The US DSL providers will soon come under their greatest challenge for years as Sprint and the major cable operators start to test their promised quadruple play services, delivering voice, video and data to the home network and the mobile device.This will be a closely watched trial by many cable operators round the world, and also by the leading wireless-only cellcos, which are considering their own response to combined DSL-mobile offerings ‘ whether through cable alliances or by moving into the wireline space under their own steam.
Sprint and its joint venture with Time Warner Cable, Cox, Comcast and Advance/Newhouse Communications said it will its quadruple play in seven test markets in the second half of this year, though in the first phase, although billing will be combined ‘ a key consumer requirement ‘ the integration of services will be at a basic level compared to the grand vision that Sprint has outlined of a full set of services delivered, with a common interface, to multiple devices in future.
Some early moves in this direction, however, will include the facility to call up the cable TV program guide from the cellphone to see show listings, to talk at no charge between mobile phones and home phones, and to check email on their handsets if they subscribe to cable high speed data services. Within three years, however, these small beginnings are set to expand into a range of multimedia, content-oriented integrated services that Sprint says will be broader in range than those of the dominant Bell operators with their own large scale quad play and IPTV plans over DSL, fiber and mobile networks.
The cablecos know that integration is key to increasing customer loyalty and revenue and making their bundles more attractive than the sum of their parts. ‘Simply adding cellphone service to our bundle is probably not all that interesting for consumers,” Glenn Britt, CEO of Time Warner Cable, said recently.
The initial test markets will be Comcast territories Austin, Texas and Raleigh, North Carolina; Comcast’s Portland, Oregon and an unidentified New England city; and three further undisclosed markets in Cox and Advance/Newhouse footprints.
Just as initial services are starting to be defined, so Sprint is working on suitable devices. One of its key promises is that subscribers will be able to watch TV shows recorded on their home digital video recorders on their handsets, a capability that may well be addressed by evolutions of the planned Motorola portable DVR (see separate item).
Also, Sprint’s release of a Linksys EV-DO/WLan bridge (see separate item) is likely an early attempt to woo DSL subscribers with a wireless-only approach. By turning the EV-DO link into a shared Wi-Fi connection in the home, effectively using the cellular network for backhaul, the user can bypass DSL (and the phone line) altogether. Such products will not scare the DSL operators yet, partly because EV-DO subscriptions are around $60 a month, compared to under $20 for many DSL offerings (though the user must have the phone line too); and also because EV-DO is far slower than wireline alternatives. However, they do show the way the wireless carriers are moving and the future potential to bypass DSL, one that is considerably strengthened, of course, by the cable alliance and by Sprint’s future addition of faster broadband wireless technology to the mix through its 2.5GHz roll-out.
“We definitely think that EV-DO Revision A makes a compelling case for replacing broadband connections,” said Barry Tishgart, director of product marketing for Sprint Nextel. “And beyond that, whatever 4G technology we choose in the future could be something that provides a wireless broadband service that is as good or better than DSL and cable.”
The debate on whether EV-DO Rev A and HSDPA can take on DSL to offer a broadband triple play rages, but before these wireless technologies pass critical milestones such as mass market affordable product roll-out, successful demonstration of indoor penetration and all-IP support, the wireless-only operators are considering the wireline technologies too. This is especially true in Europe where local loop unbundling rules could give providers like Vodafone and O2 ‘ soon to be owned by Telefonica ‘ the chance to become DSL providers themselves. The recent creation of a new division of Vodafone, dedicated to business and innovation, was partly aimed at assessing converged IP options under the leadership of former CTO Thomas Geitner (see Wireless Watch April 10 2006 issue). While Vodafone could wholesale DSL services from other carriers, its focus on convergence under an IP Multimedia Subsystem and its need to support multiple territories could lead it to build out its own networks, and talk is rife that it has already been in talks with DSL equipment and IMS vendor Alcatel. Analysts are also looking for Vodafone to use some of the proceeds of its sale of its Japanese unit to buy wireline providers, with Tiscali, the UK’s Pipex, Italy’s FastWeb and Spain’s Jazztel possible candidates, according to James Enck of Daiwa Securities SMBC Europe. Vodafone said any fixed broadband issues would be part of its current strategic review, the outcome of which will be revealed next month.
