Mobile push email, once a niche technology, now lies at the heart of the major vendors’ mobile enterprise strategies, and of an escalating intellectual property war. Thus the long running legal battle between push email market leader RIM and patent hoarder NTP has taken on new significance as larger players race after RIM’s crown.
Because email is most commonly the first step in a corporation’s broader mobile strategy, it is a critical target for vendors seeking to dominate the mobile enterprise, notably Microsoft and Nokia, and some large service providers. These are likely soon to wipe independents, including RIM, out of the picture, and so the small companies are jostling to attract the attention of the majors. In a war that has become deeply bound up with intellectual property and the ability to control the platform by owning the patents, these start-ups need to bring patents to the party as well as proven products.
Nokia recently acquired Intellisync to boost its mobile email offering, and with it various pieces of intellectual property, some of it key to Qualcomm’s rival email system Eudora2Go. Vodafone teamed up with start-up Visto to launch own-branded enterprise email services, and now Visto, seeking to leverage its carrier successes to gain influence on its market beyond its actual size, is engaged in patent related intrigues with NTP and, most ambitiously, has filed a patent lawsuit against Microsoft.
The suit against Microsoft was filed in US District Court in Texas on the same day that Visto licensed NTP’s key patents (despite most of these now being under question by the US Patents and Trademarks office), with NTP taking a stake in the company in return (the patent holder has a similar licensing/equity relationship with another RIM challenger, Good Technology).
Visto alleges that Microsoft violated three patents relating to technology for handling data flowing between servers and mobile devices, technology that has been licensed to Vodafone and other major carriers such as Sprint Nextel. Visto CEO Brian Bogosian said Microsoft is offering its own carrier email technology ‘in blatant disregard for patented intellectual property in this area’. He claims that Visto holds 25 patents related to email remote access, security and synchronization.
Combined with the NTP alliance, this looks like more than one of the frequent opportunistic patent suits that a major like Microsoft faces ‘ such actions against the giant have been encouraged recently by its string of settlements with intellectual property holders such as InterTrust and Burst.com, with payments totalling over $1bn since 2002. Instead this appears to be a double sided attack, weakening RIM still further by adding new support for NTP, and firing a warning shot across Microsoft’s bows as it moves rapidly into mobile enterprise email. The former action could just be another spat between two niche players in the push email space; the latter smacks of behind the scenes influence from larger forces, keen to stop Microsoft in its tracks as it becomes ever more attractive to the large enterprises with its aggressive pricing on mobile Exchange systems.
Visto’s suit seeks unspecified damages and an injunction against the sale of products infringing its patents. The demands are similar to those made by NTP against RIM and the two companies are clearly joining forces to weaken the already embattled mobile email leader. Although the Patents and Trademarks Office (PTO) is questioning the validity of NTP’s patents, in the law courts it is doing well, winning its most recent ruling in the District Court in Virginia and planning to ask the court at a coming hearing to ban BlackBerry sales and email service in the US. NTP lawyer Jim Wallace will argue that the licensing deal with Visto proves that such a ban would not be disastrous for BlackBerry users, who could get services from other providers “who are not stealing but paying’.
RIM responded that Visto was “a small player looking for free publicity through a last minute license with undisclosed terms for patents that have been rejected by the patent office”. It is true that the PTO’s recent judgements, although subject to appeal, increase the urgency behind NTP’s need to win its case in the courts once and for all. The PTO has rejected three core patents in the case in the past week (some for the second time, after NTP brought a revised case before the office). Although the two processes are independent of one another, somewhat illogically, RIM seems to believe that its strengthened patent claims should allow it to pursue a mediated settlement or a court showdown, rather than being forced into accepting NTP terms. With NTP putting itself at the heart of a web of players with powerful friends, however, it is clear that this once obscure battle has taken on a significance far beyond its original scope, and with all players becoming pawns in a war between Nokia, Microsoft, Vodafone and others, the outcome is anything but assured. One thing is clear ‘ the fortunes of RIM, NTP, Visto and Good are no longer the issue, except for their shareholders. This is now a serious battle between the largest names in the mobile industry.
BOX:
NTP and RIM have both recently suggested settlements to their stalemate that were both rejected out of hand. NTP served up settlement solution that called for 5.7% of the BlackBerry service’s expected revenue until 2012, the year NTP’s patents expire. Merrill Lynch estimated that a royalty at that rate could cost RIM up to $900m. NTP said that it proposed the 5.7% solution to RIM, but RIM refused and countered with its own offer, which NTP in term deemed unacceptable. NTP co-founder Dennis Stout said that the settlement amount would exceed $450m, the sum that the two companies had discussed as a settlement price last spring, a deal that subsequently foundered. RIM shareholders have been warned by analysts to prepare for a settlement closer to the $900m figure, especially as NTP still has a round of appeals in the PTO process. RIM claims to have a technology to work around the disputed patents but has failed to provide any details as yet.