The past year has seen one of the satellite communications business’s periodic reawakenings, this time with the focus on integrating with broadband wireless to try, finally, to discover a real business model outside very rural areas. This has been stimulated by the allocation of new spectrum in the US for hybrid satellite/ground-based or ATC networks, and now satellite giant Inmarsat is entering the phone services business for the first time. Meanwhile, Alcatel is pushing another way to combine satellite and radio approaches in order to maximize the amount of spectrum in use for next generation services, by suggesting a variation of the DVB-H mobile television technology for satellite spectrum.
Inmarsat has long stayed away from the commercial minefield of satellite phone services, but now believes that combining these with terrestrial wireless networks will finally deliver the business model that eluded ambitious failed ventures like Iridium. Although it failed in its bid to win some of the new US spectrum for ATC offerings, it is ploughing ahead anyway, and says it will offer voice and data phone services in about a year’s time using its new BGAN broadband platform. By combining its new generation satellites with one or more telecoms partnerships, Inmarsat says it will get ATC services to market more quickly than its competitors and with shared costs and risks. The market is inclined to listen to Inmarsat CEO Andy Sukawaty when he talks about this business, since he formerly built up and ran Sprint’s mobile business, Sprint PCS. Given Sprint’s fondness for maximizing the use of its network through widely varied partnerships, the telco is likely to be one on Sukawaty’s list of potential tie-ups.
Inmarsat aims initially to target its existing customer base with the new voice services and also to make a major play to run proposed in’flight cellphone capabilities when those are legalized. As such it aims to steal a march on the main international satellite phone operators, Iridium and Globalstar of the US and Saudi Arabia’s Thuraya, claiming its new BGAN satellites have so much capacity that voice will add little to overall costs, and that it will be even more cost-competitive with the older services when it has a cellular or broadband wireless partner. Globalstar and Iridium will not upgrade their satellite fleets for several years.
Making better commercial use of satellite capacity is also Alcatel’s interest in proposing a version of DV-H for the 2.2GHz ‘S’ band reserved for mobile satellite services around the world (but in active use mainly in the US). Alcatel is suggesting a hybrid approach incorporating a satellite for rural coverage and a terrestrial repeater network for urban services ‘ as in voice and data, the key way that operators are now looking to make satellite-based offerings more cost effective, flexible and user friendly. Alcatel’s idea reflects the approach taken in Korea and elsewhere, where there are satellite and radio versions of the DMB mobile broadcast standard.
Olivier Coste, president of Alcatel’s mobile broadcast division, said many countries, especially in Europe, are being slow to open up dedicated spectrum for mobile television, which could lead to a failure to keep up with rising demand, and so other available spectrum options must be explored. In particular, authorities are dawdling on opening up the former analog television bands around 700MHz, which will be prime real estate for mobile broadcasters. ‘The players had expected UHF to be made available sooner,’ Coste said.
Some operators will use their 3G networks for television, using technologies based on the
MBMS standard, backed by Ericsson in FDD (frequency division duplex) bands and IPWireless in TDD (time division duplex). But cellcos will have to be sure they can set aside enough of their precious 3G bandwidth for television, and that this will deliver the best ROI compared to other services.
Alcatel, which estimates the global mobile TV market will generate €10bn a year in services by 2010, sees the underused 2.2GHz band as a useful solution. Coste is undeterred by the relative failure of handheld satellite TV in Korea, blaming the business model rather than the technology ‘ the regulator has insisted on the services being free to air, and so operators have not been motivated to implement. Coste himself advocates a model based on a flat monthly fee (of around €10), once coverage is ubiquitous and a large number of channels has been launched (15-20 mainstream channels over dedicated broadcast networks, supplemented by 50-100 specialist interest services, which could be delivered on the unicast 3G system, he argues).
When focusing on a combination of broadcast and unicast, 2.2GHz has the advantage of being adjacent to 3G spectrum, allowing for reuse, in many cases of 3G base stations and antennas; and will support small handsets since large aerials are not required in that band. Alcatel is at work developing a chipset to support 700MHz and 2.2GHz in one terminal, working with mobile TV chipset specialist Dibcom and handset maker Sagem. The French giant is also in talks with the DVB Forum about extending its standard to support the S band; and with the regulators. It expects the pan-European authority, CEPT, to come up with a European framework by midyear, which would then be the blueprint for national regulators and potentially for their counterparts in other parts of the world. Alcatel said it will have a terrestrial repeater network ready for commercial deployment by 2007 and a new satellite to support rural services launched in 2008. ‘We are in discussions with satellite operators,’ said Coste.