Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 June 2008

AlcaLu’s Chinese deal highlights RAN pressures on Ericsson

As Nokia is to handsets, Ericsson is to RAN infrastructure ‘ every time it appears to be under pressure, its scale and market weight enable it to pull something out of the hat to protect its lead. The Swedish giant has seen lacklustre results recently, and despite beating market expectations, its first quarter suffered a sharp year-on-year downturn amid economic uncertainty, vicious price competition (partly driven by Ericsson itself) and a fallback by its Sony Ericsson handset venture. Then last week saw Alcatel-Lucent snatching a $1bn deal with China Mobile that many thought was sure to go to Ericsson, and there are rising fears that the Swede may have overplayed its hand on its strategy of undercutting the market on equipment sales and focusing on services ‘ as Nokia Siemens refuses to play ball, and the Chinese challengers, Huawei and ZTE, turn their own attention to services. Yet despite all these challenges, the latest figures on the RAN equipment market show Ericsson widening its lead over the pack, taking a massive 32% share. So is the mighty Swede vulnerable, as Nokia Siemens would have us believe, with its recent aggressive statements of intent to snatch the number one spot?

Ericsson’s biggest challenge has been to reduce its dependence on the market it dominates, amid assumptions that the RAN infrastructure sector will contract after the current wave of 3G expansion dissipates ‘ both because of economic conditions, and the likely shift of the market towards more off-the-shelf, low margin RAN formats at the 4G stage. It has leveraged its scale to compete even with Huawei on price and financing terms, and focused on balancing out low margin and even loss leading hardware deals with managed services contracts, a policy that has reaped dividends in India and elsewhere. Meanwhile, it has invested in expanding into convergence, IPTV and mobile platforms, and recently showed its determination not to become merely a giant box shifter, when it outlined a five-year, $25bn R&D program focused on six areas where it believes there will be high growth and the opportunity to dominate the market ‘ these are LTE; VoIP; GPON and VDSL2+; RCS/MCS (platforms for rich media and mobile multimedia services); Near Field Communications; and IPTV/personalized TV (see Wireless Watch May 21 2008).

This will shore up the company against likely constriction in its core market, but most of the efforts will not generate significant revenues for at least two years, so Ericsson has a transition period when it needs to keep costs down and market share high, and harness its scale to snatch as much as possible of whatever RAN revenues are on offer, however pressurized this market may become. And signs of that pressure are showing, with the latest figures from Infonetics on the RAN equipment sector indicating that, in the first quarter, revenues fell 14% compared to the last quarter of 2007 ‘ though this was partly a seasonal factor, since revenues actually rose 3% year-on-year, mainly because of some huge deals for GSM expansion, which has proved Ericsson’s surprise savior in the past year, in India and China. RAN sales amounted to $10.1bn in the quarter, with Ericsson on 32% global market share, followed by Nokia Siemens (NSN), Alcatel-Lucent, and Nortel.

However, the key growth areas in the RAN, as identified by Infonetics, both hold seeds of fear for Ericsson, and highlight why it urgently needs to reduce its reliance on a RAN sector that is turning against its model, and adopting new approaches where rivals like NSN are making faster progress. The two stars of the sector were the soft mobile switching center (MSC), which provides call control, signalling, and intelligence for mobile networks, and this is expected to remain a growth driver at least until 2011; and the 3G microcell or picocell. These trends are worrying for Ericsson because NSN is the leader in the former technology, supplying about 150 carriers; and the operator shift towards smaller base stations (microcells and eventually femtocells), which help them improve coverage and capacity at low cost, threatens the key margin generator and centerpiece of the traditional Ericsson model, the macrocell.

Other equipment majors are also threatened by the shift to lower margin, more commoditized base stations, but NSN and Huawei, in particular, seem more agile in their response, and in seizing the opportunities of new approaches to network design. One of the most important is the evolution of the flat network, which is another trend that vendors might have preferred to have ignored, given the number of network elements (and so revenue opportunities) it eliminates. But with flat all-IP systems like WiMAX and LTE on the horizon, it cannot be ignored, and NSN has certainly grasped the nettle more effectively than its Swedish rival.

Indeed NSN – whose management team have come out of the painful teething troubles of the venture’s first year in fighting mood ‘ has put the flat network at the forefront of its bid to overtake Ericsson in RAN infrastructure revenues by 2011. CEO Simon Beresford-Wylie says flat networks can be implemented at the HSPA stage, generating operator efficiencies and vendor revenues long before LTE becomes a reality, and like Qualcomm the company is focusing heavily on prolonging the life and revenue potential of the HSPA family. This is understandable, given that pre-venture Nokia pioneered the flat HSPA network with its Internet-HSPA architecture, and NSN remains the only supplier with a credible offering here.
‘We’re evangelists about flat IP architecture, and we’re not waiting for LTE,’ said Beresford-Wylie at a recent conference.

There are various approaches to flattening the data network to support lower cost broadband IP services now and ease migration to 4G. NSN backs a flat HSPA and HSPA+ approach based around the Direct Tunnel architecture endorsed by the 3GPP. This allows the RNC (radio network controller) to be integrated into the Node B so that the base station communicates directly with the GGSN (Gateway GPRS Support Node), pushing traffic directly on to the network without intermediate elements. Benefits include lower latency for data, lower running costs, greater capacity via the data network overlay, and a smooth path to the similar architecture of LTE (SAE or System Architecture Evolution). However, there is a lot of disruption for operators with existing, hierarchical 3G networks and there are technical difficulties in integrating the RNC into the base station, while preserving the RNC’s support for macro-diversity. NSN has been forced to adopt an ‘unorthodox’ approach to offer this support, according to analysts at Heavy Reading. However, it has snapped up three, admittedly midrange, customers ‘ Stelera Wireless and TerreStar in the US and T-2 in Slovenia ‘ and Mobilkom Austria is in trials. More importantly, this is one of many areas of RAN design where NSN is setting itself up as an innovator with a highly differentiated story, and one that will enable it to score points against Ericsson. Marc Rouanne, head of RAN at NSN, recently outlined three product areas that he believes, in combination, will enable his company to overtake Ericsson in the RAN – a flexible base station product portfolio, flat IP architecture technology, and a focus on operations support and business support systems. The former AlcaLu executive said on taking his new role that NSN was now a ‘strong number two’ and had ‘strong assets to compete for the number one position.’

