It looks as though Research in Motion is in trouble again, this time with mobile email software provider Visto filing a patent infringement suit, which claims that RIM violates four of its patents.
Visto just won a recent suit surrounding the same patents against another competitor, Seven Networks, which Seven hopes to appeal, in the process challenging the patents themselves. Visto is also suing Microsoft and Good Technology, highlighting how aggressively push email, as the key application in the budding mobile enterprise sector, is being fought over ‘ both in the markets and the law courts.
The intellectual property issues in this area are becoming complex and highly political. For instance, the suit against Microsoft was filed in US District Court in Texas on the same day, last December, that Visto licensed NTP’s key patents (despite most of these now being under question by the US Patents and Trademarks office), with NTP taking a stake in the company in return. The NTP patents were, of course, at the heart of the four-year legal dispute with RIM, which was only settled in March with RIM agreeing to pay NTP $612.5m, despite the rejection of some of the patents involved. (Funnily enough, NTP also has a licensing equity relationship with Good Technology.)
Visto technology has been licensed to Vodafone and other major carriers such as Sprint Nextel and the company claims to hold 25 patents related to email remote access, security and synchronization.
In this latest lawsuit, Visto seeks unspecified damages and a halt to RIM’s alleged infringement of four patents related to technology that allows mobile access to data.
Mobile push email, once a niche technology, now lies at the heart of the major vendors’ mobile enterprise strategies. Because email is most commonly the first step in a corporation’s broader mobile strategy, it is a critical target for vendors seeking to dominate the mobile enterprise, notably Microsoft and Nokia, and some large service providers. These are likely soon to wipe independents, including RIM, out of the picture, and so the small companies are jostling to attract the attention of the majors. In a war that has become deeply bound up with intellectual property and the ability to control the platform by owning the patents, these start-ups need to bring patents to the party as well as proven products.
Nokia recently acquired Intellisync to boost its mobile email offering, and with it various pieces of intellectual property, some of it key to Qualcomm’s rival email system Eudora2Go. Vodafone teamed up with Visto to launch own-branded enterprise email services last fall.
The NTP-Visto alliance seems to be making a double sided attack, weakening RIM still further and firing a warning shot across Microsoft’s bows as it moves rapidly into mobile enterprise email. The former action could just be another spat between two niche players in the push email space; the latter smacks of behind the scenes influence from larger forces, keen to stop Microsoft in its tracks as it becomes ever more attractive to the large enterprises with its aggressive pricing on mobile Exchange systems.
RIM said when Visto filed suit against Microsoft that the challenger was “a small player looking for free publicity through a last minute license with undisclosed terms for patents that have been rejected by the patent office”. Visto also seems to be hoping to build up a new revenue stream from its patents, as well as enhancing its position as a partner for larger players. RIM is the seventh company to be sued. As well as RIM, Good, Microsoft and Seven, Visto settled an action against Infowave in 2003 and also sued Sproquit, but the latter went out of business.Visto is hoping that the recent Seven settlement will also apply to an outstanding suit against Smartner Information Systems, which has since merged with Seven.
Though opportunistic, such a financial opportunity is not to be missed at a time when one of Visto’s largest customers, Cingular, says it is ‘winding down’ the relationship. Vodafone, Sprint Nextel, KPN, Rogers Wireless, SmarTone and Telus Mobility are its other major clients. And the tide of US intellectual property actions is currently in favor of the patent holders. “Before, the defendants would win about 70% of the times they challenged the validity of patents in court, and now the plaintiffs prevail about 70% of the time their patents are challenged,” Gene Lee, a partner in the intellectual property practise at Ropes & Gray, told the Wall Street Journal.