Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2006

Start-Up Watch: Heavily backed Tello aims to disrupt mobile enterprise space

The ‘mobile enterprise’ has been one of the greatest hopes for boosting corporate IT spending for several years now, but to date it has delivered precious few actual dollars compared to the lofty projections made at the turn of the century. Several groups of suppliers have their eyes keenly turned to it ‘ the traditional enterprise giants such as IBM and Microsoft; the mobile operators, looking to provide more than just voice minutes in the large company space; and the device makers, which see the chance gradually to usurp the role of the laptop with the smartphone. Yet while the vendors device grand frameworks for mobilizing broad swathes of corporate processes and workforces, in reality the adoption of mobile enterprise strategies have been halting, piecemeal and focused on spot solutions ‘ and the early beneficiaries have been those that recognized that fact and focused on a well chosen but specific application. The best examples have been Nextel with Push to Talk and RIM with the BlackBerry push email service. Both of these have connections with the latest challenger, start-up Tello, which emerged from stealth last week with an assault on the ‘presence’ market and a hefty line-up of big name supporters.

Among these backers is Craig McCaw, legendary wireless entrepreneur and former guiding light at Nextel, who will no doubt be assessing the potential of Tello’s presence technology for his broadband wireless venture Clearwire. Also investing and joining the founding board are Vonage founder Jeff Pulver, well respected telecoms financier Michael Price and former Apple CEO John Sculley, while the CEO is Doug Renert, ex-Oracle. Tello promises an application that is already much discussed and which some see as the next breakthrough app stimulating large companies ‘ as push email did ‘ to start to think in terms of mobile frameworks. This is presence-based communication, which combines elements of instant messaging, push to talk and email in what Tello describes as “cross-platform instantaneous communications” (its first supported platform will be BlackBerry). As in push to talk, users can press a button to contact one or a group of colleagues, and know immediately which ones are connected. However, presence applications can also indicate where the other users are and whether they are on a landline, mobile phone, or VoIP or instant messaging service. The caller can then choose which communication mode to connect on and can use voice, IM, email and other messaging from one browser interface.

This is an important building block in the creation of a fully integrated enterprise communication strategy, allowing people to contact one another in a wide variety of ways, using different networks and devices, but all with a single address book and interface. However, unlike RIM and Nextel in their days, Tello is entering a market where several giants are already focused on presence, aware that, like email, it could be one of the cornerstones of evolving mobile enterprise strategies in many organizations. Microsoft, uncharacteristically in the mobile world, has a highly developed and impressive platform in Live Communication Server (LCS), although it still has some way to go to make this fully suitable for mobile platforms as well as laptops. IBM has made similar moves under its Lotus SameTime banner, while Siemens and Cisco are also major players, as are several of the more corporate-focused mobile carriers such as Verizon Wireless.

Tello, then, will need strong partnerships to make an impact on the market, however strong its technology. It does claim some advantages over the big name solutions, notably its ability, not only to see which contacts from the address book are available at any given moment, but to collaborate instantly with them. “Presence allows the initial kick-off of communication, and then you’re able to communicate the way you need to by launching various applications within our service and collaborate seamlessly. Tello acts as a trusted broker, allowing that to happen with your community of contacts across diverse platforms and devices, regardless of whether they’re outside your company or whether they’re using the same systems,’ explained Renert in an interview.

Such functionality will be easily leapfrogged by the larger players, but where Tello will seek to steal a march will be in ease of use and low cost ‘ following in the footsteps of Nextel, Skype, Vonage and RIM in this respect. By relying on secure browsers and standard internet frameworks, Tello offers ease of use to the end user and, to the network manager, the ability easily to incorporate different devices and partners’ or customers’ systems. On the cost side, the basic service is $30 per year per user, although, following in the disruptive steps of Google ‘ also set to make a play for the converged enterprise communications market ‘ there is a bare bones version available to individual end users for free. The aim of this implementation, of course, is to create a groundswell of support, as RIM did in its early days, from the end user community that will then influence IT buyers. At the premium end, companies can also select from a set of ‘smart applications’ to manage their communications in a more sophisticated way, at extra cost.

The cost structure is cheap and, more importantly, transparent and scalable. This contrasts with Microsoft LCS and Lotus SameTime which ‘ while attractive pricing deals are on offer when these are part of a broader enterprise strategy ‘ are in themselves highly priced and complex to set up and run.

So Tello, like Skype and Google, believes it can challenge the big players by offering finance directors a low risk, easily understandable pricing structure in the early stages of the mobile enterprise (even if companies may find, once they scale up to large and complex installations, that they can actually buy a full system more cheaply from Microsoft). And in tandem, it can gain end user support with a simple and functional front end.

The technology underlying Tello consists of a a database server containing directories and preferences, a SIP proxy server for voice calls, and an instant messaging proxy server, and there is initially support for Windows XP and BlackBerry devices, with others due to follow. One area where it has made strong early progress is on integrating different channels ‘ voice, IM and so on ‘ on multiple networks and devices, including BlackBerry, whose recent troubles have focused much enterprise attention on how to incorporate that service into future, heterogeneous enterprise systems. Taking further steps down this path could enable Tello to aim for the role of key middleware provider in the multivendor world, the alternative to Microsoft’s strong but Windows-dominated position with LCS, MSN Messenger and other key communications products (many well regarded presence offerings, such as Siemens’ OpenScape, run on top of LCS).

To take on this heavy mantle, Tello will need partners, preferably including cooperation with IBM and Nokia rather than a head-on attack on Lotus SameTime. It has already gained support from one major, Cisco, that also has its own presence activities under its CallManage label. Tello could also, like mobile email player Visto, go after the carriers with the promise of a white label enterprise platform.

Whatever its market strategy as the sector evolves, it will need to stay ahead in terms of usability while not becoming too complex to operate and manage. For instance, it stands a chance of leaping ahead of Microsoft if it adopts a wide range of fully mobile platforms rapidly, and yet it will have to contend with the limitations of the current mobile browser interfaces (Microsoft’s integrated messaging activities are advanced, but remain highly PC-oriented and with inadequate attention to Windows Mobile as opposed to XP.) Most importantly, it should take a lesson from some of its key backers from the push to talk and VoIP worlds and remember that enterprises are more likely to buy a single application that is simple, low risk and makes a tangible difference, than a broad and visionary mobility strategy. IBM, Nokia, Microsoft and others are creating these strategies and have the resources and power to play the long game and pull their customers gradually towards their broader way of thinking. Tello can carve out a role for itself, like most players in mobile communications software, by giving companies attractive and realistic stepping stones for embarking on the long journey to the true mobile enterprise.

(Tello was formed in late 2004 and raised an undisclosed sum in Series A financing last April. Evercore Partners, Intel Capital, Rho Ventures and McCaw’s Eagle River are leading investors.)