Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 May 2006

WiMAX World: Mobility takes center stage, but spectrum is the key issue

Last week saw the staging of the largest ever European event dedicated to WiMAX, the WiMAX World conference in Vienna, Austria. The scale of attendance and the topics addressed by speakers reflected that 802.16 is now real enough to be commanding serious operator and vendor interest, but sufficiently new and unproven to leave those parties still with an urgent need for hype-free information. ‘Hype-free’ may be too much to ask of any technology conference, but the program concentrated on the real world and its themes reflected the key issues that occupy the minds of those making broadband wireless decisions ‘ costs, regulations, spectrum, equipment timescales and revenue models. There was also, predictably, a major focus, especially from the suppliers, on the future role of WiMAX in mobile broadband, and several companies set out their roadmaps for mobile-enabled 802.16e. This raised issues of its own ‘ one of the reasons for the persisting need for information about WiMAX is that its agenda has changed significantly over the past three years, and become increasingly dedicated to a carrier-driven, mobile and personal broadband vision. This is a far more ambitious remit than the original focus on ‘grown-up Wi-Fi’ and the WISP or alternative operator sector, and one that, while making 802.16 a platform adequate to interest the carrier suppliers such as Motorola and Alcatel, also brings new risks ‘ notably, that spectrum availability will not be sufficient to support 802.16e as a global mobile standard, and that the 3GPP roadmap, kicked into new animation by the threat of a new technology, will outstrip that of WiMAX in the eyes of the plum operator customers. The Vienna event highlighted that, while WiMAX personal broadband is on the cusp of being a very real platform with high growth trajectories, it also risks leaving behind the WISP market where it could have found its earliest and easiest business models.

This duality was brought home to delegates by, among others, comments from Jim Baker, CEO of UK broadband wireless start-up Telabria, and Ernst Eidenberger, head of business development in Alcatel’s broadband wireless unit. Baker pointed out that, while Telabria sees many advantages to including WiMAX in its roll-out of services in the south east UK, it is confined in that country to the lightly licensed 5.8GHz spectrum band, in which there is no WiMAX equipment available. Although 5.8GHz has always been a designated WiMAX Forum profile, Forum board director Mo Shakouri admitted that there had so far been no success in getting the three different products required for interoperability testing and certification into the laboratories. And for 802.16e, there is highly unlikely to be 5GHz products, since most of the advantages of that technology, such as mobile support, are irrelevant so high up the spectrum.

There is a real possibility, then, that there will never be certified WiMAX standard gear for 5.8GHz which, until significant swathes of spectrum are potentially opened up for license-free use around the world, remains the chief unlicensed band available for WISPs (apart from the over-congested 2.4GHz). This seems to deprive WiMAX of a market in which it would have had an easy sell, especially in countries like the US and UK where most licensed broadband wireless access frequencies are in the hands of just a few large players. In a world where there is increasing focus on the potential of alternative and disruptive operators to use license-exempt bands to offer low cost services with creative new approaches, this could prove a major missed opportunity. A failure to bring significant numbers of 5.8GHz products to market could also sound an early death knell for the 802.16-2004 fixed wireless standard, which ‘ once 802.16e gear is fully available ‘ was likely to fall back on WISPs lacking the scale or requirement for mobility, many of which are confined to 5.8GHz bands. Ironically, such a development will prolong the life of a number of proprietary 5.8GHz products such as Motorola Canopy, which are attaining the cost and efficiency targets set by WiMAX, and also of Wi-Fi mesh as a full metro area broadband option, and this could even preserve some of the smaller equipment vendors, which would have floundered in a head-on contest with the majors.

Sidelining of the 5.8GHz option throws the spotlight firmly on 3.5GHz. Although the hopes for WiMAX as a fully mobile broadband system for large operators rest on the opening up of 2.5GHz and even lower band options round the world, in the short term, the main frequency available outside North America is 3.5GHz, and licenses are being allocated in an increasingly wide range of territories. Debate rages over how well 3.5GHz supports mobile broadband in terms of range, efficiency and therefore ROI, but for many operators it will be the only choice. It will certainly be the only chance for WiMAX to fulfil many of the roles for which it was originally conceived, before the urban personal broadband agenda took priority. These were outlined by Eidenberger, who listed the basic political and economic objectives of WiMAX regulation as bringing broadband to the countryside and areas beyond reach of DSL; increasing competition in urban areas by driving broadband end prices down; and fulfilling a social and political function in helping bridge the digital divide through initiatives such as broadband to all schools and libraries.

In the absence of a license exempt option, which would support low barriers to entry and a proliferation of competitive operators, Eidenberger threw a strong light on the critical necessity of a stronger, more harmonized 3.5GHz regime. Other vendors and analysts might debate the merits of 2.5GHz and the chances of European and other regulators opening this up to WiMAX, but 3.5GHz remains the most important near term issue. The speed with which this band is being opened up ‘ or in some cases reopened after business failures at the turn of the century ‘ is encouraging, with 721 WiMAX licenses, mainly in 3.5GHz, issued globally (compared to 106 for 3G), and with the average cost per Hz estimated at one-thousandth that of 3G.

