Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 February 2006

Patent opportunism reaches fever pitch in wireless

The success of technologies like Wi-Fi has given rise, over the past two years, to a storm of patent claims, many of them highly opportunistic and sure only to stir up fears of increased costs or to stall the evolution of standards.

Mobile email has been the most heated battleground, centering on the RIM/NTP/Visto fights, and there is the ongoing controversy over how Qualcomm licenses its technologies, but there are many other examples, all of which cry out for a new look, by standards bodies and licensing organizations, at the whole structure of patents enforcement and royalties charging.

Large European cellcos recently scored a victory when they demanded an overhaul of how ETSI, the European standards maker, agrees standards, to avoid intellectual property traps where companies contribute technology to a standard and then later reveal patents and claw back huge royalties. Vodafone and its allies suggested that IPR terms should be agreed before a standard is even set, a proposal largely endorsed by the EU.

But there are plenty of other fields in which patent hoarders can try to gain a quick win ‘ indeed, three claims have emerged in the past week alone. First came I/O specialist and licensing company Rambus, which has spent the last decade fighting various patent litigation suits that have resulted in the company getting millions of dollars, but which stands accused of just the type of practises the EU is trying to outlaw. Critics say Rambus has often attended standards meetings and pushed for the specifications to include technology in which they had patents pending, without clarifying this to other vendors. Now the company claims nearly all handset makers infringe its intellectual property, in terms of the memory interfaces used in most phones.

CEO Harold Hughes said in an interview: ‘We have technology that we invented literally 10 to 15 years ago, that is going into just about every mobile phone, so that will be an opportunity for us to find patent licenses.’ Many people thought that Rambus would not survive patent infringement lawsuits it is involved in “and to a certain extent our technology was then incorporated wantonly’, Hughes said.

Rambus is involved in lawsuits with key semiconductor makers like Micron Technologies, Hynix Semiconductor and Samsung Electronics. Last year it settled a case with Infineon, with the German chipmaker agreeing to pay up to $150m in licensing fees.

Another boom technology that is starting to attract its share of patent actions ‘ as hotspots did in 2004-5 ‘ is VoIP. Google is already facing a lawsuit concerned with call routing from patent troll RTI, and now a German telco named Teles is claiming that it owns patents on switching between a traditional phone line and a VoIP phone line, and has decided to sue Nokia, which recently introduced its dual-mode handset, which uses UMA (Unlicensed Mobile Access) to support VoIP and cellular. Meanwhile, Globe.com, newly reinvented as a VoIP player, is claiming a patent on the concept of mapping phone numbers to IP addresses.

Completing the hat trick, WLan security start-up AirTight Networks has won a new patent and is now seeking to get rivals to license the technology, or threatens to sue. At least one rival start-up, AirDefense, says it will dispute the US Patent and Trademark Office decision, claiming prior art.

The patent covers the detection and classification of threats on a wireless Lan, blocking those threats while detecting others, and locating the problems on a floor map so they can be removed.

“We got the official notification this morning that it had been awarded,” said Dennis Tsu, VP of marketing at AirTight. “We think we have some unique intellectual property and we want to protect it.” He said AirTight has already licensed its technology to Colubris and Extreme Networks and is “in talks with a number of other companies’.

AirTight has another 14 potential patents in the works, while AirDefense has filed 18.