The satellite industry is increasingly turning towards broadband wireless as its savior, rather than a competitor, in the world of converged triple play services. Service providers of all types need to plan to offer voice, video and high speed data consistently to a multitude of access devices from set-tops to phones. To do this, satellite television giants need a broadband return path to add to their one-way systems; many broadband wireless operators need additional spectrum and marketing profile; mobile satellite players need any partners that will enable them to escape their public safety niche (even though that niche has secured them highly favourable license deals recently, especially in the US). By combining satellite and broadband wireless, there is a real opportunity to take on 3G and DSL/cable operators in the race for the mobilized triple play ‘ an opportunity that now looks so viable that there are loud cries that the apparently weaker parties have been given unfairly generous treatment by regulators, to the detriment of the major telcos and cellcos.
These cries have recently centered on the decision of the US FCC to give 2GHz licenses to the mobile satellite (MSS) operators for virtually nothing, and allowing them to offer ground-based services as well. For MSS, these hybrid systems are a lifeline, and may be built from scratch or offered in conjunction with radio partners. However, critics argue that the MSS players will now be able to compete with 3G and broadband wireless providers, without having to pay billions of dollars for spectrum as many of those companies did. The FCC also refused to allow wireless providers to bid in the auction for 2GHz (see Wireless Watch January 16 2006 edition). A key justification for this decision was the importance of mobile satellite in emergency response, especially in the wake of last year’s devastating hurricanes in the sourthern states, but now it seems that at least one of the license holders ‘ MSV, TerreStar and Craig McCaw-backed ICO ‘ is looking to sell on, or license, its spectrum rather than building it out. The other MSS players in the US are GlobalStar and Inmarsat, which did not gain new spectrum in the recent 2GHz round but are also planning a satellite mobile triple play.
An obvious candidate to partner with these companies – which badly need to emerge from their niche in public safety and the financially difficult mobile satellite phone sector – could be satellite broadcasters DirecTV and Echostar, which are looking to create a national broadband wireless system, possibly in conjunction with each other. They are being courted by possible network partners such as MSV ‘ which is working with Boeing to create its hybrid satellite/radio system ‘ and WiMAX players like Clearwire. According to documents leaked to the US press, DirecTV and EchoStar issued a confidential request for information earlier in 2005 about the creation of a national wireless broadband network and the possibility of the rivals forming a joint venture ‘for the purpose of providing broadband data and voice services to DirecTV, EchoStar and possibly other distributors’. Such a network would give them the ability to offer two-way data services and therefore compete with the cable and DSL operators to offer the full converged triple play. This could also be delivered to mobile devices, either directly though mobile satellite or, more probably, with a WiMAX, cellular or proprietary front end.
In a recent interview, Rupert Murdoch, head of DirecTV parent company News Corporation, said the satellite arm is looking at a variety of strategies, including “partnerships, going it alone, going it with a few people.” He did not specify which technology would be used other than to say, “It’s got to be something that can be upgraded and stay with public demand.” He talked about spending $1bn on the plan, although this would be a drop in the ocean if DirecTV is forced to acquire its own spectrum, making an alliance with an existing spectrum holder more probable ‘ perhaps MSV, with its 20MHz of 2GHz spectrum nationwide (and which also says its build-out will cost $1bn). Clearwire, with its significant 3.5GHz holdings, could also be an option, as could Sprint Nextel, although this would likely be ruled out by the latter’s ambition to use its 2.5GHz spectrum to create its own mobile triple play and take on the broadband providers with a wireless-only platform.
A partnership with a mobile satellite company would certainly provide an alternative wireless-only challenge to the incumbent Bell operators. A recent report from TMF Associates concludes that a partnership between an MSS operator and a satellite TV operator could provide spectrum and funding for deployment of a new nationwide 4G-class network in the US by 2010, which could provide both fixed and mobile voice and data services to a total of 13.5m terrestrial and 2.5m satellite users by 2015, generating annual service revenues of $5.3bn ‘ with the MSS partner providing the spectrum and the ability to transmit direct to mobile devices where required, at less cost than in failed MSS ventures like Iridium; and the broadcaster supplying the funding for the projected $3bn cost of building out terrestrial base stations, plus the distribution channels and content partners.
Another option would be partnering with satellite radio providers such as XM Satellite Radio or Sirius Satellite Radio to provide capacity for mobile video and telematics services.
While the MSS players seem to face a choice of remaining in a public safety corner, or finding a major wireless or broadcast partner, there will not be enough such alliances to go round, despite the attraction of the low cost spectrum holdings. And at least one of the MSS operators, Inmarsat, believes it could go it alone and create its own triple play, even if a partner is not forthcoming. It recently announced its Broadband Global Area Network (BGAN), which it said will have a headstart on WiMAX because it offers international coverage immediately, while broadband wireless will take years to achieve this. ‘People need the security of coverage and service for connectivity wherever they go,’ said Paul Griffiths, head of the BGAN unit.
