France Telecom hinted last week that it will consider using the Chinese 3G system, TD-SCDMA, in future, and has joined the industry alliance backing the technology, the first non-Chinese operator to do so. This indicates stepped-up interest by the European carrier in increasing its influence in China ahead of its major western rivals.
Many carriers with 3G licenses in Europe and elsewhere are looking at the possibility of adopting a second technology in addition to their current W-CDMA or CDMA2000 deployments. In particular, they are weighing up options ‘ such as TD-SCDMA, the IPWireless-backed TD-CDMA and WiMAX ‘ which use time division duplex (TDD) spectrum. This supports greater spectral efficiency than the mainstream 3G network because it allows different amounts of bandwidth to be allocated to uplink and downlink according to the application. Most European cellcos already have TDD spectrum as part of their 3G licenses, and a few ‘ including France Telecom’s Orange subsidiary ‘ are starting to activate this for data-intensive services. Further TDD spectrum will be available in the upcoming auctions of licenses around 2.5GHz, and France Telecom pointed out that, as current 3G spectrum reaches capacity under pressure from applications such as VoIP, it will be important to expand into new bands ‘ even at the cost of implementing an additional network.
However, apart from a ZTE trial with Romanian cellcos, no western operator has considered the Chinese technology for this strategy. The main contenders have been assumed to be TD-CDMA ‘ which is being trialled by Sprint in the US and deployed in a few territories in Europe by T-Mobile and Orange ‘ and the upcoming 802.16e WiMAX network. There are many issues with TD-CDMA, both political ‘ resistance of EU and US authorities to China’s ambitions to assert its own intellectual property rights abroad and reduce royalties to western vendors ‘ and technical (trials to date have been beset by delays and reports of poor performance, and it seems likely that the Chinese regulator will have to issue a new license, requiring TD-SCDMA build-out, to China Telecom, in order to guarantee adoption of the platform, since the existing cellcos are focused on W-CDMA.
Li Juan, from France Telecom’s Beijing R&D center, said: “There is a possibility we will consider using TD-SCDMA in Europe when the frequency spectrum for W-CDMA in Europe runs out of capacity.’
France Telecom’s decision to join the TD-SCDMA Forum and make such statements ‘ long before any equipment is available for Orange actually to deploy in Europe ‘ is likely to be mainly geared to increasing the operator’s influence on the world’s largest mobile telecoms market. France Telecom already cooperates with China Telecom, China’s largest fixed line carrier by number of subscribers ‘ and future TD-SCDMA operator – in a joint equipment buying agreement and Orange is planning to open an office in Beijing in June that will help local equipment makers tailor products for Orange. As the Chinese market opens up, France Telecom is sure to look to build on these foundations to create a full joint venture in the country, a prize for which some investment in TD-SCDMA R&D and promises of future support for the beleaguered standard will be a small price to pay.