Since mobile operators started looking to data to balance falling growth in voice revenues, and the internet began to be mobilized, some momentous choices have hung over the cellcos. As the developed economies shift uneasily towards an open access, flat rate model similar to that of the PC internet, the most fundamental choice is whether an operator aims primarily to be the owner and operator of a network, or a differentiated provider of services.
Some, like T-Mobile, are looking to reduce their commitment to infrastructure, via outsourcing or partnership, and to become retail brands that, in time, will fall little short of an MVNO (see previous item). As such, the German operator is focusing heavily on establishing a unique, operator-defined user experience for mobile broadband, with services like its web ‘n’ walk flat rate internet offering and integration with Wi-Fi hotspots. Although it will work with third party interfaces and services too, such as Nokia’s Ovi, it aims to retain pole position in the value chain and create a unique combination of applications, user interface, tariffs and bundles to keep the users loyal, and to balance increased usage with high value services. Outside central Europe, T-Mobile could extend this concept through full MVNOs; even in key territories like the UK it is engaged in backhaul outsourcing and RAN sharing to reduce its network operating activities.
Some operators will still look to differentiate their business models, and attract new revenues, by owning and controlling their own networks. These will be under pressure to keep their infrastructure at the cutting edge, and are likely to find, over time, that the cost of doing this can only be justified if the cellco leases capacity to other providers, rather than running the network purely for its own benefit. Operators that have moved into RAN sharing and MVNO wholesaling have already taken a step towards emulating the wholesale approach common to the wireline telcos, and there will, consequently, be rising business pressure to become the much talked-of ‘bit pipes’, carrying huge quantities of internet traffic of all kinds. This may be on a white label basis, or the operator may exploit the advanced nature of its network, and its own economies, to compete under its own brand as a bit pipe, offering the most attractive tariffs and flat rate service bundles.
This seems to be the direction in which the 3 Group is veering, judging by the comments of its UK CEO Kevin Russell, in the wake of the first quarter when the Hutchison-owned 3G-only group reported its first operating profit. This long awaited turnaround has been driven largely by the recent success of 3’s internet data offerings, particularly its HSPA USB dongles, which come with a flat rate, prepaid option that poses a serious alternative to Wi-Fi hotspots for the business traveller. 3 was launched amid the wave of euphoria that surrounded European UMTS, when it was assumed success would be assured by ‘killer apps’ made possible by the new fast networks. In fact, Wi-Fi showed up the actual slowness of those networks and most of the killer apps proved less attractive to the public than the real killer app, cheap voice. 3, then, has derived most of its growth from using the efficiency of its modern network ‘ with no GSM legacy ‘ to deliver low cost voice while retaining reasonable margins. Now it has adapted this viewpoint to data, and is moving aggressively into well priced, flat rate internet and content tariffs. These are the headline for its service offerings, rather than advanced and unique interfaces, or a highly branded applications portal. The handsets and dongles carry the brand, with a heavy focus on operator labelled models, rather than the web experience, and the most prominent brand association is with good flat rate tariffs and easy access to popular applications ‘ from third parties, not branded by 3.
This strategy was kicked off 18 months ago when 3 entered the mobile data market with a bang, with the launch of its X-Series offering, a set of third party internet apps within a portal, and combined with then-revolutionary all-you-can-eat price options. The disruptiveness has come from being first to market with ISP-style internet pricing, and from pre-installing apps like Skype that are inherently challenging to the traditional cellco model, but poster children for the internet approach. Thus 3, once a great resister of the fall of the walled garden, became the operator that most aggressively grasped the nettle and brought the walls crashing down itself. (Part of the reason to focus on operator branded handsets is that it can put brands such as Skype on devices optimized for that service, a key draw for consumers.)
CEO Russell, then, sees 3G and 4G as conduits for the mobile internet, but does not believe that internet needs to be different, in how it is used and presented to the consumer, from the PC internet. Despite 3 being a wireless-only operator in Europe, he does not seem to believe in the wireless-only quad play, admitting that fixed broadband is better than mobile when the user does not need to move around, but voicing no plans to try to use HSPA as a fixed technology, unlike some carriers (probably because 3 operates in markets where DSL is already almost ubiquitous). “I don’t believe mobile broadband is as good as fixed, and I’m not going to bang a drum and say mobile will replace fixed,’ he said last week in an interview.
Another way in which Russell seems an iconoclast in a Europe dominated by the cellco-turns-content-provider model, is that he is dismissive of the new wave of ‘killer apps’, notably mobile TV ‘ although in Italy 3 is involved in this activity heavily ‘ and thinks the carrier should focus, ISP-like, on core internet services like email, VoIP and instant messaging, which require fat, efficient networks; rather than on developing differentiated content, which needs a whole new set of skills and partnerships. This is a clear indicator that 3 aims to compete based on the efficiency and advanced state of its network as a data pipe, making it well placed for the trend towards open access to any device ‘ despite the current success of some devices that are certainly tied to its network. Since it introduced the dongles in October 2007, up until the end of February, it saw data throughput on its network increase sevenfold. “But there are some bandwagons 3 is not big enough to jump on,’ Russell said. ‘We need to be a more focused company and not get distracted by services such as mobile TV.”
Russell acknowledges that he and his counterparts throughout the sector need to make key choices about their business model for the mobile internet quickly, as only the very largest will be able to sustain a network-focused approach, whether wholesale or retail bit pipe, plus a differentiated content and services approach, simultaneously, for very long, at least without endangering margins and brand identity and creating conflicts of interest. Some, though, will try to do both, especially those that move into 4G-class networks early and can embrace open internet norms, advanced interfaces and applications, and super-efficient networks at the stage where these still add competitive edge. These are the advantages Sprint Nextel hopes to gain for its Xohm WiMAX service, and if it were not for the financial travails of its parent, Xohm would be a good blueprint for the so-called ‘smart pipe’ operator, which does rely on having a very efficient, very fat pipe, that can support both wholesale and retail services at flat rates and true broadband capacity; but which also looks to establish a highly differentiated brand through cutting edge devices and applications, with an operator-controlled portal and user experience designed to lure consumers away from fully open access, with the delights of a truly advanced mobile internet platform.