Inmarsat has kicked off BGAN with coverage in the EMEA region and most of Asia. A second Inmarsat-4 satellite will extend this system to the Americas in mid-2006, by which time it will cover 98% of the world’s population and 85% of land mass, says the company. BGAN has cost $1.5bn to develop and will provide simultaneous voice and broadband with guaranteed IP data rates of 256Kbps on demand, another key selling point. Initial average symmetric data rates will be 492Kbps when mobile. BGAN also claims toll-quality voice, avoiding the latency commonly associated with satellite, and support for SMS messaging.
However, though new satellite technology supports far smaller terminals ‘ not much larger than 3G handsets, although there are also heavier dedicated units that link to laptops via Bluetooth ‘ terminals will cost between $1,500 and $3,500. Once signed up, Griffiths argued Inmarsat will undercut Iridium and Globalstar and will offer voice calls at under $1 a minute anywhere in the world and data at $5-7 per megabyte. Services will be aimed almost entirely at business, government and vertical markets, and although Inmarsat is aggressive about taking on broadband wireless, it is already working on a technical level with an Ericsson 3G platform and sees the opportunity to partner with cellular operators in future to extend their coverage.
The most obvious market where satellite and broadband wireless interests will converge is in television. Here, the satellite broadcasters have customer base, marketing clout and content partnerships, and are eager to move into mobile delivery to score points against cable and IPTV players, as well as the pure wireless operators that aim to deliver a fixed/mobile triple play using 3G or broadband wireless alone. While the television players work on the big picture politics, many smaller deals are starting to shape the future of mobile television ‘ one in which providing a mobile front end for satellite content and services will be an important element, as PanAmSat spotted last year with its demonstrations of WiMAX access to its broadcasts.
The two main backers of dedicated mobile TV networks in the US, Qualcomm and Modeo (formerly Crown Castle) have both partnered with satellite providers to use capacity on their equipment.
Qualcomm’s mobile TV subsidiary, MediaFlo USA, last week signed an agreement with Intelsat to use capacity on the satellite operator’s Americas-8 satellite, launched last summer, which is expected to provide bandwidth and connectivity to MediaFlo USA’s transmitter sites. Qualcomm is building a network to offer services based on its proprietary MediaFlo technology and has already signed up Verizon Wireless to use the platform.
Last April, Crown Castle Mobile Media, now Modeo, leased capacity on SES Americom’s AMC-9 satellite to support its own roll-out, which uses the DVB-H (Digital Video Broadcasting-Handheld) standard. It also hopes to sign up major cellcos to use the system, with Cingular a likely partner.
It is important for these dedicated mobile television systems to gain market acceptance and refine their business models in good time, before alternatives that broadcast over the cellular network itself, without the need for a separate parallel platform, start to leapfrog its capabilities. An important player here may be IPWireless, whose tdTV technology can use the TDD (time division duplex) portion of most 3G operators’ UMTS allocations. It is also being trialled by Sprint Nextel, although that company aims to use its 2.5GHz broadband wireless spectrum for television rather than its cellular capacity.
IPWireless points to one approach to enable cellcos to use existing spectrum holdings for TV rather than having to build out or lease separate networks. This led it to sign a partnership last week with MobiTV, the main player in broadcasting over a standard 3G network ‘ an approach that is hopelessly constrained and very much an interim option for operators.
As much as MobiTV proclaims that it delivers more mobile TV than any other company, it would be a doomed, lifeless business if it didn’t move out of its current delivery niche.
Sending TV programs to existing mobile phones using a separate cellular signal for each TV viewer, was always going to be a short term option for mobile operators the world over and although MobiTV, a cross between a content aggregator and a Java delivery platform, has done a great job so far, mobile viewers are few and far between.
Basically, TV on a mobile doesn’t work well enough yet for anybody to make money out of it, and with the imminent arrival of DVB-H, T-DMB and MediaFLO datacasting networks, which will all send high resolution video to mobile phones, MobiTV must feel highly threatened.
All of this explains the announcement it made this week that it would partner IPWireless, which is pushing the idea of multicast TV streams over the MBMS 3GPP protocol, which will compete with DVB-H and the other datacast technologies.
MobiTV has the delivery platform and the content, but has been at the mercy of the cellcos and their current cellular architecture. In some cases, on some parts of any given network, it would take only a handful of concurrent TV viewers to use up an entire base station, if high resolution and rapid frame rates were used, so MobiTV tends to be implemented in a highly constrained way. Working with IPWireless would show off both of their offerings to good advantage and suddenly open up QVGA quality (30 frames a second at 320 x 240 pixels per frame) with established content.
