In the wake of the Alcatel-Lucent merger plan, the other major vendors are keen to reposition themselves for the changed market, as speculation swirls over which of them will acquire, or be snapped up, next. Each needs to convince the market that it has a differentiated value add, as core equipment products become increasingly commoditized, and hardware becomes a business of scale.
Ericsson CEO Carl Henric Svanberg, while dismissing the possibility of his company making a mega-acquisition of its own, said consolidation is good for the industry since too many vendor choices makes for over-complexity and actually deter operator spending.
Svanberg said Ericsson would pursue small and medium-sized acquisitions plus partnerships to complement its R&D program, rather than looking to a huge merger. Ericsson’s particular focuses in the coming few years will be IMS, IPTV and highly mobile broadband ‘ although it is strengthening its wireline activities following its purchase of Marconi, it knows its strength is in mobility rather than convergence, and it may need to seek wireline partners if it really does stay away from further large acquisitions. In particular, Svanberg is hoping that mobile TV will become the powerhouse he predicts. He also played down the threat from China’s Huawei and ZTE, saying these vendors were under greater pressure now that they had to compete on product management and customer support, not just low prices and breadth of range.
‘The Chinese are there, and they will be big, and they will be strong. But on the other hand, we may have seen their strongest offerings,’ he told the briefing.
Nortel, one of the vendors most tipped to be acquired ‘ with Cisco still a possible contender ‘ has the biggest job to do to assure customers and investors of its staying power. In the wake of financial scandals and losses, new CEO Mike Zafirovski is taking a dual approach of focusing on markets where Nortel has real impact, and either exiting the rest or partnering with another company, as it did with its recent broad-based alliance with Huawei. He said at a recent briefing that Nortel would consider quitting any market in which it holds less than 6% share, and that the key new areas where it believes it can achieve differentiation and leadership are WiMAX and IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS).
With WiMAX, Nortel hopes to broaden its base to include alternative operators such as satellite companies, and to build on its advanced developments in areas such as metrozone mesh.
Like competitors such as Motorola, it knows its differentiation in the converged market will come from software, as hardware becomes increasingly standardized around platforms like ATCA (Advanced Telecommunications Computing Architecture). In IMS, it will focus on software and some key products where it has strong presence, such as session border controllers, while relying on partners for other elements of an end-to-end platform. It recently, for instance, quit the edge router business, and turned to Huawei for other products.
Over at Nokia, the recent CTIA show saw the farewell of outgoing CEO Jorma Olilla, the man who transformed the company from stagnant conglomerate to cellphone powerhouse, and who, on his departure, laid down clear markers for Nokia’s differentiation strategy in the new century. Priorities will be making the mobile handset the dominant client device in the mobile enterprise, replacing the landline phone and impinging on the laptop PC; and taking the number one spot in the US from Motorola.
After 13 years, Olilla will be replaced by Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, currently president and chief operating officer. Some investors have been disappointed that Nokia has taken the opposite path from Motorola, when it appointed its own new CEO two years ago. Instead of importing a new broom, as Motorola did with the successful Ed Zander ‘ prompting Mike Zafirowski, who would have been the ‘safe’ internal candidate, to move to the Nortel top job ‘ Nokia has gone with Kallasvuo, a 26-year veteran of the company and close associate of Olllia. Of course, the situation is very different ‘ Motorola was floundering under an ill-regarded CEO, while Nokia has, despite some recent blips, had a strong record of growth and innovation under Olilla.
The main doubts voiced about Kallasvuo are that he is a strong operational man ‘ one of his previous posts was as CFO ‘ but may not be up to the big strategic questions facing Nokia, such as whether to stay in the networks equipment business, an issue that is made more urgent by the Lucent-Alcatel merger, which displaces Nokia as number two vendor of mobile network infrastructure after Ericsson. Olilla was best known for his brave strategic thinking ‘ from dumping Nokia’s non-mobile phone businesses at the start of his tenure to going up against Microsoft, more recently, with a multipronged bid to make the handset into ‘the new PC’.
Richard Winsor, Nokia analyst at Nomura, voiced the fears of many, saying: ‘The biggest question mark I still have with Olli-Pekka is his strategic depth. Operationally he is superb, but a large part of the CEO’s job is to select a strategic direction and ensure the company follows it.’
Olilla has left his successor with strong foundations, with a well thought-out, if radical, strategy for the rest of the decade ‘ focused on middleware, mobile enterprise and making the handset the universal focus of converged telephony as well as the universal business and leisure client device. Though with less fanfare than Motorola, and without ‘ as yet ‘ an iconic product like the RAZR phone, Olilla has also reversed the financial dip of 2004 and left most of the business in good shape. Last year, Nokia reversed three years of sales declines by reporting net income of €3.6bn on revenue of €34.2bn. Recently, Nokia increased its estimate for annual industry growth for mobile devices to 15% for 2006, from 10% and then said that average selling prices for its mobile phones rose to €103 in the first quarter from €99 in the last period of 2005, after four quarters of decline.
Given this, perhaps an operations man, who can deliver on the strategy rather than having dramatically to rethink it, is not a bad choice for Nokia, and as former head of the handsets division, Kallasvuo should be well prepared for the toughest short term challenges, maintaining 30% market share in a commoditizing market and fending off the rejuvenated Motorola, especially in the US.
His other urgent issue will certainly be addressing the infrastructure market and Nokia’s place in it. Although it will still be number three in wireless equipment after the Alcatel deal is finalized, this is a small part of its total business and increasingly, its focus on broadening the role of the handset could be better served by working with influential equipment makers than against them. With many of the infrastructure vendors taking the opposite course and getting out of handsets ‘ Alcatel and Siemens, with even Ericsson spinning phones off into its joint venture with Sony ‘ there could be unprecedented chances for Nokia to cooperate with former competitors, and strengthen the attack on Microsoft, which would have no such inroads into the major networks giants.
Should Kallasvuo keep the Networks division long term ‘ and Nokia still believes there is competitive advantage in selling both base stations and handsets as a package ‘ he will need to look at the question of fixed/mobile convergence, and whether to seek to build up a wireline business through acquisition, as Ericsson is doing, or to rely on partnerships.
With the naturally converged vendors ‘ Lucent-Alcatel, Motorola and Nortel, plus the Chinese duo ‘ clearly at an advantage here, after years of being hampered by their wireline legacies, Nokia will need some radical thought to keep its networks business strong rather than selling it off. Against the backdrop of the new industry picture created by Alcatel’s move, this will be the first big challenge of Kallasvuo’s strategic abilities.