Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2006

Vodafone under pressure from short termists just when it needs lateral thinking

Just as the US mobile carriers are turning in storming performances, Vodafone is under unprecedented pressure to dump its 45% stake in Verizon Wireless. Arun Sarin, defending his own CEOship in the face of mounting shareholder criticism, claims this would be the wrong time to get out of Verizon, since there would be greater shareholder value to be derived from waiting ‘ perhaps a very long time. But two of the operator’s top six shareholders have gone public with criticisms of the current strategy and a call to explore an exit from Verizon Wireless, a move that could generate £25-30bn.

Standard Life, the second largest investor in Vodafone, and its sixth largest backer, Morley Fund Management, have both expressed concern about strategy. ‘We share the concerns of many other shareholders and are looking closely at the situation,’ Morley told the Financial Times. Standard Life had already called on Vodafone to sell out of the US. David Cummings, head of UK equities at Standard Life Investments, said: ‘We are very supportive of a sale of Verizon. It would give a massive earnings uplift and there is a willing buyer in Verizon.’ Incoming chairman Sir John Bond is currently listening to shareholder opinions prior to taking up his position at Vodafone in July.

There is no longer much talk of Vodafone looking for an alternative US investment to replace Verizon ‘ one that would use the same GSM/UMTS technology, for instance, or in which the UK giant could hold the controlling stake. Since it backed away from its bid for AT&T Wireless two years ago, there has been increasingly vocal questioning of the Vodafone mantra of global brand and global footprint, some of it sparked by the poor performance of Vodafone Japan. Instead, the thinking goes, Vodafone should concentrate on growth by expanding in emerging markets such as Africa and eastern Europe – where it has made a string of relatively small deals recently ‘ to compensate for saturation of its core western European territories. It should also, the restive investors argue, move away from ventures in which it does not have a controlling stake, such as Verizon Wireless and France’s SFR.

These two key complaints about the Vodafone strategy are not logical when taken together. If Vodafone is to become less concerned with universal brand presence, it is of less importance to have full control of all its operations, as long as these are profitable and have a strong market position in their region. Indeed, Vodafone will always, because of the power of its purchasing and partnership capabilities, have more influence on the strategy of a joint venture than its mere percentage ownership would infer. In the past, there has even been talk of Verizon agreeing to migrate from its CDMA network to support Vodafone’s chosen UMTS in the next generation ‘ in order to take advantage of the strong procurement deals the world’s largest operator can command.

However, the universal brand is important to give Vodafone a value above being classified as a utility stock. Therefore, we believe it needs to keep its presence in key territories, but preferably with brand control. This will be particularly important as the brands of fixed line operators start to gain new approval. Vodafone is losing some of its power in partnerships as the pendulum of influence swings to operators with the networks to support fixed/mobile convergence, expected to be the basis of the most profitable business models in the coming years. Verizon is in a strong position here, and is increasingly keen, as it sees its mobile arm driving both its growth and its shift to a converged triple play, to gain full control of the wireless venture. Thus if Vodafone succumbs to shareholder pressure to sell, its partner will be a happy purchaser. And in the medium term, it might not be a bad situation for Vodafone ‘ but not if it quits the US altogether. Instead, it needs to replace Verizon with something, perhaps smaller but with growth potential, that enables it to have control of the equipment, name and branding.

That situation highlights two dilemmas for Vodafone. First, does it need to be a global operator and if so, what is the best route forward in the world’s largest market, the US? And second, convergence means that it has reached the pinnacle of its power and is in danger of racing downhill as the ‘mobile-only’ tag becomes a burden rather than the huge advantage it was a few years ago. Can Vodafone play in convergence without having its hands tied unacceptably by partnerships with wireline operators?

On the first point, procurement power and support for multinational enterprises are just two reasons why there are still advantages to being a superpower. Even if we assume that the restive investors will eventually get their way, and that there would be benefits to breaking with Verizon, Sarin is right not to throw the baby out with the bathwater ‘ the Verizon stake is profitable and generates major cashflow and is likely to get more valuable in 2006-7 as its US parent emerges from stagnation to be the most dynamic of the Bell operators. The US market still has growth, with 70% mobile phone penetration, compared to 100%-plus in some of Vodafone’s core territories, such as Italy and Germany, which were poor performers in its Q3 figures.

In the mean time, Vodafone could look for a more creative medium term route to remaining a player in the US market. It could take the obvious route of buying another cellco, but there few left on offer ‘ Cingular is too large; T-Mobile has poor coverage and no 3G as yet; Sprint Nextel would be a dream match apart from different network choices, steeply rising value and no real motivation to sell.

