$410m.

Greek telecoms integrator Intracom claims it has the right to purchase up to 10% of Telsim from Vodafone but has not yet substantiated these demands, although the UK telco has already hinted that it may make local partnerships as it goes after rapid expansion in Turkey.