All this is designed, in NSN’s eyes, to keep it aloof from the maelstrom of price cutting that is threatening to drag Ericsson and the Chinese vendors down into the world of razor thin margins, especially in high volume but price sensitive markets like India. NSN pulled out of a GSM expansion deal with India’s BSNL last year, claiming the pricing was unsustainable and it had been excessively undercut by Ericsson (Ericsson had already won the lion’s share of the deal, but the NSN portion of the contract will now be re-awarded). Beresford-Wylie recently echoed accusations by AlcaLu chairman Serge Tchuruk about Ericsson’s driving of the market towards “silly pricing”, and said this is now shifting into the managed services market. Talking to Light Reading last month, NSN’s chief said he wanted to spread the word that the price situation was running out of control. ‘Our statements were for our customers to hear, and our employees, to know that we are focused on profitability. Our noise got equal attention from rivals, customers, and employees. That sort of pricing is destroying value, and the operators in India are making good margins, even if them ARPUs are low.” However, he says the pricing of mobile infrastructure deals has improved, but ‘irrationality’ has now spread to managed services, with many vendors rushing to gain a share in the developing market.

A key market where the pricing models of the various giants will be tested will be China, where significant GSM expansion will soon be followed by 3G build-out, first by China Mobile’s TD-SCDMA system this year, and then by the other operators following 3G auctions expected after the Olympic Games this summer. Here NSN may be less well positioned than the homegrown vendors, Huawei and ZTE; Ericsson, which has been working closely with Chinese companies on LTE standards, in particular, and also on TD-SCDMA; and Alcatel-Lucent, which through its Alcatel Shanghai Bell venture and other well established relationships has always had a strong position in the vast country.

This strength was highlighted with the award to AlcaLu of China Mobile’s $1bn deal for core and RAN systems, a huge contract that covers TD-SCDMA 3G as well as GSM, and is highly likely to lead to follow-on business with the world’s largest mobile operator by subscriber numbers. China Mobile is also likely to be a very early adopter of LTE, which it will trial later this year with Verizon Wireless and Vodafone – despite being, to some extent, stuck with TD-SCDMA because of Chinese 3G politics, it may also use W-CDMA in some regions, and certainly plans to make up for any shortcomings in the homegrown platform with early roll-out of 4G hotzones.

All this offers much needed hope to the beleaguered French company, and the deal helped spark a wave of concern about Ericsson’s ability to compete in one of the major new 3G markets. The Swedish giant was sufficiently worried by the reaction to AlcaLu’s win that CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg himself ‘ not one to overreact ‘ made various statements denying that his company was ever competing for the Chinese megadeal. The company insisted, however, that it had developed a full TD-SCDMA platform and, despite Svanberg’s studied indifference to the China Mobile business, his head of RAN products, Ulf Ewaldsson, is still confident of getting future sales. He said recently that Ericsson was ready to supply TD-SCDMA to China Mobile ‘and will be part of their purchasing going forward. We are doing entire networks for TD-SCDMA and we will be able to offer a complete portfolio if they have the desire to move forward. We will be able to provide what we believe is the world’s best possible TD-SCDMA solution.’ The problem for any company that has invested in this system is that China Mobile may well be the only operator ever to deploy it ‘ so if AlcaLu follows through on its initial success and ties up the bulk of that roll-out, Ericsson will be left waiting for the 4G stage to get a return on its investment. Here, it should be well placed, as it has worked intensively with Chinese authorities and vendors to devise a TDD portion of the LTE standard, heavily based on the next generation of TD-SCDMA.

Alcatel-Lucent’s trials:

Ericsson may be under pressure, but Alcatel-Lucent continues to flounder. An article in BusinessWeek last week posed the question whether CEO Patricia Russo could hold on to her position for much longer, following an annual shareholders’ meeting in Paris at which her presentation was met with boos and catcalls from investors. Since Lucent’s merger with Alcatel in 2006, the vendor has posted six consecutive quarterly losses and has taken more than $4.5bn in writedowns, while its stock has plummeted 50%. Although all RAN vendors are feeling the pinch, AlcaLu is performing worse than the rest of the pack, and Huawei is starting to catch up with it in some key markets, including IP DSL and even GSM. Outside the US, the Chinese vendor is now said to be neck-and-neck with AlcaLu in GSM.

Like its larger competitors, AlcaLu is looking to increase its focus on convergence, software and services to improve its differentiation and margins. Last week, it announced an agreement to acquire Motive, a provider of service management software for broadband and mobile data services, for $67.8m. The cash offer values Motive stock at $2.23 per share, a premium of approximately 53% over the closing price of the shares on June 16. The transaction is expected to close by early in the fourth quarter of 2008

The acquisition follows a three-year relationship between the two companies during which jointly developed and sold remote management software for automating the deployment, configuration and support of residential gateways. They have 40-odd joint customers, including AT&T, Verizon, BT and Swisscom. Motive has 300 employees worldwide with R&D operations in Austin, Texas, and Bangalore, India. It will become part of Alcatel-Lucent’s Fixed Access Division, within the Carrier Business Group.