Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2006

Nortel looks east for convergence venture with Huawei

The reinvigoration of Nortel proceeds apace as new CEO Mike Zafirowski looks to make a short term impact as great as that of Ed Zander, the man who beat him to the top job at Motorola. Financial scandals, declining business units and a string of restructurings have plagued Nortel in the past few years, yet it retains certain crown jewels in terms of technology and market presence, that should become more valuable in the converged network world. Not only is the Canadian company eyeing all-IP convergence hungrily, with its skills in wireline and wireless platforms and IP systems, but it is increasingly turning to an east-west alliance strategy to accelerate its growth and take it into new areas more quickly ‘ a strategy that should hold some lessons for other western vendors, many of which remain wary of collaborating with their Asian counterparts. Nortel already has an important joint venture with Korea’s LG, focused on WiMAX and other wireless technologies, and now it has formed an even more ambitious alliance with China’s would-be global networks powerhouse, Huawei Technologies. This new venture company will develop “ultra broadband access solutions” for the global service provider market, the partners announced last week, with the aim of kickstarting Nortel’s broadband business again, and helping Huawei in its ambitions to gain significant presence in the Americas and other western markets.

The new company, which will be based in Ottawa, will be majority owned by Nortel and is expected to be in operation in the third quarter of 2006. Nortel is already marketing Huawei’s broadband access gear to carriers, and the two firms have now started joint product development. The key R&D aspect is to create a next generation multiservice access platform designed specifically to enable carriers to converge their voice, data, video, fixed wireless (such as WiMAX), and, in future, mobile network traffic on a single IP network, said Nortel’s general manager of broadband networks, Walt Megura. The resulting products will build on Nortel’s voice and optical networking strengths and Huawei’s broadband technology and manufacturing efficiencies, and will provide a platform for selling other key products such as Nortel’s IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem). The partnership will also get Nortel back into the fixed broadband access market, which it exited a few years ago, a move most believe it soon regretted. This is a sector where Huawei flourishes, and it was one of the DSL and multiservice access suppliers named for BT’s $10bn 21st Century Network project.

The major risk lies not with the technology but the problems that tend to beset ambitious joint ventures across continents. “We view (Nortel’s) strategy as practical, both from an investment and time to market standpoint as re-entering the access market with its own products only would be difficult after exiting in 2001,” said a research note from UBS. “Major risk is the ability to manage the joint venture and partner effectively with Huawei. We note that in the past, Huawei’s joint ventures with 3Com [for enterprise switches] and Siemens have not proven as successful as initially anticipated.”

However, with this alliance Nortel shows once again how it is starting to tap into the key trends of the hour ‘ IMS, multiservice broadband access, WiMAX and metro mesh. Its core focus is to exploit its existing relationships with carriers and its ability to span several different platforms in order to jump ahead of specialists in any one field. It has a cost efficient approach to R&D that enables reusing generic work in fundamental areas such as OFDM and smart antennas for several different technologies ‘ note its program to create sophisticated OFDM-based mobile WiMAX products, but also to push its OFDM technology HSOPA to the 3GPP authorities.

But Nortel, while looking to emerging technologies such as mesh and IMS, also needs to build on its traditional strengths, notably its large presence in conventional switches, where it is third placed in market share terms, on almost 12% worldwide. As smaller carriers and large enterprises move towards all-IP, Nortel has identified a strong growth opportunity, building on its strong market shares in carrier IP networks (leader on 21%, ahead of Siemens), and in cellular infrastructure (fifth, on 10.2%, behind Ericsson, Siemens, Nokia and Lucent).

Large scale partnerships to enable Nortel to fill the gaps between its strong points, and to access new markets, while spreading the cost and risk, are likely to be a hallmark of the Zafirowski regime as they were of his predecessor Bill Owens’. These are sending strong signals to the market, but the challenge now will be to manage them effectively and ensure they enhance rather than hindering the Nortel comeback plan.