Hutchison’s European 3G-only operator 3 was once a symbol of the disappointed expectations of UMTS in the region, especially in the UK, the market where it paid most for its 3G licenses. But after years of struggling to achieve its financial objectives, 3 is riding the wave of mobile internet uptake, and has crossed the milestone of one million customers across Europe for the mobile broadband service it launched last year. It says demand is strong in all its territories ‘ the UK, Ireland, Italy, Sweden, Denmark and Austria.
The operator has been through various shifts in its business model in its attempt to find profit from its 3G network, which is being rapidly upgraded to HSPA. In the early years it saw lower than expected enthusiasm for 3G data and multimedia offerings, because of immature demand and poorly performing networks and handsets. With no GSM revenues to fall back on, it turned the lack of legacy to some advantage by exploiting the superior efficiency of its 3G system to drive down voice and text rates, gaining market share if not margin, and having a disruptive effect on established cellcos, especially in the UK. But 3 really came into its own with the launch of X Series last year, relying on partnerships with big name internet brands, and an early move to affordable flat rate mobile internet tariffs, to attract subscribers. This was one of the first credible attempts outside Japan to create a true mobile web platform that met the consumer expectations created by the PC and Wi-Fi ‘ low all-you-can-eat data rates; bundled voice tariffs; easy access to key applications like Skype or Google; a simple user interface ‘ plus the specific benefits of the mobile network, such as personalization and location awareness. In making its move early, 3 forced response from larger European carriers like Vodafone, even while it was largely accepting that its role would be that of a bitpipe, relying on partner brands more than its own to attract users, and supporting innovative devices ‘ most successfully its strongly branded and affordable dongles, which include pay-as-you-go options.
All this has turned 3 from one of the most backward looking cellcos ‘ whose managing director famously said in 2006 that users would not welcome open web access and were reassured by the walled gardens ‘ into a flagwaver for a true mobile broadband business model. However, this still leaves doubts over how much profit lies in this model, given that operators will have to offer low, flat rate prices, and support ever increasing levels of usage of the network. So far, though, 3’s headstart, its keen eye for partnerships, and its strong marketing/pricing initiatives of this year, are generating hopeful results.
However, the operator took the opportunity of announcing its millionth mobile broadband user to lobby the European Union again on data roaming. Christian Salbaing, managing director for European telecoms at parent company Hutchison Whampoa, expressed concern at the continuing high cost of data roaming in the region. “Typical retail roaming prices are literally hundreds of times what customers expect to pay domestically. A European consumer might pay around one eurocent per megabyte at home, yet pay a premium of 360 times that, simply to cross a border,” he said, calling on the European Commission to take action as it did last year with voice roaming in 2007. Moves to bring data roaming policies into line with voice are under consideration, but will not take effect until next year at the earliest, and are being opposed by the incumbent operators and their representative body, the GSMA. 3 allows its customers to use their domestic price plans when roaming on to its sister networks in Europe, which has boosted volumes on its networks in the area by 2,500% over the past year.
As well as seeking to disrupt its older rivals’ roaming expectations, 3 is also taking aim at the fixed broadband operators and claims HSPA is finally a technology that can allow people to replace, or reduce usage, of their fixed lines in the same way that they are doing for voice. While many cellcos are looking to buy or team up with fixed line providers to offer fixed/mobile convergence and quad play, 3 is taking the higher risk option of persuading users that with an HSPA connection – attached potentially to multiple devices like handsets, dongles and even home media routers ‘ they can dump the fixed line subscription altogether. This line has often been taken in theory by wireless-only operators, seeking to challenge the wired/wireless incumbents, but few have put it seriously into practise, at least outside territories underserved by fixed lines. In reality, Vodafone and other wireless-only providers have been partnering with broadband ISPs, and others like O2 have merged with owners of fixed line operations. But as mobile broadband networks and devices improve, and LTE comes on the horizon, the 3 route will become more viable, with Sprint Nextel leading the charge across the Atlantic.
“This milestone shows people everywhere want to access our mobile broadband services. Since we launched our offers late last year we have seen phenomenal growth from customers who are using it to both supplement and replace their fixed line broadband. For many customers, it is their first personal broadband connection,” Salbaing said.
Of course there are big decisions to be made when using a wireless network for both fixed and mobile usage, in terms of build-out and therefore capex priorities. This is even true of WiMAX, the first major wireless network optimized for fixed and mobile usage on one system. LTE will have similar characteristics but for operators with HSPA, the trade-offs of introducing significant levels of fixed access are higher, and the balance of business must justify it. For a company like 3, though, which is relying heavily on laptop usage, these choices need to be made, since many subscribers are turning their laptop into their main or only PC and/or media server, and so the device will usually be in a fixed location.
In a network optimized for mostly mobile usage, most cell sites are divided into three 120-degree sectors (or more using smart antennas) to maximize capacity. Traffic loads are then predicated on mobility – devices moving from sector to sector and from cell site to cell site. Introducing a lot of fixed services into this type of network can result in diminished capacity for a sector and slower data speeds for mobile users, because a number of heavy duty users are taking up capacity in a sector, and not moving on. But in planning mobile broadband, it has to be assumed that many users will want to consume high bandwidth services, often in a fixed location (even if using a mobile device like a notebook or phone). Sprint has already discovered this in its launch of QChat push to talk ‘ to deliver that service to all its customer base, it has had to build out full broadband capability, using EV-DO Rev A, to the very edges of its network. This investment is justified by the level of improved ARPU and customer retention Sprint expects to get from reviving its push to talk flagship application, but it also offers the carrier the opportunity to use the newly dense network, which can support greater levels of fixed usage, for a new set of services ‘ even before it starts to reap benefits from its Xohm/Clearwire WiMAX venture.
3 will find the same balance of increased expense, and increased complexity in balancing and prioritizing networks, with new service opportunities, as it extends HSPA to the very edges of its network. The cell sites located at the edge of the network will probably be only lightly used for mobile data and so there will be spare capacity that could be used for fixed wireless, especially in rural areas.
In the US, Sprint Nextel is going a step further in keeping its busiest cells for mobile users and using up spare capacity on edge cells with fixed services that generate additional revenue. It is reported to be looking for resellers that will offer fixed broadband wireless using the EV-DO network, but only targeting specific rural areas. This is an extension of the MVNO model that, for a while at least, helped revive Sprint’s fortunes prior to its Nextel merger ‘ enlisting third parties to ensure that a new or underused network is maximized in capacity/ROI terms, but with fixed services, of course, this additional revenue can be precisely targeted to areas of underused EV-DO. A similar approach could well be adopted by Clearwire for its WiMAX network.
Note: Telefonica-owned UK cellco O2 is considering plans to match British Telecom’s recent promise of 50Mbps broadband services to the home using fiber. However, O2 needs Ofcom to amend regulations first to allow private companies to make “healthy returns” on their investment. O2 said: “We need clear and unambiguous regulation in place before we start shelling out huge sums of money.” BT and Virgin Media have already announced fiber to the home plans while BSkyB is said to be considering fiber to the kerb.