Nortel and Lucent are both seeking to be the big telecoms turnarounds of 2006, and Nortel has kicked off strongly with a new CEO and a strategy of forming alliances with major Asian partners such as Huawei to bulk out its broadband convergence portfolio and to ease its penetration of China. Lucent is taking a very different stance, but like Nortel is focusing firmly on wired/wireless convergence and the IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS). Now it has scored a major point against its Canadian rival, planning to use this week’s 3GSM conference in Spain to announce a major IMS partnership with IBM ‘ similar to one formed last year by Nortel.
At first glance, the two alliances look very similar. Lucent brings its IMS and converged IP expertise and extensive R&D to the table; IBM offers integration with business processes and key middleware such as WebSphere, devised for the enterprise but now being pushed into the carrier sector. But there are two more radical possibilities attached to the deal ‘ that Lucent could take the first leap into a managed IMS service, that could significantly shake up this emerging market; and that it may finally take a lesson from Nortel and seek greater return on its huge R&D investments by sharing its broad technology portfolio more freely with partner companies.
The logical extension of this latter point, and one that could create far better value out of Lucent’s advanced developments and its Bell Labs culture, might be to create a separate unit to license technology and intellectual property. Lucent’s ‘innovation engine’, Bell Labs, was spun out of AT&T in 1996 and generates about two patents a day, with over 30,000 to its name, plus six Nobel prizes and key contributions such as the transistor. Although it has been scaled back considerably since its heyday, it still provides Lucent with an enormously advanced R&D facility, but one that is often criticized for having too little measurable commercial return for the company. But partnerships with strong allies such as IBM can provide a faster and more effective route to market for the innovations ‘ such as the very advanced IMS work ‘ and gain them higher profile and more rapid ROI.
Nortel has recognized this fact already, selling off many technologies and relying on partners to fill gaps in its range, and seeking to spread R&D cost and risk through joint activities. One of the most important of these, though one overshadowed by the new Lucent deal, is the codevelopment of an IMS with IBM. Former CEO Bill Owens highlighted the strategy last summer when the deal was announced. ‘This agreement with IBM is a critical component of our strategy to partner for growth.Working with IBM, as one of their key partners, is a bold step forward in our efforts to transform our business by reaching an entirely new level of R&D collaboration while reducing our R&D costs, introducing products at a faster pace and serving a broad range of customers more rapidly.’
The IMS has been an important focus of R&D work for Lucent for the past few years and has started to generate good returns. According to CEO Pat Russo, speaking last fall, told shareholders: ‘Lucent’s IMS initiative is further along than we, or anyone else, originally thought, with revenue recognition now likely to occur in the first half of 2006.’ This puts it ahead of most of the market in revenue terms, and the IBM tie-up should help attract other big name customers by providing integration services and business functionality. Lucent has already announced IMS contracts with Cingular Wireless and both its parents, SBC and BellSouth, and is also the favorite to supply an IMS to the other senior Bell carrier, Verizon Communications.
The attractions of the Lucent IMS have rested heavily on its advanced home subscriber server (HSS), a key element of the IMS, which unifies subscriber information from all legacy systems; and on its more gradual, step-by-step approach to IMS than that of many rivals. The IBM deal adds further functionality, but it also seems that Lucent could be thinking even further ahead and looking to work with IBM to offer a fully managed IMS service, which could be highly appealing to carriers that are nervous of the risk attached to a major investment in the core software for delivering converged, multi-network, multimedia services.
In the short term, Lucent and IBM will develop, market and deliver a joint IMS architecture, including service creation and network management solutions such as billing and OSS. The two companies have developed a reference architecture to support operations and billing solutions that leverages IBM’s WebSphere, Rational and Tivoli software, Lucent’s VitalSuite products, and/or third party software and services. This is being tested by five service providers currently.
An important focus is on creating blended services that span wireless and enterprise needs. At 3GSM, for instance, the partners will demonstrate integration between Lucent’s Active PhoneBook, a mobile directory, with IBM’s Lotus Workplace Collaboration Services. John Marinho, corporate strategic marketing vice president for Lucent Technologies, said the alliance was particularly strong ‘where traditional IT capabilities and telecom capabilities can leverage what IMS does in terms of a unified architecture. All these wonderful IMS services are great, but if at the end of the day the operator can’t provision or bill for them in a way that doesn’t break the bank or compromise the end user experience, then we haven’t gotten the benefit out of IMS we all believe it has.’
This relatively pre-packaged, end-to-end approach should be simpler and less risky for carriers than fully tailored integrator projects, argues IBM, but the next step would be a fully outsourced offering based on the same building blocks. In the past year, Lucent has put services at the heart of its recovery strategy to a far greater extent than Nortel and constantly talks up its Global Network Operations Centers (GNOCs) in Denver, Colorado, the Netherlands, Poland and Australia, where managed and hosted telecoms operation and security services are based. For the first time last year, Lucent reported services earnings separately. Key to the GNOC strategy are tie-ups with large enterprise and server companies such as IBM and Sun. For instance, Lucent developed its Hosted Secure Email service with Sun and Echoworx and won Verizon as its first customer last year, but also sees such deals as its route into the enterprise, where it has little direct profile. It now claims $1bn in managed services contracts over the past 24 months and is currently managing more than 40 networks worldwide.
The aim is to expand the number of services offered from the GNOCs and other facilities, with hosted IMS an obvious possibility that could throw a spanner in the works of competitors looking to sell big ticket ‘big bang’ IMS systems. Hosted IMS could be especially successful among tier two carriers, MVNO virtual operators, and outside the US, where telcos are more averse to outsourcing than in Europe and Asia. Late last year, Lucent raise the concept of being a provider of hosted IMS, and we would not be surprised to see it leverage its IBM partnership to pursue that aim and appeal to large enterprise IP projects too. Like Nortel, Lucent is realizing that integration software, services and partnerships will create far more value for the company than clever products alone, and accelerate its hoped-for turnaround.
BOX ‘ Riverstone
Lucent has agreed to purchase Ethernet developer Riverstone Networks’ assets for $170m in cash. The two companies have worked together delivering carrier-grade Ethernet routers to service providers.
Riverstone agreed to conduct the sale of its business from Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. Once the sale is completed, it plans to pay off its liabilities, including a $65m loan. Any remaining cash is set to be distributed to Riverstone’s shareholders as part of a plan of liquidation.
The deal should give Lucent a jumpstart into the front line of the carrier Ethernet equipment market. According to Infonetics Research, Riverstone was second only to Cisco Systems in this sector in 2004 – a market that could be worth $2.6bn in 2008. The Riverstone acquisition comes nearly three years after Alcatel’s similar purchase of TiMetra, which has been a major contributor to the French company.