Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 May 2006

Wi-Bro ‘roaming belt’ raises new fears of east-west WiMAX split

Ever since Samsung and other Korean parties succeeded in getting their Wi-Bro personal broadband technology adopted as the basis of the WiMAX 802.16e standard, it has been clear that this was part of a broader effort by east Asian hi-tech countries to assert themselves in the wireless intellectual property race, thus reducing their dependence on western technologies, and their royalty bills, and driving the 4G agenda. The importance of the Wi-Bro in this mission is highlighted by the formation of an alliance of operators from the region to promote the technology and accelerate its development. This suggests that, far from being a short term stopgap on the road to 802.16e, Wi-Bro is being positioned not only to gain the largest market share of any pre-802.16e system, but to continue to lead the mobile WiMAX sector in terms of innovation and customer gains.

The new group, called Wi-Bro and Mobile WiMAX Community (WMC), is composed of Korea Telecom, which has already gone live with its first Wi-Bro services in South Korean capital Seoul; plus Japan’s NTT, Hong Kong’s PCCW and Telekom Malaysia Berhad, all powerhouses of the east Asian telecoms market that have made a strong commitment to including WiMAX in their multi-network broadband roadmaps. None of them, however, had previously announced any choice of technology supplier, though their founding of WMC must raise high hopes for the main Wi-Bro vendor, Samsung. It is also likely that, if Wi-Bro is seen gaining ground in its own right, before 802.16e is fully available, other vendors will leap to join the Korean suppliers Samsung, LG and POSdata ‘ with China’s Huawei and ZTE, also heavily focused on WiMAX and also keen to reduce patent payments to the west, strong candidates, as is Alcatel, which has a joint development agreement with Samsung and a trial with Telekom Malaysia. Wi-Bro has already scored sufficient wins to convince that it will not be, as originally assumed, a technology specific to Korea. It is being trialled by Sprint Nextel and Telecom Italia and has customer wins in Brazil, Venezuela and Croatia. NTT’s mobile arm, DoCoMo, is also trialling Wi-Bro systems from POSdata.

The odd one out among the founding members of the WMC is Covad Communications, the US competitive operator that plans to deploy WiMAX from this year to extend its wholesale DSL and VoIP operations. Support for Wi-Bro could give the technology its second win among US providers, following a $6m Samsung deal with AriaLink of Michigan earlier this year.

“By joining the WMC, Covad gains an opportunity to learn from and share information with leading telecom providers in other countries,” said Alan Howe, vice president of strategic and wireless development for Covad. “This puts us on the cutting edge of new developments in the fast-growing wireless broadband market.”

The WMC claims a further 20 operators from 16 countries have signed up, although they have not yet gone public with their identities. Apart from the importance to vendors of these signs of a broad international market for Wi-Bro, this level of support raises hopes of a major roaming agreement between Wi-Bro providers, as they roll out ‘ which could come significantly earlier than any similar deals using other forms of WiMAX. KT refers to the WMC as the basis of a ‘roaming belt’ for Wi-Bro and later for full mobile WiMAX.

The creation of such a belt would raise the question ‘ how quickly will all these Wi-Bro operators, if they really do deploy systems in the coming year, move towards full 802.16e? If they move slowly, perhaps finding their own build-outs and roaming deals sufficient to support their business plans for a couple of years at least, this could create a two-tier mobile WiMAX world, a serious delay in achieving global roaming and harmonization around full 802.16e, and a reduced addressable market for non Wi-Bro vendors. At worst, it could create a large island of Wi-Bro deployments with only limited roaming and interoperability capabilities with other WiMAX variants.

The activities of the WMC in technology and regulatory improvements could also come into conflict with those of the WiMAX Forum, potentially setting an alternative agenda dominated by the east Asian giants rather than Intel and the traditional WiMAX community. It is crucial for the progress of 802.16e as a global force that this split is not allowed to occur, and that the WMC activities are embraced within those of the Forum. This was achieved ‘ albeit after much politicking and compromise ‘ when Samsung originally proposed Wi-Bro as the basis of 802.16e, and it became clear that it would be in the interests of WiMAX to adopt this technology, and the interests of its supporters, rather than risk an east-west technology split. Such a split, always a lurking possibility as the China-Japan-Korea hi-tech axis gains in strength, innovation and international reach, would be fatal to WiMAX and it is vital that majors on both sides work to prevent it happening.

Further Wi-Bro news:

Korea Telecom and smartcard provider Axalto have announced the commercial launch of a Wi-Bro universal integrated circuit card that will let subscribers connect to the service using a notebook PC, PDA or smartphone.

Meanwhile, Samsung is providing Wi-Bro equipment to H1 of Croatia for its national roll-out, which will start in the country’s second city, Split. H1 is using the 3.5GHz band.