Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2006

900MHz bands becomes more useful on both sides of the Atlantic

The range limitations of wireless technologies in higher reaches of the spectrum are increasingly a preoccupation for operators under pressure to deliver 3G-class services in rural areas. The newer networks offer the high bandwidth to support almost-broadband data and multimedia, but tend to have spectrum allocated significantly above that of GSM and 2G CDMA (WiMAX in 2.5GHz and 3.5GHz, W-CDMA in 2.1GHz and so on). In sparsely populated or low income areas, having any access at all is more important than achieving 1Mbps-plus per user, and it can be economically impractical to build out the small cells that the smaller range above 2GHz demand. This has focused operator attention on the potential of using 450MHz bands for rural areas, and the latest interest is in the 900MHz frequencies. In Europe, these are GSM territory, but could now support 3G services too; while in the US, where 26MHz of the band is unlicensed, it can be deployed as a complement to Wi-Fi or WiMAX.

In Europe last week, Nortel, Qualcomm and Orange completed UMTS and HSDPA calls in the 900MHz band, and claimed this will be a cost effective way for many operators to deliver nationwide coverage since it offers 60% reduction in cell sites required to serve rural areas and enhances in-building penetration by 25%.

“UMTS in the 900 MHz band is a complementary solution to existing 3G services that will enable Orange to provide high speed wireless internet to both rural and urban areas of France, thereby enabling us to deliver a true nationwide UMTS/HSDPA service,” said Vivek Badrinath, executive vice president of products, technology and innovation at Orange.

This will be an alternative to 450MHz solutions for operators as they start to switch capacity from GSM to 3G. Most European regulators do not currently allow 450MHz ‘ the former analog mobile spectrum ‘ to be used for 3G, fearing dilution of service quality, a view enshrined in a close decision made late last year by the Swedish authorities, which had been petitioned by two 3G operators to permit the 450MHz band to be used for rural coverage.

Although 450MHz supports even longer ranges and greater efficiency than 900MHz, it has the disadvantage for a GSM/UMTS carrier of not currently supporting a technology from this stable ‘ although Nokia and Ericsson are developing a GSM implementation for this band which they claim will support profitable ARPU rates of $5 a month (see Wireless Watch October 17 2005 edition). The main technology available for 3G-class services in 450MHz is Qualcomm’s CDMA450, which now supports the new EV-DO flavor and is being deployed in many eastern European regions. The Flash-OFDM broadband network now owned by Qualcomm can also run in 450MHz thanks to a joint development between its creator Flarion and Siemens, as can the IPWireless implementation of TD-CDMA.

For western European countries where UMTS is a requirement, and to support a coherent technology base, a 900MHz option for UMTS and HSDPA is likely to be the simplest and least controversial way of extending access to areas where a 2.1GHz roll-out would be hard to justify economically.

Meanwhile, over the Atlantic, there are always attempts to increase the usability of the unlicensed portion (902MHz to 928MHz) of the band, despite its well documented problems ‘ small channels, lack of bandwidth and interference, as many services including baby monitors and cordless phones crowd in alongside wireless access. Some service providers have managed to build successful 900MHz networks in rural areas and vendors working in this band, such as WaveRider, have put significant effort into anti-interference mechanisms.

The most recent attempt to exploit 900MHz more effectively comes from a start-up called Ubiquiti Networks, founded last year, which has created a high power 900MHz mini-PCI radio module, called SuperRange 9, which can be combined with Wi-Fi or, in future, WiMAX to transmit the signals over far greater distances. It can be used in a mesh configuration to achieve lower cost blanketing of a district, especially one that is too sparsely populated to justify the large number of access points needed in 2.4GHz or, even more, 5GHz, or one with large numbers of obstacles such as buildings (lower frequencies also support non-line of sight more effectively than those above 2GHz).

The SuperRange 9 features 700mW output power capability, and claims highly sensitive receiver antennas and advanced anti-interference mechanisms to create a Wi-Fi class user experience in 900MHz and at long distances from the access point (at least a kilometre). The radio platform, which is based on Wi-Fi silicon from Atheros, in effect converts a Wi-Fi signal to 900MHz and will be adapted in future for many frequencies up to 60GHz. It provides full integration with standard Wi-Fi systems and so can be accessed by any 802.11 equipment. There is only room for one 20MHz Wi-Fi class channel on the 900MHz band but Ubiquiti says its technology delivers the full 54Mbps of 802.11g in this, for lower cost than existing specialist solutions for the frequency.

“900MHz will be a very attractive addition to the increasingly popular city Wi-Fi market,’ said Ubiquiti. “If it can be integrated into the mesh infrastructure and client premise equipment, it could significantly improve the value proposition of municipal Wi-Fi networking since it can penetrate buildings and foliage.”