Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 June 2006

Vodafone looks to convergence and advertising as it records huge loss

Vodafone this week paid the price for its buccaneering past, writing down assets to create the biggest loss in European corporate history. The largest mobile phone company in the world also caved in to shareholder demands to return more cash to them, and committed to what appears to be a ruinous dividend policy, that will relegate the stock to being a cash cow. It also outlined a new corporate focus, with a heavy emphasis on the internet access and convergence trends that Vodafone has long resisted. But while its plans sound convincing, they could be seriously inhibited, in a world where the giant cellco will be taking on a new breed of competitors, from start-ups to incumbents, by the new cautiousness imposed by its restless investors.

CEO Arun Sarin said Vodafone will start to offer fixed-mobile service bundles that include broadband internet access, enabling it to take on the large wired/wireline telcos. This will start in Germany, the only territory where Vodafone has a majority stake in a fixed line operator, Arcor. In other countries it will need to weigh up the options of wireline partnerships or acquisitions, or delivering fixed as well as mobile services over wireless using HSDPA or other technologies. Sarin reassured shareholders that acquisition would not be the heart of the strategy. ‘We are not interested in buying a fixed line or DSLAM company. We’re only interested in buying capacity and reselling it in a bundle,’ he told analysts and investors. However, Thomas Geitner, who heads the Business and Innovation unit, said that, while the company would initially only resell DSL capacity, it would ‘consider unbundling on country by country basis’.

Just as importantly, Vodafone is also facing up to the market shift achieved by the internet players such as Google, which have introduced the advertising model to the mobile sector. Cellcos are having to break down their walled gardens and accept that users will insist on open internet access over their mobile networks, rather than necessarily paying their operator for services or data access. One way to counter the fact that subscribers will be accessing applications that generate no incremental revenue for the operator is to support an advertising-supported model, something that could be acceptable in certain low budget user groups. Virgin Mobile is to introduce a free service with advertising support, borrowing the model Google is extending from the fixed internet into the Wi-Fi metrozone. Now Sarin says Vodafone will experiment with advertising as a new revenue stream, and expects internet services to account for about 10% of its revenue within 3-5 years.

Such new revenue streams, and in particular the shift to convergence, will be the key focus of the new Business and Innovation unit, formed earlier this year and headed by former CTO Geitner. Much of his responsibility will be to explore the opportunities coming from converged and mobile internet services and extending Vodafone’s offerings in the home and at the office including the provisioning of DSL services.

‘We are coming under increasing pressure from internet players entering the communications market using a very different business model and charging model,’ said Sarin at the results conference. ‘The average Vodafone user is only on their phone four minutes per day. We think we can do much better than this. So we have developed strategies to bring Vodafone into the home and office to tackle this.’

Geitner said one revenue stream would be focused on the integration of the mobile, PC and internet at the application level, offering seamless interoperability of services, such as PC to mobile interworking of instant messaging and email.

Vodafone used the opportunity of its year end figures totally to realign its balance sheet, taking savage impairments, the bulk of them a write down in value of its operations in Germany, acquired through a hostile $183bn takeover of Mannesmann in 2000.

Vodafone recorded smaller, but equally dramatic falls, in the value of its Italian assets and on deals to sell its Swedish and Japanese operations. The net result was the biggest loss in European corporate history of some $17.2bn ($32bn) after total impairments of £23.5bn ($44bn). The impairments are not made in accordance with US GAAP rules, so will show as far smaller impairments in its US accounts.

Vodafone CEO Arun Sarin praised the result claiming that organic growth of 6.7% and free cash flow of £6.4bn ($12bn) was ahead of expectation with revenues up 10% to £29.3bn ($55bn).

The company has miraculously ended the year with 170m mobile customers, with organic addition of 22m customers on its continuing operations, despite losing a huge number of subscribers when it gave up its Swedish and Japanese operations.

But its new dividend policy is a clear indication that Sarin has caved in to greedy investors and Vodafone will now pay out 60% of its earnings both now with a final dividend, plus at a pro-rated level in future years.

This strategy consigns the glorious swashbuckling past of Vodafone to the dustbin of history and ties up most of its cash generation going forwards. In the next few years more ambitious mobile operations may well be in a position to overtake Vodafone as the global mobile leader.

The company also agreed to add a further £3bn ($5.6bn) of shareholder payouts to the £6bn ($11bn) it has already returned in cash from the Japan sale. Despite all this Vodafone has found ways this year to enter markets in the Czech Republic, Romania, India, South Africa and Turkey, through low priced acquisitions and says there’s plenty of revenue growth here for the time being.

Vodafone will now focus on cost reduction and ARPU growth and only pick up stakes in emerging markets.

Vodafone gave an outlook of 5% to 6.5% growth and a 1% lower margin and free cash flow of £4bn to £4.5bn ($7.5bn to $8.4bn) in the coming year.

The potentially huge sale of Vodafone’s 45% holding in its US joint venture with Verizon appears to be not immediately on the cards, since Verizon has said that it will not meet the price that Vodafone recently placed on the shareholding.

Vodafone still has £20bn ($37bn) of debt, which would be wiped out at a stroke if it ever sold the Verizon Wireless stake. However it would lose its position as the world number one, with all the negotiating power that gives it with equipment suppliers.

Vodafone’s market capitalization jumped from $135bn to $143bn in the two days after the announcement.

Vodafone said it will continue to focus on emerging markets as a driver of growth but that there will likely be a lower level of acquisition activity than in recent years. Vodafone will consider selling assets on which it believes it ‘cannot earn a superior return’, but is also keen to increase its stakes in some countries, notably France and Poland.

The operator also outlined a strategy to cut its costs including outsourcing its IT application development and maintenance activities, regional consolidation of its data centers and cutting more than 400 jobs, mainly in the UK.

Virgin Mobile’s free wireless

MVNO Virgin Mobile USA has announced plans to give subscribers free airtime in return for responding to mobile adverts. Under the scheme, users spending up to 75 minutes per month reading ads and responding via SMS will receive the equivalent amount of time in free voice minutes. Initial partners include Pepsi, Microsoft’s Xbox unit and anti-smoking advocacy group Truth.

‘Very practically speaking a lot of our customers are value conscious. They manage budgets that are finite,’ said chief marketing officer Howard Handler, noting that 65% of the operator’s subscriber base is below the age of 30.

He said the scheme should also boost Virgin’s ad revenue by sending more potential clients to advertisers. ‘It will contribute meaningful additional top line revenue and EBITDA,’ he said.