Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 March 2006

DVB-H support shows small signs of a new Qualcomm

Qualcomm is throwing its engineering and commercial expertise at trying to create a dominant next generation platform to sustain its unique business model, but in its strategic heart it knows that the future will be one of multiple networks and it is also building up its revenue streams in technologies it does not control. This has been seen in its W-CDMA chipset range, and its intensifying focus on integrating multiple radios such as Wi-Fi and 3G in one platform. Now, while it aims to make its MediaFLO system pre-eminent in mobile television, it has also announced it will make chips for the probably victorious standard in Europe, DVB-H.

Supporting Europe’s favorite standards is the only practical way that Qualcomm will gain market share in this region, even though it will carve out some footholds for its software platforms such as Brew and UIQ, and for its CDMA450 networks in eastern Europe. Europe is also leading the charge to ensure that Qualcomm does not gain such a patents-based stranglehold as it has in its CDMA sector, in any future market. Its assertion of significant patent rights in W-CDMA, and the effect those licensing fees have on keeping handset bills high, has prompted a complaint to the EU led by Nokia, Broadcom, Ericsson and others. Also patent holders in W-CDMA, these companies are looking to introduce a cap of about 5% cumulative royalties in order to make their handset lines more competitive.

While the EU examines the allegations of anti-competitive business practises, a more immediate stand ‘ this time prompted by the major cellcos ‘ has been taken by European standards body ETSI (European Telecommunications Standards Institute), which is developing a radical plan to restrict intellectual property rights for patents essential to all components of the next version of the 3GPP-based radio standard, known as Long Term Evolution (LTE). The plan, devised last year by mobile operators, is designed to get all relevant patent holders to agree in advance to a cumulative cap of about 5% for royalties on the cost of all LTE equipment so that companies can more clearly define the cost of the technology.

Such principles could also be important if applied to WiMAX, where vendors fear Qulacomm will assert patent rights, and so prompt other intellectual property owners like Samsung to reciprocate, pushing up the cost of the platform. Qualcomm is accumulating intellectual property in the key OFDM technology that will underpin its MediaFLO system and its own next generation network, which it is likely to push to be the 802.20 standard. However, it will have to be more flexible in its licensing if these new technologies are to gain market acceptance, and it will never be as dominant in OFDM patents as it is in CDMA.

All this will force it to ensure that its core chip business is as competitive as possible, using the patents to keep its silicon products ahead of the game, rather than directly as a major revenue stream. Hence keeping its options open by branching out into DVB-H, not just for Europe but to give Qualcomm the chance to sell chips for mobile TV handsets in the US, where the main competition to Qualcomm’s own MediaFLO network ‘ to be used by Verizon ‘ could come from Crown Castle, which is building a DVB-H system called Modeo.

Other vendors are moving to take advantage of the burgeoning operator interest in mobile television. Microsoft last week unveiled itself as the missing sixth founding member of the Mobile DTV Alliance, joining Intel, Modeo, Motorola, Nokia and Texas Instruments. Modeo, in particular, has stressed that DVB-H is as much for laptops and PDAs as mobile phones and Microsoft will not want to allow another software house a chance to build a Trojan horse video platform for laptops.

And French broadband equipment maker Thomson is working with WiNetworks, a specialist in integrating WiMAX, satellite and DVB technologies to support triple play models. WiNetworks’ patented Hybrid WiMAX DVB (HWDV) technology allows one-way broadcasters, such as those using satellite, one-way cable and MMDS, to extend their existing infrastructures to deliver high speed internet access, VoIP and interactive TV services. This technology will be integrated into Thomson’s CPE for broadcasters, cablecos and other service providers.

BOX ‘ Alcatel

The difficulty in freeing up UHF spectrum in some European countries such as the UK, France and Germany for mobile TV services has prompted Alcatel to propose yet another mobile TV solution. Alcatel has proposed using DVB-H in the 2.2GHz ‘S’ band and adding a mobile satellite component to it. Alcatel’s timeframe is to have a terrestrial repeater network ready for commercial deployment by 2007. A new satellite to support rural services will need to be launched and is expected to be in place in 2008 or 2009. The move is similar to what is happening in Korea, where players are launching terrestrial and satellite versions DMB-based mobile TV services. But there are also several regulatory changes that need to take place for such a plan to move forward.