In each wave of technology, a chipmaker emerges that has a key impact on the direction of far larger players. Sometimes the company goes on to build an empire of its own, as Qualcomm did, more frequently it gets acquired by a giant. In 802.16e, that chipmaker appears to be Beceem Communications, which was an important contributor to the standard and its profiles, and has now scored a hat trick of major investments from key players ‘ Samsung, Intel and most recently, and most intriguingly, Japanese cellco NTT DoCoMo.
We believe the DoCoMo investment is more significant than a major operator and technology developer merely increasing its understanding of an emerging platform. The Japanese giant is by nature an enemy of WiMAX, since it has been one of the greatest contributors to the W-CDMA standard and its upgrades, and has not welcomed any network that could threaten 3G in mobile broadband data applications. However, DoCoMo is part of the larger NTT group ‘ and no longer the undisputed financial star of the group either. Like all incumbent telcos, NTT is focusing heavily on fixed/mobile convergence, and earlier this year started WiMAX trials that involve DoCoMo as well as its fixed broadband units. The investment in Beceem, in the short term, should support those trials, but longer term, it indicates the increasing likelihood that the 802.16e and 3GPP agendas will merge. Though most of the impetus for a combined effort to create a single ‘4G’ standard has so far come from the WiMAX community ‘ especially as it sees the HSDPA and CDMA2000 technologies accelerating their evolution routes to respond to 802.16e ‘ there will also be considerable interest from 3G players in avoiding a head-to-head battle. Two considerations could persuade a 3G aficionado like DoCoMo to embrace 802.16e as part of a merged roadmap ‘ the need to attract the wireline-driven converged operators rather than let them fall to WiMAX; and the potential to retain control of the 4G agenda by adopting and driving a combined standard, rather than taking on the likes of Intel in a straight fight.
The fixed performance of 802.16e, combined with the promise of mobility and support for all-IP, is its main differentiator from HSDPA and CDMA EV-DO, and makes it a natural choice for a converged operator, especially one that either lacks a mobile arm, like BT, or in which the wireline operations call the shots ‘ an increasingly common situation, as NTT itself shows, as pressure on mobile revenues and margins takes some of the shine off the cellular units. In this situation, it could be advantageous for 3G players like DoCoMo to take WiMAX to their hearts to strengthen their own future roadmap without losing control of the development agenda.
In particular, 3G and WiMAX evolution share a focus on certain key technologies such a MIMO smart antennas, and these are one factor in the appeal of Beceem. “We have chosen to invest in Beceem due to its advanced technology position in wireless technology, especially when it comes to MIMO and smart antenna techniques. This relationship will give us a good view of the capabilities of the wireless broadband technology as we investigate the future of OFDMA-based wireless broadband solutions,” said Nobuyuki Akimoto, CEO of DoCoMo Capital, in a statement.
Last month Intel invested an undisclosed but ‘substantial’ sum in Beceem, and a partnership to ‘accelerate the trial and deployment of mobile WiMAX networks’. In December, it received more than $20m in C-round financing led by Samsung Ventures America, the US-based venture capital arm of Samsung Venture Investment Corporation (SVIC).
The company shipped its first WiMAX digital baseband and integrated radio chipset in January. The MS120 chipset is built to the 802.16e profile, to which Beceem contributed, though there will be no certification of this until mid-2006. It is targeted at handsets and PDAs and Beceem is also shipping a reference design kit for the WiMAX modem, including host driver software.