It was only a few weeks back that IPWireless, which specializes in TDD radio delivery in the unpaired 3G bands issued in European spectrum for 3G mobile, launched its TDtv, and announced that US operator Sprint had taken it on in a trial that could result in 50 cable TV channels being shifted onto mobiles over the next few years.
During the first half of 2006 MobiTV will demonstrate delivery of its programming over TDtv to mobile handsets and will begin updating its codec to use H.264, which is an essential part of the 3GPP MBMS standard for multicasting. Multicasting is the process whereby a single copy of a TV program is broadcast from each base station, and any number of viewers can watch it at the same time using no extra bandwidth. This should become available as 3G UMTS base stations in Europe migrate to version 6.0 of their software and new handsets to handle multi-part radio come onto the market in mid-2007.
Given the number of cellcos that are using MobiTV, albeit as a low standard unicast fill in, it will mean that IP Wireless should then be pushing at an open door among the top cellcos, in Europe at least.
Television over W-CDMA or even its successor HSDPA may be impractical for any but the most basic services, but it may be a different matter when the 3G platform is upgraded further, namely to the emerging LTE or so-called 3.9G system. This is being created within the 3GPP process by players such as NTT DoCoMo and Ericsson, and is conceived as a stepping stone to full 4G. HSDPA will only be able to support a few minutes of unicast viewing per day and, within the confines of current 3G paired frequency allocations, the MBMS broadcasting capability within the standard will only support a small number of channels compared to DVB-H. But 3G LTE could enable mobile operators to offer a mixture of broadcast and unicast content without needing DVB-H, rather as the IPWireless-MobiTV combination is promising.
However, as always in the area of high bandwidth mobile services, the positioning of the different platforms against one another will depend largely on the decisions of regulators ‘ what spectrum is allocated, and in what quantity. Like WiMAX, the full benefits of 3G LTE will only be achieved if mobile operators are able to use it in 20MHz of bandwidth, which will require new spectrum allocations ‘ making it even more vital to European operators that the 3G expansion band around 2.5GHz, soon to be auctioned, should be reserved for their technologies and not opened up to WiMAX and others.
There will almost certainly be complex combinations of broadband wireless, TV-specific, satellite and 3G technologies to achieve the dream of the fixed/mobile wireless triple play, and its ability to take on the wireline broadband operators. The precise balance of those combinations, though, will be decided by political alliances and spectrum decisions, rather than by technology itself.
BOX: Spectrum controversy
“The FCC’s giveaway’ to satellite providers like MSV was an outrage,” claims JH Snider, a director of research for the New America Foundation, a Washington thinktank. “It was like the federal government leasing mining rights to federal lands and later throwing in oil rights for free.”
Such commentators argue that, when broader usage ‘ such as adding ground-based rights to the MSS licenses – is allowed in a spectrum that was acquired for very low cost, it should be re-auctioned and opened up to other bidders too. The FCC argues that the boost to the economy from higher usage of the spectrum outweighs mere auction fees revenues. And the cellcos that are objecting to the MSV situation have often benefited themselves from such changes of usage ‘ Sprint Nextel and Clearwire have obtained changes in usage rules that have made their 2.5GHz spectrum more valuable, especially in terms of adding mobile support and using educational frequencies for commercial services, and in the past, many large operators such as Cingular and Verizon Wireless have received spectrum at very low cost as part of a government bid to kickstart the cellular market.
The Bush administration’s recently submitted budget proposal for 2007 contains one attempt to address the competitive problem of some operators using spectrum they acquired for free, in order to compete directly with companies that paid millions of dollars for theirs.
The budget plan calls for a tax on unauctioned spectrum licenses, which could raise $3.6bn over the coming decade, said the submission to the FCC. Industry analysts initially saw this as an effort to target license-exempt spectrum and therefore gain tax from WiMAX and Wi-Fi services, but in fact there are no plans to tax Wi-Fi. Instead the aim is to gain some levies from licensed spectrum that had been acquired for virtually no fees.
The document says that service providers using different technologies to deliver a similar product can face different license acquisition costs, and the “lack of parity in spectrum assignment” creates incentives diminishing overall efficiency of spectrum usage. It then argues: “User fees will help to ensure that spectrum is put to its highest and best use, by internalizing the value of spectrum to license holders. This will have the effect of advancing US economic growth and technological progress. Fee collections are estimated to begin in 2007 and total $3.6bn in the first 10 years.”
The administration is trying to confront the fact that many organizations use licenses they did not acquire at auctions. As well as the satellite players, the cellcos received free cellular licenses back in the mid-1980s when the FCC started the service and distributed most of the initial licenses by free lottery. The main reason for these tax proposals are to replace the formerly suggested plan for a tax on analog TV spectrum, which has always been defeated by the lobbying of commercial TV interests.