Instead, Vodafone could learn some lessons from Sprint Nextel, which is using a combination of wireless technologies to seek to create a converged triple play of its own to challenge the Bellcos. The US company is showing how it will be possible in future to have wireless-only fixed/mobile broadband convergence and multimedia, and if successful, it could restore the lustre to the ‘wireless-only’ label and so, indirectly, benefit Vodafone. The UK giant is better positioned than any other to create a wireless-only converged model, with its buying power, R&D resource and brand, and this may well be its route to growth in the saturated markets, whether it uses an HSDPA with enhanced indoor coverage, WiMAX or some other combination of technologies. Such a strategy would put Clearwire firmly into Vodafone’s acquisition sights. In the game of fantasy operator, buying Clearwire for its 2.5GHz network and T-Mobile plus a handful of regional carriers for cellular would not be a bad way to piece together, Sprint Nextel-style, a system that would be greater than the sum of its parts in terms of US market presence and shareholder value.

Any deals in mature markets will be hard to do in the current investor climate though. Sarin labors under the reputation of being a ‘big deal man’ who wants to follow in predecessor Chris Gent’s footsteps and make huge acquisitions for Vodafone. Ironically, this reputation continues to hold him back, ensuring he is always regarded warily by his timorous shareholders, even while he has actually made only the most cautious of purchases during his reign. Whether he goes or stays, Vodafone desperately needs to stand up to its exceptionally short termist shareholders, who complain that the company is treated as a utility stock while being entirely unwilling to take on the risk that goes with achieving greater growth and dynamism in a market as treacherous as mobile communications.

Wireless-only convergence, selected wireline partners in markets where this is impossible for competitive or regulatory reasons, rapid growth in new economies ‘ such a combination could be a powerful prescription for putting Vodafone and its share price back on track. The global footprint ambition should not be too hastily discarded, just achieved using different means and ones that, in the twenty first century converged world, may create greater shareholder return. One thing the investors should realize, however ‘ Vodafone will need daring and creativity to remain on top, not short term thinking and a refusal to take risk.

BOX ‘ The Verizon pitch

Ivan Seidenberg, CEO of Verizon Communications, said last week that his company was ready to increase its stake in Verizon Wireless or acquire all of the mobile carrier, and stressed that it would be accommodating on terms. He acknowledged during a conference call with analysts that Vodafone, under pressure from some of its UK institutional shareholders, appeared to have become more open to selling its stake. He said he and Doreen Tobin, Verizon’s chief financial officer, had talked about the options for financing such a move and would try to provide Vodafone ‘with as much cash as possible’, should a deal materialize. Such a deal could also include the sale of Verizon’s stake in Italy’s Vodafone Omnitel.

‘I would add that we also recognize that the put option is not the preferred vehicle for Vodafone to facilitate any transaction,’ Seidenberg said. ‘We are very open and willing to consider negotiation around that to make sure that it’s efficient for both sides and ‘ we can maximize value for both parties.’

According to a Bear Sterns report on Verizon, Vodafone can exercise a put right that would require Verizon to buy out its shares at market value in July 2006 or July 2007, but the aggregate amount Verizon must pay may not exceed $20bn and ‘no single exercise of the right may be for an amount in excess of $10bn’. The terms change slightly if Verizon Communications opts to take on the buy-out obligations; Verizon Wireless could still be required to cover $7.5bn of the repurchasing costs in cash or by other arrangement such as assuming debt, but Verizon’s immediate liability could only go up to $10bn. If, as is likely, Vodafone’s 45% stake is worth more than $20bn, Vodafone could retain an interest in the wireless carrier, or Verizon could buy out the rest of the stake.

BOX

Last Tuesday, Vodafone released its third quarter financial figures and updated its full year guidance and strategy. It added 7.1m new subscribers in Q3 and grew mobile revenue by 7%.

Vodafone’s quarterly net additions were 30% up on those of a year ago, bringing its total global customer base to 179.3m. It said that 3G sales continue to develop in line with expectations, with 3.1m net additions in the quarter, bringing the closing total to 8m.

Mobile data revenue grew 7% year-on-year, with non-messaging data revenue up 24%, including 53% growth outside Japan.

However, ARPU figures fell 4.3% in the UK to £23.80, 7.8% in Germany to €22.90, and 8.3% in Italy to €27.70.

Over the past year Vodafone has consistently underperformed the UK’s FTSE 100 stock index and the operator’s shares fell every day last week with more than £6bn or 6.5% being taken off the carrier’s capital value in just five trading days. At close of the markets on Friday, Vodafone shares were trading at £1.18.

Meanwhile, the quarter highlighted the rising strength of the major converged US operators, with mobility the key driver. Verizon’s fourth quarter revenues grew 5.8% to $19.3bn, boosted largely by the performance of Verizon Wireless which increased its revenues by 18.3% to $8.7bn. Verizon Wireless gained a record 2m subscribers to end the year with 51.3m customers, narrowing the gap with Cingular Wireless, the BellSouth-AT&T joint venture.