Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 June 2006

CLECs will fail again as two-tier internet takes hold in US cities

Cox Communications’ announcement that it would offer multiple layers of tariffs, according to usage patterns, when it launches wireless services later this year (see separate item), highlighted this key topic within the heated debate over internet neutrality. Pure internet players such as Google argue that customers should be free to use their net connection for any purpose without differentiated charges or other control by the carrier, but already most providers are struggling with any way to create a business model around this notion in wireless ‘ including several parties, and even Google itself, that are moving into the metrozone market. Municipalities themselves have shifted their focus from idealistic, publicly funded freezones to support universal broadband and community regeneration, to private-public partnerships usually involving a strong element of commercial profit as well as municipal or public safety efficiency. Despite the appeal of the more rosy arguments for unfettered internet, the same lurch towards realism will have to take place in the wireless sector to ensure growth and innovation in the industry at all ‘ a hard fact that is clearly reflected in the compromises over neutrality embodied in the proposed Telecommunications Act.

Arguments for entirely free internet usage, with no scaling of charges even for heavy duty video or enterprise users, are na’ve in wireless, even more than in wireline, which generally has sufficient capacity truly to become a utility. In wireless – even with spectrally efficient new generation technologies like 802.16e, and more plentiful allocations of licensed spectrum and even license-exempt frequencies – physical capacity limitations imposed by spectrum mean that unrestricted usage of bandwidth hogging services will quickly collapse the network. And if the operator can make no gain from such usage, there will be few business models available to sustain wireless build-out at all. Even the most popular solution to marrying unconstrained access with operator profit ‘ advertising support ‘ will quickly fall down if the carrier cannot acquire sufficient bandwidth, or afford sufficiently rapid network ramp-up, to support heavy duty services at a quality level acceptable to most users (and after all, the affluent or corporate users with the most exacting quality demands will also be the prime targets for the mobile advertisers, and their custom will be essential to attract the ads that can then subsidize low cost access for poorer communities).

Google itself is supporting the multi-tiered model by partnering, in its San Francisco metrozone project, with ISP EarthLink. While Google will use the network to provide a free, ad-supported service, this will be confined to sub-1Mbps ‘best effort’ access, while EarthLink will address the cream of the user base, such as enterprises and other ISPs, with a paid-for offering with higher data rates and QoS.

The challenges facing would-be metrozone operators, faced by the dual pressures to support low cost or free access and to allow customers to roam freely on the net, will lead to a wave of project failures and of start-ups exiting the space. This will be an echo of a similar readjustment that came in the wake of the dotcom boom, when all but the largest and most creative providers found the advertising-funded model impossible to turn into profit.

There has already been a string of failed projects to establish free or ad-subsidized metrozones in the US, but the problems are highlighted particularly well by the withdrawal of one of the smartest of the commercial providers targeting the municipal space, MobilePro, from one of its flagship contracts. Last year MobilePro won a tender to create a wireless network for the City of Sacramento, state capital of California, and has already conducted a downtown pilot supporting outdoor internet access and public safety video applications. However, MobilePro says that, after awarding the contract, the city demanded new terms, requesting a free network funded by advertising, and with no guarantee that the city would act as the anchor tenant.

Sacramento clearly has its eye on the relatively new model pioneered in nearby San Francisco by Google, which reduces risk to the authority to almost nil. But MobilePro had bid on the basis of its more traditional approach ‘ which it has already employed in other metrozones such as Tempe, Arizona with commercial success. This would have provided a free service of limited bandwidth ‘ like Google ‘ but also limited in coverage, which would have been funded by a requirement that higher bandwidth customers pay a monthly fee, or that the city itself was a guaranteed customer.

‘It is our understanding based on the final request of the City of Sacramento that the city would require MobilePro to provide free high speed wireless internet service to all residents and have the company rely primarily on advertising revenues for its profits and returns on investment. Based upon MobilePro’s research and experience as one of the leading Wi-Fi broadband wireless network service providers to municipalities in North America, MobilePro does not believe that an advertising supported business case is financially sustainable,’ commented MobilePro president Jerry Sullivan.

In microcosm, this is the same dilemma that faces the US telecoms market as a whole. Traditional provider business models, whether employed by the incumbent Bellcos or independents like MobilePro, are under attack from the move towards an unfettered internet. Currently, advertising models are the most fashionable alternative and can certainly provide a way to offer free or very low cost services ‘ but only if the advertising carrier can generate sufficient revenue to make a profit, something that in many cases will prove just as difficult as sustaining traditional fee-based services. Even the most successful internet advertising business of all, Google, has demonstrated through its EarthLink compromise in San Francisco that ads alone will not generate sufficient revenue to deliver unlimited bandwidth to all citizens for free ‘ the ultimate goal of net neutrality. San Francisco inhabitants will certainly find it hard to make heavy use of bitTorrent on a best effort, 256Kbps connection as promised by Google. The cost of building out capacity for unlimited wireless broadband usage will be impossible to sustain without either limiting heavy duty applications ‘ for instance, blocking VoIP, as some providers like Clearwire have attempted ‘ or charging fees for premium usage.

