The US’ largest providers of dial-up ISP services need to transition that base as quickly as possible to broadband, without losing too many customers, a balance that the leaders, AOL and Earthlink, have found tough. In the past year, Earthlink has proved the more aggressive about using wireless as a way to offer broadband migration while circumventing the telcos’ and cablecos’ ownership of the broadband lines, but now AOL is hitting back with an alliance with Clearwire.
This is overdue, though perhaps signalled by AOL Canada’s earlier trial of the Canadian Inukshuk network, which is closely associated with Clearwire. Earthlink has set the pace in using wireless as a broadband alternative. It has projects from its extensive metrozone plans, working with Google and Motorola, to its joint venture with SK Telecom, whose first fruit is the newly launched Helio MVNO, but which is also likely to expand into broadband wireless. AOL, though it has been sounding out wireless partners in and beyond the US for more than two years, has been remarkably tentative, although it has been more successful than Earthlink in using cable alliances to avoid the telco DSL lines, because of its alliance with sister company Time Warner Cable. (Though to complicate the picture, Time Warner Cable’s own wireless network partner is Sprint Nextel, and it is ever rumored to be interested in acquiring its own cellular spectrum.)
This is not just about its access business of course. AOL is also engaged in a bitter battle with the other major internet portal and advertising players, Google and MSN, not to mention newer challengers like eBay/Skype. All these companies are hunting network partners to increase the reach and revenue of their offerings. They are all having some success with the cellcos, creating versions of their services for the mobile handsets; but the relationships with the wireline and wireless network owners are clearly difficult, with AT&T and others unable to exclude such strong internet content players from their ecosystems, but also increasingly resentful of the fact that the open internet generates huge amounts of traffic and virtually no incremental revenue for the infrastructure owner.
One way for the internet companies to strengthen their position in the balance with the telcos is to create an alternative system that they control entirely, and which therefore is a threat to the incumbent. Google is doing this by funding the creation of wireless metrozones, and possibly investing in spectrum, and has found its most logical partner in Earthlink. AOL has both Google’s and Earthlink’s motivations ‘ expanded service reach and a dial-up migration route – rolled into one company and so faced the choice of building its own wireless networks, or identifying a partner with such a network, and with an interest in disrupting the major Bell telcos. Before the Sprint Nextel merger, this was widely expected to be Nextel, but with the combined company not rolling out its first territories for over a year, Clearwire offers the advantage of immediacy, since it is building out new territories rapidly, many in strong dial-up bases. Also, AOL wireless subscribers will receive the Clearwire/NextNet modem, whose portability and strong design is an attraction to operators, and which, in future, will support the mobile WiMAX standard 802.16e. This could take AOL into the mobile broadband market without being dependent on the 3G operators, a factor that could prove highly disruptive by the end of the decade.
All this leaves the obvious question ‘ what about the third internet portal giant, Microsoft MSN? Microsoft has been investing in broadband wireless ventures since the first, abortive boom of the turn of the century, and may even bid to acquire spectrum of its own in forthcoming cellular or 700MHz auctions. It will certainly be weighing up its own likely partners, to ensure it is not leapfrogged by its younger rivals, with its new closeness to Qualcomm one possible clue (see separate item). Its negotiations with any partner will be complicated by its need to control not just the access but the device used for that access ‘ the PC, laptop, console and now the smartphone. This will make large operators that might otherwise be logical allies ‘ notably Sprint Nextel ‘ wary of a partner that will want to push client and server software architectures, not just internet services, upon them. Also, of course, Microsoft will not want to be too antagonistic to the wireline telcos to which it aims to sell major products such as its IPTV technology.
Google’s and AOL’s indifference to the equipment underpinning their services makes their lives simpler, and those of their partners. For Clearwire, the AOL agreement is a major coup even for renowned dealmaker McCaw, delivering it a route to market that still has a well recognized brand and considerable marketing and content clout. This should boost usage of its network at a far more rapid rate than it could achieve on its own, and in turn this will generate revenues for faster expansion of the system across the US. AOL has 20m customers in the US, and although it has suffered serious subscriber declines in recent years, this base still offers strong potential for Clearwire.
Clearwire’s network is now live in 200 cities and towns in Alaska, California, Florida, Hawaii, Idaho, Minnesota, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin, plus Ireland, Belgium, Denmark and Mexico. The AOL-branded version of the service will kick off in four of the US locations, Jacksonville and Daytona Beach, Florida and Stockton and Modesto, California. It also has an extensive partnership with the Canadian NextNet-based service being created by Inukshuk, a joint venture of Bell Canada and Rogers, and which AOL’s Canadian arm could well use for wireless offerings. Clearwire recently started providing Bell Canada-licensed VoIP on its US system and boasts major investment from the telco.
The new AOL service will be badged ‘AOL High Speed ‘ Powered by Clearwire’, the latter half of the name largely aimed to build confidence among Clearwire investors and fear among competitors, rather than to appeal to the consumer public. Clearwire has always said it would use some of its capacity to lease out to ‘virtual operators’, a system that Sprint Nextel will also adopt through its joint venture with four large cablecos, and creating its own consumer brand is likely, long term, to be the least vital aspect of its growth strategy.
AOL High Speed will offer tariffs from $25.90 a month for a 768Kbps/128Kbps service, with a faster version delivering 1.5Mbps/256Kbps. Subscribers will gain access to AOL content and other features such as online storage. “This innovative approach to broadband access offers consumers additional levels of freedom and flexibility in how and where they experience AOL’s content and services – and stands to be a promising feature for new consumer segments,” commented Joe Redling, president of AOL’s access business, in a statement.