However, there are still many inconsistencies and risks. Some countries, such as Poland with 3.7GHz, have chosen slightly incompatible bands for which there will be no equipment economies of scale. Others are allocating too little spectrum to each operator to support an attractive WiMAX business case, especially in areas with competition ‘ most commentators believe 30MHz is the ideal amount, but few European regulators have been this generous. And pricing has been erratic, with Eidenberger pointing to Poland and Bulgaria as examples of overpriced auctions (€8m for four national licenses in the former). He called for operators to be supported in a payback period of typically 3.5 years, no more, and for regulators to allow license holders to choose between TDD and FDD technology, and to be unrestricted in implementing mobile and nomadic services (hand-off is banned in many European countries in 3.5GHz). Another key requirement is to impose minimum coverage conditions for rural areas so that providers are prevented from building out only in the ‘juicy’ urban centers; and to insist that subscribers gain a minimum bandwidth.

While spectrum might have been the greatest uncertainty factor highlighted at WiMAX World, the topic that aroused the most excitement was certainly the evolution to personal and mobile broadband, and the opportunity WiMAX presents for alternative operators to enter this world without 3G. The sense that this is becoming a genuine possibility rather than an interesting idea was reinforced by the announcement of the largest planned 802.16e deployment mooted to date, by Wateen Telecom in Pakistan, using Motorola equipment (see separate item). This is a text book example of a company using a creative mixture of technologies ‘ GSM and WiMAX in this case ‘ to leapfrog the incumbent in bringing broadband to a country that is underserved, but has high growth potential. And with 1m subscribers targeted within three years, this is a carrier-scale plan.

With 802.16-2004 increasingly being seen as a short term technology option, all the vendor focus was on 802.16e. There are various pre-certified products available, and some will be tested under wave one of the Forum’s program as early as the third quarter, though since the scope of wave one is limited, many suppliers will wait for a second wave around the turn of the year, which will cover a wider range of functionality. Among the majors, Motorola, Alcatel, Siemens and Samsung are almost sure to be the early movers, with Navini key among the specialists. Companies whose focus has been mainly on 802.16-2004 are either resigning themselves to sticking to a fairly confined and traditional base for the foreseeable future, or are coming up with various migration plans to 802.16e.

One of the latter is chipmaker Wavesat, whose Shark system claims to bridge the gap between fixed and mobile WiMAX. All the specialist silicon companies are reaching for a differentiating factor as they brace themselves for the entry of Intel and other giants. Wavesat has gained considerable ground in the important Taiwanese ODM sector; Sequans has strength in low cost, low footprint platforms; while PicoChip is the most convincing in spanning different wireless architectures with a software-intensive approach. Beceem, with the distinction of being funded by Intel, Samsung and NTT DoCoMo, is strong in Wi-Bro ‘ the Korean pre-802.16e implementation ‘ and has stolen a march on many rivals in bringing ‘e’-class chips to reality, earning itself the starring role in Motorola’s 802.16e demonstrations at the show, which focused on interoperability between its small footprint MotoWi4 pre-certified 802.16e base station and third party CPE.

The Wavesat Shark chipset is built to specifications laid out by the WiMAX Forum’s Evolutionary Task Group, which is developing profiles that support the evolution of 802.16-2004 to 802.16e. Shark uses the 802.16e SOFDMA scheme and its adaptive antenna technology, but currently supports only hard hand-off between base stations (eventually 802.16e will support soft hand-off, which does not require the connection to be re-established).

Like Motorola, Navini has never entered the 802.16-2004 market and so is free from the conflicts the dual-technology approach can create. In Vienna, it announced that it had started commercial delivery of its Ripwave MX BTS, a dual-mode base station supporting the current Ripwave mobile broadband architecture and 802.16e, which was originally announced last June (see Wireless Watch June 30 2005 edition). The MX is software upgradable to 802.16e and supports Navini’s advanced smart beamforming technology as well as the various Ripwave CPE formats, which include PC cards.

Of course, any discussion of WiMAX as a mobile broadband technology invites comparisons with the 3GPP agenda, and WiMAX World scored a coup in getting the main bugbear of 802.16, Qualcomm, to present its point of view surrounded by the WiMAX crowd. Qualcomm has long argued that CDMA EV-DO and HSxPA will sustain their lead over the newer challenger in mobility terms and will match OFDM in other key aspects of the roadmap such as broadband performance and indoor penetration. Just to be sure, it has its own OFDM technologies, notably Flarion Flash-OFDM and MediaFLO, and is backing an alternative standard to WiMAX, 802.20. The rights and wrongs of the various models and simulations detailed by Qualcomm ‘ to offer an unimpressive picture of WiMAX versus HSxPA ‘ and by vendors like Motorola ‘ to do the opposite – will be tested when the technologies are used in earnest and real products are available. But among operators and some suppliers, there is an increasing awareness that WiMAX should not enter a war, and that it will thrive best as a complement to 3G, DSL and other networks. So perhaps the viewpoint that resonated best with the audience ‘ and provided the strongest hope for those relying on WiMAX forming a key part of 4G ‘ came from Klaus-D Kohrt, senior vice president of government relations at Siemens, who is both the vice-chair of the UMTS Forum and very active in the WiMAX Forum. As WiMAX evolves towards mobility and large carrier models, such a crossover approach should prove the voice of reason and success.