We have analyzed before the likely explosion in wireless backhaul that would occur from 2006 onwards as cellular operators seek to reduce their dependence on expensive leased lines. This trend is starting to become a clear reality, with a host of wireless options being launched or enhanced to appeal to cellcos ‘ whose backhaul requirements are growing exponentially with the denser networks and increased data traffic of 3G ‘ as well as large enterprises and hotzone operators.
The wireless infrastructure makers themselves are putting wireless backhaul closer to the center of their portfolios, hoping to increase revenues by selling more end-to-end systems and compensate for the declining prices of base stations; the point-to-point experts such as Harris, Alcatel and Marconi expect strong growth in their high end microwave options; WiMAX is itself an increasingly attractive option for relatively short distances from a POP; and there are various emerging choices, often backed by ambitious start-ups, and making use of new spectrum, with technologies from satellite to ‘wireless fiber’ or ‘pseudowire’. Important spectrum will be the newly allocated 40MHz of 2GHz satellite bandwidth in the US; the ‘millimeter wave’ frequencies supporting wireless fiber; and the newly activated LMDS frequencies owned by companies like XO and IDT.
The biggest opportunity lies with the cellular carriers, which are facing a huge hike in backhaul capacity. A typical GSM operator deploys one or two 2Mbps backhaul connections per cell site, but many carriers believe between four and eight E1s will be needed for each 3G base station, and up to 16 once the HSDPA upgrade is implemented too. Cingular believes its backhaul costs will rise by 25% once it deploys HSDPA on a wide scale (see Wireless Watch September 30 2005). The sector could be worth $20bn over the next five years in the US alone. As a global average, about 18% of cellco’s opex now goes on backhaul leasing and maintenance, and the figure increases threefold once the network is all-3G, according to Nortel. The situation is improved by moving to packet-based backhaul, notably IP, which can aggregate more traffic per leased line, but the combination of owned wireless lines and IP switching can have a dramatic effect on opex, bringing backhaul down to under 10% of the total if spectrum is owned (operators that are not using all their spectrum can even lease capacity to enterprises or other players to add a new revenue stream.)
European cellcos have used microwave for at least some of their backhaul for years, but the trend has been less noticeable in the US, partly because the largest operators are owned by wireline telcos which control the T1 lines. But now some are looking to change, including Sprint Nextel, which may use some of its own 2.5GHz spectrum and WiMAX-class technology for backhaul. Apart from cost and easier scalability, another factor driving US cellcos to go wireless was last year’s wave of hurricanes. Immediately after Hurricane Katrina, executives from both Cellular South and SouthernLINC Wireless said that some of their cell site outages were due to the T1 lines backhauling traffic being down, and credited use of back-up microwave backhaul links with the ability to recover cell sites quickly.
Such advantages help to outweigh the main drawback of backhaul, the cost of working in licensed spectrum, which most carriers want for reliability. And wider spectrum choices, plus unlicensed options, like millimeter wave, that provide superior guards against interference, are bringing down costs. While the main LMDS spectrum holders in the US, XO, IDT and First Avenue, are trying to lure cellcos to lease their bandwidth around 28-31GHz, the recent winners of expanded 2GHz mobile satellite licenses (see separate item) are also talking up plans to offer some of this for backhaul.
And deals are beginning to come through for companies that make equipment for wireless backhaul, such as Dragonwave, which offers all-IP systems that are used by Clearwire, Gigabeam in the wireless fiber/millimeter wave space; and Axerra and RAD Data Communications. The last of these is used by Time Warner Cable to carry voice and data across IP, while Axerra numbers Korea Telecom among its backhaul users, and also has the advantage of an OEM deal with Ericsson.
Such agreements are critical, since the cellular vendors have the customer influence to push wireless backhaul into their key accounts and are increasingly looking to provide end-to-end solutions. Last week, Nokia announced an agreement with Ceragon Networks, for its FibeAir family, which will now be incorporated with the Nokia microwave radio product portfolio as Nokia PowerHopper Vario.
And WiMAX is increasingly making its bid for a share of the cellular backhaul market, connecting the radio access network to the POP even if it does not reach right back to the cell tower. One of the vendors targeting this sector is Aperto, which has just launched its TDM (time division multiplexing) system for backhaul, which work over distances of up to 15 miles.
The key technical challenge in providing traditional TDM service over broadband wireless links is the transport of a synchronous service, such as a T1/E1 circuit, over the asynchronous IP network. Data from a TDM bit stream has to be encapsulated at the source, transported over a wireless link, and received by a destination device — while maintaining clock, synchronization, and framing. By emulating the characteristics of T1/E1 wireline or fiber connection, Aperto and other WiMAX suppliers claim to offer the same service wirelessly.