As part of Telefonica, which is already converging its fixed and mobile networks in some territories such as the Czech Republic, O2 is likely to be part of the extension of that process, but could also look for wireline partners or build-out in areas where its parent does not have DSL, such as the UK. Here, it has been talking to Fujitsu about possible fixed deployment, the vendor confirmed. Some smaller mobile operators have already invested in DSL ‘ Belgium’s Mobistar installed Alcatel equipment and now has 3,000 converged subscribers.
A few years ago, a mobile operator saddling itself with a wireline network would have been unthinkable ‘ now, as converged fixed/mobile services become de rigeur, 3G margins come under pressure and DSL equipment gets cheaper, the wireless-only providers look less attractive. With Sprint setting the pace, a wave of alliances with cable/DSL owners, or even network build-outs, are likely to follow in the mobile community.
EV-DO Rev B
As operators weigh up their technology choices for delivering fixed/mobile converged broadband, Qualcomm knows that the long term survival of its CDMA platform depends partly on the ability to perform in that market. It has strengthened its hand by focusing on OFDM systems, such as Flash-OFDM and MediaFLO, that can work alongside CDMA networks and are likely to be the basis of a next generation, OFDM-oriented upgrade path. But it is also rapidly accelerating the enhancement of CDMA2000 itself, particularly to support all-IP and to rival wireline networks for fixed broadband delivery.
Qualcomm has often scored from its strong awareness of the changing needs of cellular operators, and its willingness to adapt its roadmap with considerable agility to meet these ‘ an advantage denied to the multi-headed GSM/W-CDMA giant. Thus it canned EV-DV, the original successor to the currently installed EV-DO Rev 0, when it saw limited operator interest. As cellco preoccupations with moving to all-IP and fixed/mobile convergence grew, Qualcomm saw EV-DV, which would have added voice capabilities to the 3G platform, as a sideline, and instead chose to add advanced VoIP and quality of service to EV-DO, originally a data-only enhancement (a happy side effect for Qualcomm was to wrongfoot Texas Instruments, which had put most of its R&D efforts surrounding its entry into the CDMA chip market around EV-DV.)
The shift led to the rapid introduction of enhancements to EV-DO ‘ first Rev A, which boosts data rates and supports VoIP, and now Rev B, with a further implementation, supporting variable channel sizes and so more competitive with WiMAX, to come next. Sprint and Verizon Wireless – the main US-based CDMA carriers and the customers Qualcomm most desperately wants to keep loyal, since their choices are closely watched round the world ‘ are already adding Rev A support and now the chip giant says Rev B data modems will be ready in late 2007, trebling downlink and uplink rates.
Compared to Rev 0’s download speed of 400-700Kbps and upload of 50-70Kbps, Rev A boosts the former by one-third and the latter twofold. Rev B should triple download and double upload speeds, says Qualcomm, promising average speeds to the consumer of 1.3-2.4Mbps on the downlink and 210-432Kbps on the uplink. This would bring EV-DO within realistic shooting distance of mobile WiMAX as well as HSDPA, and Qualcomm claims would make it a viable alternative to DSL.
“I believe that as we move to EV-DO Rev A and then to Rev B, we’ll start to have the speeds that are needed to match fixed broadband,” said the company. “But whether or not consumers decide to go with wireless broadband over a DSL service depends on the operators’ business models.”
The other key enhancement in Rev B is to support multiple channels, where the operator has these available. By combining three channels, download speed can be 14.7Mbps and the company says future high performance devices could boost this to over 73Mbps using its FLO (forward link only) OFDM technology integrated with EV-DO. This parallels the W-CDMA community’s development of its own next generation, which will also support IP and OFDM forward links, called LTE (Long Term Evolution). At this stage, these two technologies and WiMAX will start to look increasingly similar, and increasingly viable for fixed broadband.