Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 February 2006

Progress to ultra-low cost handset accelerates but Nokia wary

Growth in handsets is increasingly focused on emerging markets, that require lower price points than the saturating mobile economies. This is spurring a constant stream of developments aimed at achieving low cost devices, from reference platforms for sub-$30 cellphones to pricing changes by major players like Symbian. But Nokia, despite its advanced work in low cost base stations for emerging economies, is staying somewhat aloof from the race for the super-cheap phone.

Most of the work on handsets that can be created for less than $30 ‘ the tipping point defined by the GSM Association for low income markets such as many African countries ‘ has come from major chipmakers and OEMs (see inset). Now the makers of the reference platforms that are typically adopted by the white label phonemakers and ODMs ‘ vital to the mass market expansion of any technology ‘ are joining the race. Last week saw one of the leaders in this market, TTPcom, announcing a complete reference design for the Ultra Low Cost (ULC) segment. The design, which includes an application suite, protocol software and baseband chipset engine, will enable handset manufacturers and semiconductor vendors to deliver a sub-$20 ex-factory handset.

Another key component in handset cost, especially at the more sophisticated end, is software licensing, and mobile operating system vendor Symbian is to cut its fees in a bid to move beyond the smartphone niche into the mass market ‘ though it will be some years before emerging customer bases require its advanced facilities. But when they do, Symbian needs to have a strong position ahead of its challengers, Windows Mobile and Linux. It currently charges handset makers $5 per phone (for shipments of more than 2m units) and will now reduce this to as low as $2.50 per phone.

Research firm Diffusion Group said Symbian enjoyed a market share of 51% last year in the smartphone sector, followed by Linux with 23% and Windows Mobile with 17%, but the Microsoft system is predicted to gain steady ground until the three OSs share the market almost evenly by 2010. As part of its effort to stall that process, Symbian said that, along with its majority owner Nokia and Freescale Semiconductor, it has developed a low cost 3G reference design for Symbian OS devices. This should enable a Symbian smartphone that will cost operators less than $150.

For all the drive to bring phones to the next billion users, for high margin companies like Nokia this brings the obvious sacrifice of profit levels to volume and market share. Last month, Nokia said the shift of sales to entry level models, even in developed markets, was putting huge pressure on average selling price, which in the Finnish giant’s case fell to €99 in the fourth quarter last year, from €111 a year earlier. Such trends are making Nokia, whose margins are famously high in the cellphone market, very wary of ULC developments.

Nokia said it has no intention of joining low cost handset initiatives that seek to promote the manufacture and sale of mobile phones at very low price points. ‘It was our conscious decision’ not to be part of the GSMA’s low cost initiatives (led by Motorola), said Arja Suominen, vice president of corporate communications, at a recent financial briefing in Helsinki.

Nokia has been developing lower cost handsets targeted at emerging markets, without getting into ULC sectors yet, and hopes to cherrypick those bases that will move most quickly up the value chain and start to demand higher value models within one generation of phone replacement.

This is the real key to the drive for low cost handsets ‘ the hope of replacement markets in the medium term that will add significant value. Companies like Motorola and Nokia will take a tremendous hit on their average margin per phone by entering low cost sectors, but they will also take pole position in economies where wealth is growing, and where many of the users will, by the time they replace their phones, have more money to spend on higher featured models.

Motorola, probably the most aggressive of the handset makers about achieving a handset priced around $30-$40 retail, has positioned these activities as a way to generate scale, along with the higher sounding motives of social and technological inclusion. The company is heading the Emerging Market Handset Programme with the GSM Association and targets sales of 6m ultra-low cost handsets to 10 operators in emerging economies by 2007.

But for a company that can think in the longer term, and whose traditional markets are saturating, the replacement or upgrade sector, with a hoped-for hike to $100 phones by many users, will be even more attractive. Investment bank UBS expects the emerging market replacement segment to show the most significant volume growth over the next several years, growing from 10% of global volumes in 2004 to 27% in 2007. This makes high growth emerging economies like South Africa, Russia, China and some other African and Latin American countries highly attractive.

BOX: Key contributors to the sub-$30 handset initiative:

‘ Last year, the GSM Association kickstarted two efforts to develop mobile phones that would retail in emerging countries ‘ one for devices priced below $40 and one below $30 wholesale. It selected Motorola to head up both projects and the company has launched several prototypes.

‘ Predicting that 1bn handsets will ship in 2009, Infineon Technologies said last week that for those devices to achieve the Holy Grail of multimode, multimedia functionality, serious innovation in the realm of RF and digital design will be required. It claims it will achieve 1bn-transistor systems-on-chip before 2008, bringing its own problems ‘ the need for $5bn wafer fabs by 2006, all while device costs remain fairly flat. Prices will drop below $20 wholesale as early as 2007, according to Infineon’s entry platforms vice president Horst Pratsch and $10 phones are possible, although the German company believes phonemakers will be nervous of damaging their image by using extremely low grade components necessary for this price point. ‘Low quality is not an option, but accepting fewer features is,’ Pratsch said. Infineon aims to develop a $5 chip and trim 100 components from the typical handset. ‘In 2007, we can do 50 components,’ Pratsch said, claiming that wholesale pricing should dip below $20 at that time.

‘ Texas Instruments’ Dr Bill Krenik, manager of advanced wireless architectures, told the recent World Handset Forum: ‘With the advent of ultra-low cost GSM phones at the sub-$40 wholesale cost, we are finally able to bring mobile communications to economically disadvantaged regions of the world.’ And the next goal, the $30 voice-only mobile phone, is just ahead, Krenik said, relying particularly on ever more compact and integrated chipsets to cut down on the number one cost factor, silicon. This integration has been an area where TI is especially advanced.

‘ Philips expects to sample a sub-$5 hardware and software platform for making ultra-low cost handsets by the end of this year. The Nexperia cellular platform should drive GSM handset costs below $20, according to Thierry Laurent, Philips Semiconductors’ executive vice president of business development. The long term goal, he added, is to drive down total handset cost to below $15 by 2008.