Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

10 April 2006

Sarin takes bold move with new innovation unit for Vodafone

Having weathered his recent shareholder storm somewhat by selling the ailing Vodafone Japan unit, the cellco’s CEO Arun Sarin is building on his reprieve with clear signals that major change is to come to keep Vodafone competitive. We have already heard him talking up strategic shifts such as moves to fixed/mobile convergence, and now he is turning his attention to corporate structure, with a reorganization into three new business groups.

These groups are Europe ‘ by which Vodafone means its western European heartlands, now facing cut-throat competition and near-saturation; Central Europe, Middle East, Asia Pacific and affiliates, the key geographic growth regions for the company; and Business and Innovation, which will focus on new revenue streams. The thinking is that each of these requires an entirely different set of priorities and strategies, even while drawing on the global purchasing scale of Vodafone, and with cost reduction critical to all three.

The main objective of Bill Morrow, head of Europe (and currently head of Vodafone Japan), will be to drive operational efficiency and cost cuts, and to work on a more pan-regional scale to support these aims. Morrow was transferred to Japan as a last ditch attempt to rescue operations there, and was widely seen as one of the only Vodafone executives with the operational excellence to have a chance of success there. His remit also includes technology and marketing functions for the whole global organization, keeping procurement and branding unified ‘ both crucial to the business model.

In addition, Tim Miles will move from his role as head of Vodafone UK to become chief technology officer and will be succeeded by Nick Read, currently UK chief commercial officer.

Morrow’s counterpart in the other regions, Paul Donovan ‘ currently head of OVS (Other Vodafone Subsidiaries) – will be looking at profitable growth in new or emerging markets, new acquisitions and the shift to 3G. This unit will also swallow up the current Emerging Markets operation, and will house joint ventures, affiliates and investments for the whole group, including Verizon Wireless, China Mobile, Vodacom (Africa) and SFR in France.

The third and most interesting unit will look to ‘capture new revenue streams by extending its reach into converged and IP services’. This means that its head, Thomas Geitner, currently the group’s chief technology officer, will be looking well beyond W-CDMA and HSDPA, towards other wireless and wireline IP networks and the chances for a cellco to play as a converged quadruple play operator.

Geitner’s job is by far the hardest of the three. The other two units are all about what Vodafone has learned to do well in the years since its buccaneering heyday under Chris Gent’s leadership. In more difficult times, it has become increasingly strong in operational efficiency, leveraging its own scale for branding and cost economies, and making less dramatic but more immediately generative acquisitions. In considering multi-technology strategies and thinking out of the box about business models and IP, it has been less impressive, at least in public, and its defense of W-CDMA/HSxPA as the only technology a large cellco needs has become hollow sounding.

By creating the new unit, Sarin has given Geitner, and the organization as a whole, the capacity and support to be more creative and to build a new approach that will keep Vodafone ahead. Geitner’s job may depend on success, but so, to a large extent, does Sarin’s, and the ability of Vodafone to remain in the forefront of wireless as it enters the converged IP age. Creating such a new unit is belated, but a very strong move all the same from a CEO who is showing signs that adversity may be giving him new determination to move beyond the legacies of the Gent era and stamp his own imprint on the company as it faces entirely new challenges.

Shareholder turmoil:

Arun Sarin may be showing his mettle, and his inherent understanding of the complex market he is in, but he remains hampered by short termist and backbiting shareholders and, in some cases, executives. Damaging leaks from deep within the company continue, has do public and semi-public spats between various factions. A reorganization may help create unity and purpose, but that will take time, and in the meantime, major shareholders are demanding further changes in the boardroom. Their requirements are now said to include the dismissal of the company’s deputy chairman, Paul Hazen, a close associate of Sarin, with critics claiming he is not really independent and acts more like a mentor of Sarin than an objective voice on the board.

Many are also concerned that outgong chairman Lord MacLaurin, a representative of the Chris Gent ‘ancien regime’ will stay on as advisor and chairman of Vodafone’s charitable trust after he is succeeded by HSBC chairman Sir John Bond, a ‘new broom’, on July 1. Many investors believe this does not bode well for future harmony and unity.