Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 May 2006

Patent disputes spread fear and doubt among investors as well as vendors

Patent royalties ‘ and potential royalties ‘ are currently having as strong an impact on shareholder attitudes to mobile companies as actual technologies. Several key issues are lurking in the woodwork, making investors jittery around advanced wireless stocks. So Qualcomm fell back last week on an analyst report on its ongoing patent-related dispute with Broadcom, and its investors remain worried about the possible effect of a breakdown in CDMA licensing talks with Nokia. Meanwhile, any financial decision focused on WiMAX is beset by the key risk of a major intellectual property holder emerging to claim heavy dues on the technology once it gains market mass ‘ whether that holder is Qualcomm or another of at least four bodies with significant intellectual property in the would-be standard.

The nervousness around the Broadcom issue has arisen from a brief put out by a US International Trade Commission (ITC) staff attorney, which points to Qualcomm infringing on the company’s patents (although this is merely an individual opinion at this stage, not a decision). The opinion was reported in a note by analysts at investment bank UBS. The ITC has been hearing claims by Broadcom of business practises by the CDMA giant that infringe antitrust law ‘ claims that are reflected in complaints brought before the European Commission last year by Broadcom, Nokia, Ericsson and other companies that fear Qualcomm extending its influence, and its royalty charges, from its CDMA heartland in to W-CDMA and even WiMAX.

Following the completion of the first ITC round of hearings, a staff attorney asserted in a brief that he believes two of Broadcom’s patents are being infringed by Qualcomm, something the latter denies. An initial decision from the ITC judge is expected in August and a final pronouncement in December.

Meanwhile, other analysts are warning that WiMAX vendors should abandon the dream of royalty-free equipment ‘ based on the push by Intel and others to persuade intellectual property holders to donate their assets to the process in the interests of kickstarting the market ‘ and factor future royalties into their planning. ABI Research claims this potential cost is being widely ignored by WiMAX players but expects Qualcomm to start collecting dues on OFDM-related patents, some acquired last year with Flarion, and given weight recently by WiMAX supplier Soma Networks’ decision to license Qualcomm OFDM technologies for its 802.16 architecture.

Analyst Phil Solis commented: “By acquiring Flarion Technologies recently, Qualcomm added significantly to its stable of OFDM-related patents, and the company will enforce them vigorously. That has a direct bearing on the plans of WiMAX vendors, who must factor these royalties into their business models.”

All this points to the confusion that is increasingly a negative factor in the wireless industry, and which can hold back the progress of a new technology because of nervousness about future additional costs. While inventors should have a means to benefit from their innovation, there is a clear need for this process to be managed by a neutral patent pool, as is common in consumer electronics, and for intellectual property owners to declare their interests upfront rather than waiting until a market is well established or spreading fear and doubt in a fledgeling sector. This is a policy that the European standards body ETSI is pushing for ‘ denying patent rights to vendors that do not reveal their hand upfront ‘and this will be essential to ensure that wireless technology progress is not held back to the slow pace of standards body and antitrust authority decision making.