The proliferation of different wireless technologies, with increasingly overlapping remits, is having one positive effect ‘ cutting down on destructive standards battles. The lurking threat of Qualcomm’s OFDM activities has helped light a fire under mobile WiMAX processes, and now the two groups fighting to provide the forthcoming standard for Wi-Fi mesh have come to a remarkably painless consensus and produced a combined proposal. This will accelerate the creation of a standard in this important area ‘ vital to ensure that the momentum behind metrozone deployments is not slowed by fears about dead end equipment choices, and that mesh continues to play a major role despite the emergence of other potential platforms for city networks such as WiMAX.
Although the 802.11s standard for Wi-Fi mesh will not be ratified for at least another 18 months, the IEEE taskgroup charged with creating the specification will at least be working from a single starting point now, avoiding the factional fighting that plagued the 802.11n fast Wi-Fi efforts until recently, and which killed the 802.15.3a UltraWideBand initiative altogether. Such delays and uncertainties would have been highly damaging in the metrozone space, the great hope for all the mesh suppliers right now, since they could have divided the market in two, with budget-constrained cities facing the risk of choosing equipment that might be non-standard and therefore have a short shelf life and no future interoperability with other equipment.
The 802.11s platform will standardize the currently proprietary protocols that route traffic around the mesh and will support mobility and broadcast/multicast/unicast signals. The Wi-Fi Alliance, or a separate body, is likely to take responsibility for creating different profiles or subsets of the full standard, as has happened in WiMAX, and this activity could also open the way to including other networks in the mesh alongside Wi-Fi. There is a high degree of interest in combined Wi-Fi/WiMAX metrozones, with the latter providing backhaul and premium services, perhaps in licensed spectrum. Profiles are likely for different types of mesh behavior and this will be important to make the standard meaningful. There has been much debate over how all-encompassing 802.11s should be ‘ for instance,whether it should cover both indoor and outdoor usage. Profiles allow a potentially unwieldy standard to be subdivided into more manageable chunks that are optimized for certain applications and can relatively easily unite the vendors in that sector and so create volume economics. Examples are likely to include profiles for single and switched multiple radios; contention-free sectorized mesh; and various frequencies such as 2.4GHz, 4.9GHz, and 5GHz).
The original 15 proposals submitted to the 802.11s taskgroup were quickly whittled down to two, under the auspices of two coalitions. One was the Wi-Mesh Alliance (WiMA), created last year and led by Nortel, with supporters including Accton, ComNets, InterDigital, NextHop, Philips, Extreme Networks, Mitre, the US Naval Research Laboratory, Swisscom Innovations and Thomson. The other was the SEEMesh group, backed by Intel, Nokia, Motorola, NTT DoCoMo and Texas Instruments.
The urgent need to maintain confidence in mesh clearly outweighed the different agendas of the two parties and drove a fairly quick compromise. This has been portrayed as a response to the ‘threat’ that WiMAX would pose to metrozone mesh ‘ for instance, Motorola, which plays in both technologies, has produced models that show WiMAX as a more cost effective way to blanket a densely populated city than Wi-Fi mesh. And WiMAX has clear advantages such as the choice of licensed or unlicensed spectrum for different required service levels. However, we believe WiMAX and Wi-Fi will more commonly combine than compete in this particular market, especially with the rapid appearance of dual-mode devices for the two radios, as previewed by Intel last week. The real danger to mesh sales in the city environment is the fightback from cellular operators, offering better priced, more powerful 3G and 3G+ services that, they argue, make the mesh a waste of city money.
Not that the world of Wi-Fi is entirely harmonious. True, the two factions that were fighting last year to provide the 802.11n fast WLan standard did come to a consensus ‘ albeit one largely forced upon them by the major Wi-Fi chipmakers ‘ Intel, Broadcom, Atheros and Marvell ‘ effectively threatening to support a breakaway movement and bypass the IEEE were their ideas not adopted by 802.11n. This was a real threat ‘ in the 802.15.3a stalemate, Intel and Texas Instruments did remove their WiMedia Alliance from the IEEE altogether and gained standardization from another body, ECMA, effectively killing the IEEE effort. In 802.11n, a consensus proposal was adopted, however grudgingly in some quarters, but that has not stopped the bickering over certain aspects of the platform, notably its support for optional wide (40MHz) channels. This echoes previous tussles over apparently obscure but politically charged technological topics ‘ such as last year’s epic about what really constitutes MIMO (Multiple Input Multiple Output, the smart antenna approach at the heart of 802.11n). As with that debate, the latest one is as much about politics as wireless technology, and pitches the two claimants to Wi-Fi MIMO pre-eminence, Airgo and Atheros, against one another.
