Innovative technologies abound in wireless, and most have to make several stabs at a business model before they can even smell commercial success. One such is xG Technology’s xMAX, an ultra-low power broadband wireless platform which, last year, was touting itself as a solution for cellular operators looking to increase their coverage at low cost, or as an alternative physical layer to provide a highly efficient base for standards like WiMAX. Now it has repositioned, and is going after the local WISP base, promising low cost, wide area base stations and VoIP handsets.
The $10,000 xMAX base station and the handset – which will emerge in a business version in the summer, followed by a consumer device at the end of the year – will improve the business case for low cost VoIP providers and spark a wave of new providers that will echo the boom in highly localized ISPs of the 1990s, claims xG. However, there are problems with the analogy. The ISPs were riding a new internet wave, in which the larger providers had not yet got their own business models right, while VoIP and wireless services are already well established, even in many rural areas because of the influence of Wi-Fi, and the main issue is how any provider can make money by providing bandwidth for Skype and the others (not to mention the fact that most of those mom-and-pop ISPs failed in the end anyway).
Despite these notes of caution, there clearly is still a gap in the rural market, especially in the US, where it has been hard to find a technology that can supply true broadband cost-effectively to a sparse population, where there could be just a handful of homes in the reach of one base station. Solutions that can achieve long range without breaking power regulations and can deliver high data rates for low capex are required, and if xMAX lives up to its claims, it would certainly fulfil those criteria. The technology, which has been certified to meet FCC radio emissions limits, has been demonstrated to transmit 40Mbps of data over 15 miles using less than 1W of power. The company release states that: ‘small companies, institutions, and communities can deploy wireless VoIP networks for thousands rather than millions of dollars.” (The technology has so far been approved only in the US.)
But all the wireless technologies have been chasing this rare untapped market. Extended range Wi-Fi solutions ‘ especially in the US with its relatively high power allowances ‘ have been followed by proprietary solutions and early WiMAX offerings. One problem has been the lack of spectrum choices ‘ with most licensed bands accounted for, the main options are 900MHz, which supports long range but is noisy, and 5.8GHz, less congested but with short range and no near-line of sight flexibility, making cell site location a potential obstacle. The FCC’s opening up of 3.65GHz frequencies under a light licensing scheme geared largely to rural access should help, but the perfect solution certainly has not been found yet. The closest have probably been proprietary, fairly low cost 5.8GHz solutions like Motorola Canopy, plus the promise of the 802.16e standard and its forerunners, such as Navini Ripwave, which increase spectral efficiency and range through use of smart antenna techniques like smart beamforming and MIMO.
With all these options on offer, or imminent, is there room for another, and one that, even if its specifications meet the needs of the rural WISPs better than existing technologies, has yet to attract large vendor backing, and therefore the prospect of volume and consequent commodity pricing?
xG seems to have recognized this problem to some extent, taking a leaf out of the book of early WiMAX players by piggybacking on the wide availability of Wi-Fi to try to accelerate early uptake of its systems. The handsets will work with Wi-Fi hotspots as well as xMAX systems.
Hedging its bets somewhat, xG also says it is after the enterprise point-to-point market, working with contract manufacturers to put its chipset into a wireless broadband ‘Ethernet extender’ with a range of about 20 miles for applications such as bridging two sites or providing back-up for a wired network. It claims it would offer far lower costs than the usual solutions for this space, digital microwave, or even point-to-point WiMAX.
However, even if the somewhat vaguely explained advantages of its technology prove real and robust, xG is still fighting for OEM and customer attention with better established, better backed and better marketed platforms. The original idea outlined by the company’s founders almost a year ago, to offer the xMAX technology purely as a physical layer on which other vendors could build MAC layers based on WiMAX or other standards, would have served it better, enabling its breakthroughs to be adopted by large players without posing a threat to their own products and roadmaps.
The technology
At first glance xMAX has resemblances to UltraWideBand, in that it uses such low power that it operates below the spectral floor, but delivers very high data rates, up to 40Mbps. However, its techniques are different to the rapid succession of pulses used by classic UWB and it can operate at longer ranges (up to 15 miles). It claims to deliver broadband rates in narrow bands without interfering with other spectrum users.
Its secret is its own xG Flash Signaling, which transmits data at power levels up to 100,000 times below FCC limits (and, it claims up to 10,000 times below that of UWB). Unlike other wireless technologies that move as much power as possible from the carrier into the information bearing sidebands, xMax does the opposite, using the Flash Signalling technique to keep sideband information carrying to just 1% of total power. The method takes a narrowband carrier at any frequency and modulates a single RF cycle to create a very brief, low power signal. This merely coordinates the sender and receiver, while the actual data is transmitted in a wideband Flash Signal out of band, but at power levels that are lower than those permitted by regulators for unintentional out of band emissions.
The technology only needs a narrow segment of unoccupied spectrum (1MHz to 100MHz depending on application can be supported) within any band to deliver broadband data rates, which makes it viable for use in sub-1GHz frequencies. Although these are ideal for wireless networks because they support long range and high mobility, they are normally divided into very small segments, limiting the services that carriers can deliver and forcing them up to the higher bands. Here, far more base stations are required to cover a given area, raising costs.
There are three modes of operation for xMax. The first is normal mode, where it shares spectrum with other occupiers but well below FCC requirements for out of band emissions, so that interference is not created. The second mode is aimed at eventual approval in Europe, where intentional out of band emissions are not allowed at all, and so the signal is reshaped to ensure that it falls in a predictable place. The third option suppresses the carrier and just sends out the flash signal, which supports lower data rates (25% lower) but improves battery life.