Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 July 2008

AlcaLu chiefs to quit, but this will address few of the vendor’s real issues

Alcatel-Lucent has had one of the more painful mergers of recent years and has suffered a string of disastrous quarters, so there is a natural wish among investors for the management team that architected the deal to take the consequences, and for a new broom to sweep away the pain of the past 18 months. But sometimes even poor performance is the best an executive team could do, and uncertainty added to difficult market conditions can be worse than even a miserable stability. The departure of CEO Pat Russo and chairman Serge Tchuruk will only result in a shiny new Alcatel-Lucent if its woes prove to be something they could have addressed more effectively, and if someone else is found rapidly to restore confidence and to take that effective action.

In reality, two major problems are dogging the giant Franco-American venture ‘ the weak dollar, for a company that bills half its revenues in dollars or related currencies but reports in (strong) euros; and the decline of the CDMA business. Clearly the former is not something the current management could influence, though AlcaLu does seem to have weathered the storm worse than its major rivals, NSN and Ericsson, both European too (though Ericsson reports in Swedish kronor, but this currency has also gained on the dollar this year, by a factor of 8%, about the same as the euro. And Ericsson has an even greater exposure to the dollar than AlcaLu, at 58%.)

The CDMA situation is one reason why AlcaLu has been even more adversely affected by currency trends than its European rivals, but again, many of the factors would have been pretty much the same whoever was in the CEO role, and at least Russo has a deep understanding of the CDMA market that remains.

But undoubtedly, even by the sorry standards of mega-mergers, the Alcatel-Lucent marriage has been badly managed, and the comments and statements of the key players this week have pointed to the severe culture clash that has afflicted performance. Alcatel was, despite many years of acquisitions around the world, a truly French company, headed by a sharp politician, Tchuruk, and owing some of its success to subtle tactics that would have been regarded as obscure by US counterparts. The speculation that a prime candidate to replace Russo might be Thierry Breton, former French finance minister and head of France Telecom in the days when it was hardly pretending to have moved beyond nationalization, show that Alcatel-Lucent is a French company still, in which there has been only a grudging tolerance of Russo and the Lucent team. Only spectacular success would have gained her more than that ‘ as it is, her half of the company, the world leader in CDMA, is the main problem Easier to make a scapegoat of the CEO than conclude that Alcatel’s board and management were foolhardy to take on a major CDMA vendor just at the point of crisis in that market. This has been combined with difficulty in the other wireless infrastructure sectors and the challenge of integrating other Alcatel acquisitions such as Nortel’s W-CDMA business and the former Fujitsu venture ‘ and with AlcaLu gaining economies of scale, but with its targets being vendors with virtually no exposure to CDMA, namely Ericsson and NSN.

Reporting its sixth consecutive quarter of losses, during which period the merged company has halved in value, AlcaLu conceded that ‘CDMA activity declined at a higher pace than the company had planned. This was due, to a large extent, to a strong reduction in the capital expenditure of a key customer in North America. Although there are new opportunities in other geographic areas, the uncertainty regarding spending in North America has led the company to take more cautious midterm assumptions in this activity.’ This setback led to a non-cash impairment charge of €810m ($1.28bn) against the CDMA business, which was also written down in the fourth quarter of last year. That charge pushed AlcaLu’s net loss for the second quarter to €1.1bn ($1.73bn), or €0.49 per share. Excluding that writedown, and some smaller charges related to the ongoing Alcatel/Lucent merger process, the company’s second quarter adjusted net loss was €222m ($349m), or €0.10 per share. Revenues were €4.1bn ($6.45bn), down 5.2% year-on-year. With a constant dollar:euro currency rate over last year, revenues would have grown 1.7%, but the carrier business would still have suffered a 3% decline, while in real terms, this unit saw a 9.4% drop to €2.8bn ($4.4bn).

Outside the CDMA minefield, and the fixed access space, where Russo noted weakness in Europe, there are signs of hope, notably ‘stronger than expected demand for GSM/W-CDMA mobile access in emerging markets, especially in Asia. In addition, we feel positive about our prospects in China, both in 2G and 3G (including CDMA EV-DO) for the fourth quarter and next year.’ AlcaLu expects its third quarter revenues to be flat or slightly down compared with the second quarter, with a ‘strong ramp’ in fourth quarter sales, in line with seasonal trends.

The danger for AlcaLu for the rest of this difficult year will be handling the uncertainty of a potentially prolonged leadership search ‘ the boost that the prospect of a new broom gave the markets will be quickly deflated by a long period of stagnation, especially given the ongoing resurgence of NSN and the consistently excellent leadership of Carl-Henric Svanberg at Ericsson, even in the current hard times. Apart from Breton ‘ unlikely to inspire huge investr confidence outside France ‘ the prime candidates also reflect the fact that AlcaLu is now a European company operating largely in European-driven technologies like W-CDMA, despite the huge downside of that positioning, the weak dollar. The most impressive whispered candidate is Ben Vervaayen, recently departed CEO of British Telecom, who certainly understands how to drag a sleeping giant, drugged by its nationalized European roots, into the tough world of twenty first century telecoms and media.

Alcatel-Lucent and services:

Alcatel-Lucent’s services division was the star of the second quarter, with revenues up 9.1% year-on-year at €818m ($1.3bn). And the company expects that trend to continue in the coming quarters: ‘We now see a stronger than initially expected demand in services, especially in network operations and network integration,’ the vendor noted.

AlcaLu is emulating Ericsson by heightening its focus on services, where there are better margins than in the increasingly pressurized equipment market. The services unit, which is particularly strong in building customized systems for public sector organizations, doubled in size last year to generate €3.2bn ($5.02bnn) of the company’s €17.8bn in annual revenue. Most of the services business, like those of Ericsson and NSN, comes from managing networks for operators, but Alcatel-Lucent is branching out strongly into an area where it is more differentiated, building private communication networks for government and transport agencies, utilities, and other customers with specialized requirements and extreme security concerns.

All the vendors are trying to find areas where they can be uniquely positioned in services ‘ Ericsson is looking to managed content, IPTV and media offerings, and NSN has inherited various areas of activity, especially in the public sector, from its Siemens co-parent.

But AlcaLu is the most aggressive about going beyond telcos and taking on the more generic integrators and services giants such as IBM and Accenture. Indeed, the head of AlcaLu’s services arm, Andy Williams, is a long time veteran of IBM.