Vodafone may be unlikely to exit its US joint venture with Verizon in the near future, but it remains under intense shareholder pressure to make the lucrative divestment and reduce its debt ‘ a strategy that completely ignores one of the cellco’s chief competitive advantages, the massive buying power that global reach brings it. This is a lesson that has not been so easily forgotten at Japanese super-operator NTT DoCoMo, even though its expansionist moves in the past, less successful than Vodafone’s, have been similar criticized by its investors. Despite that, the company is now looking for a new phase of international acquisitions and ventures, although instead of looking west it will focus on the high growth markets of east Asia, and potentially on China and India. Its chief short term motivation is to increase the uptake of its i-Mode content platform and so achieve economies of scale in i-Mode handsets.
These two massive economies present attractive opportunities for DoCoMo, especially in terms of increasing its handset volumes and so reducing its costs, but they are likely to be fairly slow to materialize. Last week, 3G licensing in China and India once again looked to be suffering delays, with the Chinese government reported to be holding back its auction from mid-2006 to the first quarter of 2007, and the Indian authorities unlikely to complete a license allocation framework until the end of this year.
In the mean time, DoCoMo will look towards smaller but faster moving territories, notably Indonesia, Thailand and Vietnam. CEO Masao Nakamura told the London Financial Times last week: ‘I think the centre of activity going forward will be Asia.’ However, he admitted that the model that DoCoMo has adopted in Europe since 2002, when it halted international M&A programs ‘ making technical alliances based around its i-Mode content platform, rather than investing large sums in stakes ‘ would not work in Asia. Since operators there are less developed, cash investment is almost certain to be required.
Nakamura was keen to limit expectations surrounding China and India, saying DoCoMo had had no concrete talks in the former because of the uncertain 3G landscape. ‘We’re not really sure which operator runs which technology,’ he said. And in India, progress has been blocked by Vodafone’s acquisition of a stake in Bharti Telecom, which means DoCoMo has ‘to think which operator is left and it’s going to be difficult’.
The short term key to DoCoMo’s renewed international outlook is to increase the volume of i-Mode handsets sold worldwide and so reduce its costs as well as, longer term, its software-related revenues. Though uptake of i-Mode outside Japan ‘ where it is wildly popular ‘ has been slow, the company scored a new success last week, signing Hutchison Telecom Hong Kong to use i-Mode phones. Other Asian i-Mode alliances are already in place in Singapore, Taiwan and the Philippines.
I-Mode carriers have a total of 250m subscribers in 15 countries, and of these, over 50m already use the content and internet platform (45m in Japan). The full list of i-Mode alliance members consists of Telefonica/O2 in Spain, the UK and Ireland, Wind in Italy, Cellcom in Israel, MTS in Russia, Cosmote in Greece, Telstra in Australia, Starhub in Singapore, Far EasTone in Taiwan, BASE in Belgium, KPN in the Netherlands, E-Plus in Germany, Bouygues in France and DoCoMo itself, and now Hutchison. Cingular also offers a variant of i-Mode, called mMode, which it acquired with AT&T Wireless, although these users are not included in the i-Mode total.
DoCoMo has a poor track record when it comes to international acquisitions. In 2000, the company committed about $23bn in acquisitions to port its i-mode technology, including more than $15bn for a share of AT&T Wireless, an investment which turned out to be ill-timed. The firm wrote off almost $15bn in international share value in 2001-2002 and stopped international expansions in early 2002. It ended up making technical alliances with operators in Europe and Asia, rather than taking stakes, to push i-mode. But, faced with increasing competition in its own saturated home market, it now needs to look abroad again.