With the combination of Clearwire and Time Warner Cable networks, AOL is taking significant steps to creating an alternative infrastructure to enable it to compete with the Bell operators in broadband access and accelerate the dumping of its legacy dial-up base. In keeping up with Google and MSN in internet portals, it has scored the advantage of a wireless delivery network that is, partially at least, already in place, unlike Google’s metrozones or the future Sprint Nextel 2.5GHz system. With AOL snatching back a little of the momentum lost to Google/Earthlink, the next and most interesting move rests with Microsoft.
Time Warner/AOL results
Cable television was the highlight of Time Warner’s recently announced first quarter, offsetting worsening results at AOL.
Time Warner Cable accounted for 25% of $10.5bn in total revenue for the quarter, up 1% on the year earlier, and 35% of operating income of $2.7bn, which was up 8%. Net income rose 59% to $1.46bn. However, investors were unimpressed, pushing shares of Time Warner down 20 cents to $17.22.
The company said the main reason for its cable growth was bundling of internet access, phone and digital cable services, an approach it hopes to enhance with the addition of mobile offerings via the Sprint Nextel alliance from later this year.
AOL’s results were worse than expected, with revenues down 7% to $2bn. Analysts blamed slower than hoped-for transition to the web portal business model, even as the dial-up business erodes. US subscribers totaled 18.6m at the end of the quarter, 3.1m fewer than in the period a year earlier. Advertising revenue across AOL’s subscription and heavily promoted free sites rose 26%.
Executives said it was too soon to assess the success of converting dial-up subscribers to broadband services, but thought they would be able to make a prediction when subscriber figures stabilized later this year. “I think the initial returns are largely in the right direction. It’s too early to run up the victory flag,” said CEO Richard Parsons.
New rules in the BRS/EBS band:
While Sprint Nextel and Clearwire hold the largest swathes of spectrum around 2.5GHz in the US, significant bandwidth in the 2496-2690MHz range is also owned by educational and religious organizations, a legacy of when the FCC earmarked the frequencies, then called ITFS, for educational broadcasting. In 2004, the regulator reorganized the whole band ‘ ITFS and the commercial portion, formerly known as MDS ‘ renaming it BRS/EBS (broadband radio service/educational broadband service) and aiming to make it less fragmented. It also relaxed the rules to make it easier for the educational owners to lease out their holdings to commercial operators and so stimulate broadband wireless roll-out and competitive services. Before this, schools were only able to lease excess capacity via a body called the ITFS Alliance, which was a complex and somewhat restricted process. Now the FCC is seeking to accelerate the process further and recently adopted new rules that would double leasing periods and make licensing areas smaller, to make the bands more attractive to smaller providers.
The devising of new rules for the commercial and educational spectrum in this areas has been long winded and complex. “This is one of the most complicated spectrum issues at the FCC,’ commented Trey Hanbury, government affairs director at Sprint, one of the companies with the keenest interest in how the new rules may work, since it is likely to be a major leaser of licenses in order to supplement its already impressive warchest of 2.5GHz spectrum. Sprint needs to know details such as how local leases would work and a step-by-step transition plan to sort out local bandwidth among users. Hanbury said that, of the average 97MHz of 2.5GHz spectrum Sprint holds in the markets it serves, about 60% is leased from educational license holders.
The FCC’s new leasing rules are based on a compromise plan devised by the Wireless Communications Association and Catholic Television, which settled on 30-year leases from educational holders to commercial providers. However, even though the smaller geographies make the landscape more competitive in theory, in practise critics believe the plan has been set up in such a way that Sprint will gain ‘inordinate’ control because it will be the logical party, in many areas, to coordinate the local transition process (Clearwire would also fill these shoes in some regions). In other words, because consolidating the smaller geographic areas into a coherent coverage block might require transferring leases among owners, and according to the FCC’s rules, those transfers would require adjacent license holders’ approvals, Sprint will play a major role in who gets which allocations.
Sprint argues that this potential source of power over the myriad small holders will be more than outweighed by the new attractiveness of the rules for start-up providers, which will be in a better position to build up a network step by step (the classic tactic of Clearwire chief Craig McCaw) and so challenge Sprint without having to raise billions of dollars upfront.
One such likely challenger is aggressive WISP WebSky, which holds 2.5GHz spectrum in many areas and last year signed long term leases for educational frequencies in four new, underserved markets in South Dakota, Oregon, Texas and New Mexico, totalling 24MHz of spectrum for 30 years. WebSky, which also operates in India and Latin America, uses the Clearwire-owned NextNet equipment and could be well placed to roam or sell out to the larger provider.
The 2004 plan restructured the ITFS-MDS band to eliminate the use of interleaved channels and create three distinct band segments: high power operations, such as one-way video transmission; low power operations, such as two-way fixed services; and mobile broadband applications. The last two of these are clearly applicable to WiMAX. The aim of separating high and low power users was to reduce interference and spur development of “low power, cellularized broadband operations’. An additional 5MHz below 2500MHz was also added at that time, widening the total band to 194MHz, although this will be consumed by the relocation of MDS channels 1 and 2 from the 2.4GHz ‘Wi-Fi band’.
Powerline
As well as wireless, the internet players are also looking to other possible ways to bypass the telco networks. One of these is broadband over powerline, and powerline carrier, Current Communications Group, has secured a further $130m in financing from investors including EarthLink, which joins a list of backers that already includes Google.
Current offers powerline service in Cincinnati, Ohio and plans to expand to Texas next.
The Earthlink tie-up also sees the ISP offering powerline as a retail service. Earthlink has long been interested in its own local access loop, working on powerline with Duke Power, Progress Energy and Consolidated Edison, as well as building wireless networks.