Airgo was the big loser from the acceptance of the Intel-inspired 802.11n proposal, which was supported by Atheros. Airgo was first to market with MIMO chipsets in the Wi-Fi arena, and has signed up OEMs such as Linksys and Belkin for its ‘True MIMO’ devices. These claim to be ‘pre-802.11n’ but are in fact proprietary performance boosters for current Wi-Fi standards, since 802.11n has not yet been ratified or fully defined. However, they do bring ‘n’-class performance ‘ well over 100Mbps ‘ to current WLan ranges, provided Airgo chips are used at both access point and client end. Atheros has a similar offering, though one dismissed by start-up Airgo as ‘not really MIMO’. Whatever the rights and wrongs of that intellectual debate, Airgo is now faced with the prospect of having to overhaul its technology to support 802.11n, rather than its chips becoming the heart of the new standard, as it had previously hoped. For a start-up, this will entail unwelcome costs, plus the loss of the market headstart it had created.
Little surprise, then, that there are some sour grapes, with Airgo claiming it will not build a chipset for draft one of 802.11n because it will not be good enough. It also claims the draft has problems that will delay the emergence of the full specification and subsequent products ‘ a point of view denied by Atheros, which said the newly released draft 1.0 is hardly changed from the original draft, demonstrating its innate stability and closeness to the final stages.
Airgo’s complaint is that the current draft would degrade or even disable existing 802.11b/g networks in the 2.4GHz band, and it implies that its rivals are deliberately seeking to push a standard that does not coexist with current products in order to steal Airgo’s market share in the fast Wi-Fi sector. This is overwrought ‘ Airgo’s share of the Wi-Fi chip market, despite its early moves in MIMO, is dwarfed by those of Atheros, Broadcom and Intel. But the first two, plus Marvell, have shown off products based on the 802.11n draft and aim to release chips long before the final standard is ratified, so this really has become a game of timing ‘ one where Airgo may have overplayed its hand, and where Broadcom, if past history is anything to go by, will get it just right. Broadcom, after all, rocketed up the WLan chip rankings in 2003, from nowhere to the number one spot, based on a controversial decision to launch ‘pre-standard’ silicon for 802.11g. Despite dire warnings of the risks of buying pre-standard products that might then have to be adapted to be fully interoperable, consumers snapped up the fast devices, and Broadcom set a trend for anticipating standards that has been a feature of wireless ever since.
The trick, of course, is to get to market first, but with a product that, at most, will just require a firmware update to be fully standards compliant ‘ not a complete rework such as Airgo will have to undergo for its True MIMO range (whose current semi-proprietary form it will continue to market). Airgo claims draft 1.0 silicon will not be close enough to the final 802.11n spec to allow for a simple firmware update, a point of view countered by the larger competitors (though there will almost certainly be several more drafts ‘ 802.11g reached eight). And the main issue at stake in redrafting is sure to be that of wide channels and the related one of interference with adjacent devices. Despite the breezy dismissals from Atheros, these are being taken seriously enough for the 802.11n taskgroup to set up an internal committee, chaired by Cisco and Motorola representatives, to study them.
There have always been disputes over whether turbocharged Wi-Fi systems cause unacceptable interference with standard 802.11 devices within range ‘ most famously a long and bitter debate between Atheros and Broadcom in late 2003, with the former accused of causing interference with its SuperG technology. SuperG uses three techniques to achieve its performance hike. Turbo mode is the one at issue, since it can directly affect other devices.
The issue gained even more attention when vendors like Belkin started shipping Airgo-based products labelled ‘pre-N’, and the Wi-Fi Alliance came up with the policy that any product claiming to be 802.11n capable, but that “adversely impacts the interoperability of other Wi-Fi Certified products”, would have its certification revoked. This has never yet been enforced, partly because testing is voluntary and, in the consumer market, claims for supercharged performance can outweigh the comfort factor of a standards certification guarantee. This has led to fears that the standard will start to fragment as vendors chase a wireless home market whose demands for speed are far outrunning the agility of the standards body to produce new platforms. To retain the credibility and unity of the Wi-Fi standard in the consumer market, the vendors will need to take the example of their cousins in mesh and hold their fragile unity together, in order to bring a robust technology that meets consumer demands to market as soon as possible.