We labeled the company the reluctant Virgin when we revealed that Virgin Mobile was being courted by UK cable TV company NTL, but this week the Virgin said yes and accepted the marriage proposal to create one of Europe’s biggest quadruple play operations. The deal is valued at $1.69bn, a rise from the original offer of $1.4bn and comes with the endorsement of all the non-Virgin Group board members that control Virgin Mobile. More than that, it sets a pattern for creating fixed/mobile converged players that is sure to be emulated across Europe.
Behind the deal is the NTL existing management, but also the cavalier music entrepreneur, turned transatlantic flight operator, Richard Branson, who will end up trading his 72% in the Virgin Mobile MVNO for a 14% slice of the converged quadruple play, once NTL also merges with Telewest, lumping all UK cable franchises into a single entity.
The company will have the right to use the Virgin brand and will pay an annual royalty of 0.25% of relevant consumer revenues, a minimum of £8.5m, to Branson’s Virgin Enterprises. Virgin is almost a global brand, massively popular among youth culture and is accepted as one of the major reasons that the MVNO took off so well both in the UK and the US.
When we first sniffed the deal we wondered what role could be carved out for Virgin Mobile in the US and Australia, and the valuation is all the more remarkable given that neither of these entities are involved in the deal, with their shares being held higher up the Virgin Group’s food chain. These can continue or be sold off or used to broker other quadruple play deals, as Branson sees fit. All of the Virgin MVNO deals ride on the T-Mobile network, which has already given its blessing to the required changes in the UK operation.
The transaction is complicated by the fact that NTL is a US stock, owned in dollars, while it operates entirely in the UK. It was once owned by US Bellcos before a debt-for-equity swap drove its shareholding back into the hands of its US and European bankers. The company trades in British pounds and the transaction price in the merger agreement is in pounds too.
The deal is offered in any of shares, shares and cash, or just cash, but with Branson opting for mostly stock, the financial cost to the group is expected to be $832m in cash, with some $726m in shareholder pay-outs and the rest in refinancing of existing Virgin Mobile debt, and some deal costs. This will be met by the existing debt holders for NTL plus some of its cash holdings. Both operations throw off cash, so no further cash is expected to be required to fund it going forwards.
By June the merged entity will consist of the combined NTL and Telewest businesses, with 3.3m cable TV customers and 2.5m broadband internet customers, plus 4.3m fixed phone customers, with Virgin contributing just under 2m of its total 5m mobile customers, (the remaining 3m are in the US and Australia).
This will also be one of the first companies to market in the UK with a mobile TV strategy and it will have at least one year’s headstart on all the competition, working as it is with BT’s Movio service (which will form the only other competition with its own Vodafone-based MVNO) which uses a raw IP version of Digital Audio Broadcast to send TV channels to mobile phones using existing spectrum. The effect on the youth market in the UK will be that it ends up believing that Virgin invented affordable mobile TV, especially music TV on the phone. This service relies on Microsoft Mobile-based smartphones and will represent a breakthrough for Microsoft in mobile TV.
This deal does in the UK what the US cable companies’ joint agreement with Sprint did in the US, opening up the battle lines for a full quadruple play and beyond, including mobile voice, mobile music and data and mobile TV, and fixed voice services combined with broadband internet access and cable TV/IPTV video services. Sprint and a collection of US cable operators announced a deal in November to take cable TV directly onto a mobile phone over a likely three-year timeframe.
Standing opposite this new Virgin group will be British Telecom, also planning services across each of those dimensions, and the News Corp-owned BSkyB, already delivering broadband film services alongside its satellite TV play. BSkyB has also recently bought Easynet, a UK broadband supplier that unbundles internet lines at local BT exchanges. Sky just did its first mobile TV deal last year, offering some of its programming on the Vodafone service.
There are still hurdles for this deal to overcome, but this increased and accepted offer has already got over the most important problem, the reluctance of the non-Virgin board to support the price of the deal. Although NTL shareholders will not be required to vote, other hurdles include more than 50% of the non-Virgin shareholder vote accepting both the terms of the deal and the terms of the Virgin royalty, and it needs the nod from the UK competition authority, but both seem likely.
We believe that this deal will set a template for convergence across all of Europe, with many countries such as France, Italy and Germany ready for four-way convergence, each getting their mobile TV acts together in different ways with the involvement of content players, broadcasters and mobile operators.
As such it is likely that what may become known as Virgin TV, will be one of the first quadruple plays in Europe to establish a public flotation valuation to serve as an indicator for the rest of European media.
One issue that the new Virgin-branded NTL will have to overcome is its appalling service record with consumers in its cable TV operations. This was clearly a point of concern for Branson, who insisted that the deal included a director from Virgin, possibly himself, and a marketing director imported from the group as an employee. We believe that the Virgin brand will be enough to overcome the past, unappealing record of NTL, but not if it continues to offer sloppy service and indifferent call centre attitudes to consumers, something that would soil the Virgin name, and likely to lead to future boardroom battles.
Many other cable operators around Europe, mostly in the hands of private equity groups, will be jockeying for position with local media brands, but none of them are likely to have the modern cabling mix of mostly digital cable, and a stated intention that continued infrastructure build out, will be purely IP, and over DSL at that.
NTL decided a year ago that building out more cable was too expensive and that in the local loop unbundling regulatory environment of Europe, it would using a double pronged ADSL2+ strategy. This involves putting ADSL2+ across the existing phone lines it laid alongside its cable, which are for the most part just 1,000 feet from fiber for the 8m homes that its cable passes, plus it will install its own ADSL2+ capable DSLAMs into the 300 most popular British Telecom telephone exchanges, spending $117m in the process, for those that are not currently passed by NTL cable.
NTL and Telewest have already announced their own merger, to be complete any time now, and they have said that after deal costs and integration issues are resolved they will be generating at least $440m a year in free cashflow, sometime before 2008.