Also, any company that is focused on advertising revenue will need to focus mainly on communities with income to respond to the ads ‘ which works against the original goal of many poorer municipalities, of offering access to deprived groups and regenerating the city in the process. This dream has been spoiled by two factors ‘ the unwillingness of taxpayers to see their dollars spent on such services, driving the municipalities towards commercial partnerships that involve no public money; and the hostility of the telcos to an approach that could undermine their own models. While the telcos have been forced to make some adjustments to embrace low cost access ‘ and are now starting to bid to control metrozone projects themselves ‘ they are also scoring points with the regulators that will weaken the free municipal vision still further. This is highlighted in the proposed Telecommunications Act, which would establish a national video franchise that would allow television providers to bypass local governments when seeking to offer pay TV service. The Bells have argued that municipal authorities have often hindered their efforts to compete with cablecos in video, by withholding permission or restricting access to publicly owned infrastructure, until the telcos paid for local improvements such as playgrounds, or promised services for poor parts of the community. Opponents complain providers will now be able to focus only on the richest and most profitable communities.

The argument is an extension of the broader conflict between public authorities and telcos, which has mainly centered on the issue of subsidized metrozones – an argument that has been largely resolved by the cities shifting from direct funding of free or low cost broadband, to supporting competitive operators with commercial models that can still encompass cheap access, such as advertising-funded services. These new operators, such as Google, may be a threat to the telcos, because they shift the balance of revenue and drive down prices, but they are certainly less of a threat than a true publicly funded, universal broadband model. Like telcos, advertising carriers need to focus on the most economically attractive communities, and there are many instances ‘ as with Google/EarthLink ‘ where their interests will converge rather than conflict. The telcos have the power and financial resources to adjust to the new models and embrace them in order to retain control of customers and networks. In the process, the underserved rural and urban populations will remain largely underserved, and the smaller competitive providers, which were pinning their hopes of revival on wireless after being effectively shut out of the broadband market by the Bell operators, will lack the scale to adjust to the new order, leading to a second wave of CLEC failures.

Two tier data pricing

At last week’s Globalcomm conference, RIM’s co-CEO Mike Lazaridis pointed to the dilemma faced by wireless operators, forced to offer more and more bandwidth at low rates, and so putting their network capacity under intolerable strain.

Lazaridis said that one reason for the success of the BlackBerry push email service, which was built on two-way paging concepts, was that it was very efficient with the cellco’s network and was ‘respectful of the bandwidth’.

Many modern IP services cannot say the same, of course, and Lazaridis made a simple distinction between unlimited wireless data services and flat rate wireless data services – the latter won’t bring down a network.

‘We have to be very careful not to confuse flat rate with unlimited use,’ he said. ‘What we’ve realized is that if you use too much of the network bandwidth, you get to the point where carriers aren’t making money.’

This inevitably leads wireless operators to introduce some form of restriction on volumes consumed over their networks, even if they try to disguise these in the small print attached to the ‘unlimited’ flat rate services that users increasingly demand. Clearwire ran into dispute with VoIP provider Vonage when it tried to block VoIP and video from its network, claiming such applications would jeopardize the performance of its system, at least in the first generation. Often, spectrum allocations are even sparser for cellular operators, and while many are looking to build parallel networks to offload excess traffic ‘ in new licensed bands such as AWS in the US or 2.5GHz in Europe, or even in unlicensed frequencies, using cellular or BWA technologies ‘ they are also seeking to keep usage of their current systems under control, to preserve quality of service and profitability.

Some are being more subtle than others. T-Mobile UK was heavily criticized recently when it introduced a 3G data package with ‘unlimited’ data access, that actually bans customers from using VoIP and instant messaging. The Web ‘n’ Walk Professional data tariff is aggressive on price at £19 a month and T-Mobile has been a frontrunner among the major cellcos in opening up its walled garden and supporting IP ‘ but such far-sightedness comes at a price, and the following is included in the small print: ‘Use of voice over Internet Protocol and messaging over Internet Protocol is prohibited by T-Mobile. If use of either or both of these services is detected T-Mobile may terminate all contracts with the customer and disconnect any SIM cards and/or web ‘n’ walk cards from the T-Mobile network.’

Japan’s NTT DoCoMo does not seek to ban certain types of application, but instead controls volumes by allowing flat rate, all-you-can-eat pricing, provided there are nofile downloads ‘ these carry additional fees. This seems more usable than the T-Mobile approach, since most customers want to use the cellular network to communicate or access data on the move, and can wait until they reach a wired or Wi-Fi connection to obtain whole files.