Year-old start-up Aerohive Networks is promising cheaper corporate WLans by reversing the switch architecture currently in common use, in an approach it dubs ‘cooperative access points’.
Switches or controllers – which centralize WLan security, roaming and management and usually operate with thin or dumb access points – have been gradually taking the place of the old fat AP architecture over the past few years, benefiting pioneers like Aruba, Trapeze and Airespace (the last of these acquired by Cisco). Each AP tunnels back to the controller over the wired net, sending to it all data and control packets, and standards are under development for these tunnelling processes.
Aerohive distributes many of the functions of the controller through a mesh of intelligent APs, each with its own IP address, and the devices then work cooperatively together, pooling their resources to carry out the switch’s tasks and making that expensive device redundant. This leads to a simpler and cheaper architecture, claims Aerohive, that is especially suited to branch locations or non-office environments such as retail stores, where there may not be IT support on-site. It also says its approach provides superior scaling and load balancing because of the shared architecture, and so is more reliable.
To run with the HiveAP network comes a PC-based network management appliance called HiveManager, and a Java application that links a central administrator with the HiveManager features, for tasks such as setting and updating user and group security and mobility policies, monitoring network performance and tracking use trends. The HiveAP 20 has two radios – 802.11a and 802.11g and costs $995, while the network management software costs $4,995. HiveAPs can wirelessly communicate with each other via a mesh protocol, and when needed, they become portals that are wired into any existing Ethernet switch port to connect with the wired Lan. The code on the APs supports identity-based security, QoS enforced at the edge, autodiscovery of neighboring access points, mesh and best-path-forwarding protocols.
When WLan users are moving around, the AP to which they are attached shares the session encryption key and user data with its neighbors, and algorithms use changing signal strength and other factors to detect the users’ motion and predict which APs will be the best for the next association. This is an approach that has already been adopted by some of the classic switchmakers to reduce load on the controller and speed up roaming for VoIP – Trapeze, for instance, introduced the option for the AP to take over traffic forwarding and QoS functions last year.
Aerohive claims its products can be deployed for about one-half to one-third of the cost – depending on scale and number of branch sites – of a similar roll-out using Cisco 2000 and 4400 controllers with Cisco 1130 APs.
HiveAP differs from old standalone APs because it supports mobility and roaming, and because the pooled approach means functions are still centralized across the WLan, even if they are physically distributed. Aerohive’s work fits neatly into the emerging ‘fourth generation’ of enterprise WLans, which will gradually evolve from, and take over from, the switches. Vendors are working on various approaches to enhancing the switch architecture for very large deployments featuring carrier class voice, although Aerohive goes further than the others in bypassing the large switch altogether. Increased integration of wireless and wireline Lans will also stimulate a move away from standalone wireless switches. In general, the challenge to the conventional controller approach will take two forms – towards more complex, scalable technologies, such as Meru’s, for wireless dominated sites; or towards more integrated, low cost options for wired/wireless sites.
The switch/controller architecture is set to dominate enterprise WLan roll-outs in 2006-8 and even beyond (switches are expected to account for over half of total enterprise WLan spending by 2009), but in the fourth generation, new approaches are already emerging to challenge or enhance the switches. As well as Aerohive, these are epitomized by the offerings of Extricom, Meru and Xirrus, all of which are addressing scalability and roaming in particular. Their techniques are sure to be eyed carefully by Cisco and any of these pioneers would be heavily tipped to be a Cisco acquisition target in 2007-8.
Xirrus is addressing deployment and scalability challenges by integrating as many as 16 radios and a controller into a single AP and using sectorized antennas to support narrow pie-slice shaped cells, an approach resembling that taken by cellular networks. Extricom and Meru have adopted a more radical approach, replacing conventional channel planning design in favor of a single-channel architecture with the goal of addressing interference and roaming problems. Meru has adopted a ‘blanket’ or mesh architecture, initially for backhaul, in which the APs all use the same WLan channel or channels, leaving others free for backhaul or a specific application like VoIP. By contrast, Xirrus uses a sectorized architecture in which one AP contains up to 16 radios, which use directional antennas to reach a section of the building and avoid interfering with one another. In both cases, because the WLan appears to clients as a single AP operating on one channel, rather than multiple APs operating on different channels, as is the case with older designs, roaming is extremely fast.
The other shift away from switches, in the low cost arena, was pioneered in February 2005, when Broadcom announced a chipset that made wireless into a simple appliance, one function within a general purpose Ethernet switch. Other companies have joined the trend, such as NextHop Technologies, which acquired technology from now defunct switch company Legra and incorporated this into its UNS 4.0 platform, which allows a WLan and a regular Ethernet switch to be merged by system designers. As well as aiding convergence, this trend would significantly cut the cost of building and running WLans. NextHop, for instance, has been working with low cost Taiwanese vendors on unified switches. The process of incorporating the WLan into the generic router will accelerate and play into the hands of Cisco.
Aerohive:
Aerohive was founded in 2006. The company is closely connected through its heritage with Juniper Networks. Its CEO David Flynn was previously head of marketing at security specialist NetScreen Technologies, which was acquired by Juniper for $4bn in 2005, while CTO Changming Liu was formerly a distinguished engineer at Juniper. The start-up is funded to the tune of $6m by Lightspeed Venture Partners, whose partners also came out of Juniper and NetScreen, and Northern Light Venture Capital. The company is focusing heavily on China for R&D skills and marketing, and 30 of its 50 engineers are based there.