Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 January 2006

Sprint Nextel keeps 2.5GHz options open and trials IPWireless mobile TV

Since Sprint Nextel merged and became aggressive about plans to build out its large holdings in 2.5GHz, it has been assumed that these plans would rest on WiMAX. The telco is in close alliances and equipment trials with two pre-WiMAX vendors, Motorola and Samsung, and has development partnerships with Intel and other key 802.16 players. But in the background, Nextel had an ongoing trial of a rival technology, IPWireless’ implementation of the TD-CDMA standard, and now the combined carrier has made an investment in IPWireless just as the vendor announces a system for an application close to Sprint’s heart, mobile television.

A closer relationship between Sprint Nextel and IPWireless would be bad news for various technology factions, particularly in the mobile television market ‘ increasingly seen by large carriers as a killer application, and one where all the major wireless platforms except WiMAX are promoting a different solution. Sprint Nextel recently poured cold water on speculation that it would create or lease a dedicated mobile TV network to complement its 3G offering ‘ using either Qualcomm’s MediaFLO (chosen by Verizon Wireless) or the network being created by Crown Castle/Modeo across the US and supporting the DVB-H (Digital Video Broadcasting-Handheld) standard. It said recently that it planned to use the 2.5GHz spectrum in part to roll out an advanced media services system including television and music, and leveraging its far-reaching joint venture with major cablecos such as Comcast as a leverage for exclusive content. This implied that it would make do with the MobiTV system it currently uses for (fairly limited) broadcast offerings, based on its existing CDMA2000 EV-DO spectrum, until the 2.5GHz network was ready by early 2008. At this point, Sprint Nextel expects to deliver 1Gb of data for $20-$40 per month. Although the strategy may give Verizon a temporary chance to leapfrog Sprint’s position as the first carrier to deliver mobile TV over 3G, Sprint chief operating officer Len Lauer told the WCA conference that he believes the use of the more powerful 2.5GHz network will push its mobile TV offering, when it arrives, ‘two years in advance of the other US carriers’. It will then transition its 3G services as that network gets overcrowded.

Although Lauer said Sprint had not yet chosen a technology to deliver the 2.5GHz service, the deal with IPWireless and the agreement to trial its new mobile TV technology, hard on the heels of his comments, threw the spotlight firmly on TD-CDMA. Also know as UMTS TDD, this is the time division duplex variant of the UMTS standard, which contrasts with the commonly used FDD version by supporting separate uplink and downlink channels and being optimized for broadband data services and full IP. Although in trials and some commercial roll-outs with various operators, mainly in eastern Europe and Japan (where it has dedicated spectrum), TD-CDMA has so far failed to gain significant market traction because of lack of major vendor support. Despite its inherent mobility, most of its early build-outs have been for fixed or portable access, such as the UK Broadband system in the UK.

But IPWireless, which aims to sign up big name backers and transition its business towards licensing rather than systems design, has been working hard to enhance its implementation of TD-CDMA ‘ the only major one on the market ‘ to be both a complement to 3G and an alternative to WiMAX as a broadband wireless system. In recent times it has improved the IP multimedia support and has now created the television platform. Now these efforts have received the endorsement of a $10m investment by Sprint Nextel, to add to an initial $4m made last July. Sprint Nextel is currently trialing TD-CDMA technology in the Washington, DC area for broadband access for laptops, desktops or PDAs; backhaul for enterprise campus; and various interactive multimedia services such as video streaming, online gaming, document collaboration and videoconferencing. (IPWireless has raised more than $200M since its founding in 1999, with lead backers including Bay Partners, Doll Capital Management, Gabriel Venture Partners, GIC Special Investments, JF Shea Venture Capital and Oak Hill Capital Management.)

Barry West, chief technology officer of Sprint Nextel, commented in a statement: “We believe that UMTS TD-CDMA technology holds great promise as a next generation platform for operators globally, especially for mobile broadband and mobile TV applications.’

The television platform from IPWireless is called TDtv and, like its core data offering, works in existing 3G spectrum as well as in broadband wireless bands such as 2.5GHz. As well as initial triallist Sprint Nextel, the vendor claims several European carriers will follow in 1.9GHz 3G bands, presumably including T-Mobile, which is using TD-CDMA to support broadband data offerings, and ease pressure on 3G roll-out, in parts of eastern Europe. IPMobile also plans to trial TDtv in Japan using the 2.010GHz spectrum it recently acquired, and in which TD-CDMA is specified.

The situation highlights the challenges ahead for WiMAX. While $10m is not a major investment by Sprint standards, and a trial certainly does not guarantee that Sprint will chose the IPWireless platform ‘ large equipment suppliers and successful real world performance outside the 3G bands will be two issues ‘ it does make it clear that the carrier is not fully committed to WiMAX for its 2.5GHz roll-out, which will be one of the world’s largest in the band. 802.16e and its backers are going to have to fight for every deal against 3G derivatives and Qualcomm, and there are areas, such as high mobility and mobile television, which are of interest to many carriers and where it has not yet made significant progress. IPWireless, for all its appeal to 3G carriers, looks puny against the massive industry support for 802.16e, but is at least gaining enough profile to create an irritant for WiMAX that may actually stimulate intensified development by important players like Motorola. One thing is sure, as in the early days of the CDMA-GSM debate, Sprint Nextel once again stands in the position of market bellwether and kingmaker.

BOX

TDtv combines TD-CDMA with one of the mobile broadcasting standards, MBMS (Multimedia Broadcast and Multicast Standard) as defined recently by the 3GPP for 3G spectrum, although the technology is also usable in 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz. MBMS multicasts the same signal to thousands of subscribers for optimal spectrum usage. Despite the Sprint effect, IPWireless sees its main opportunity in Europe and Asia as its promise to cellular operators that they can make better use of their existing 3G spectrum to deliver multimedia and broadband data ‘ and so fend off challenges from technologies in other bands such as 3.5GHz. Most European operators hold TDD spectrum that was allocated along with their 3G licenses, but few have used it because of past technical and bandwidth limitations. That has started to change recently with T-Mobile’s projects and trials by Orange in France and Czech Republic. TD-CDMA is less threatening to cellcos than WiMAX because it is a technology that is still largely geared to the spectrum that they already hold.

IPWireless claims that the cost of adding MBMS to a handset will be only $10 by 2008, and that use of the 3GPP standard Broadcast Multicast Service Center (BMSC) ensures close integration with the main 3G services (although it is not clear when MBMS-capable chipsets will appear). Initially dual-mode chipsets are needed to support TD-CDMA and W-CDMA, although the former is likely to be incorporated into the latter by 2008, achieving the $10 price tag. TDtv enables the delivery of up to 50 channels of TV for standard screen size phones, or 15 higher quality QVGA channels, and can use the 5MHz of unpaired spectrum that European and Asian operators were allocated as part of their 3G licenses as a direct 1:1 overlay on their existing network ‘ so no requirement to build additional cells or masts.