Alcatel-Lucent has bought some time to deliver on its turnaround plan at last, securing €1.6bn in loan financing in a deal underwritten by investment banks Credit Suisse and Goldman Sachs. This will allow Alcatel-Lucent ‘aggressively’ to consider all its options to boost profitability, sort out the balance sheet and refine its business strategy, said embattled CEO Ben Verwaayen, whose success in restoring profitability proved shortlived amid the eurozone crisis and rising competition in key ALU markets.
The financing will be secured by assets including the firm’s huge portfolio of patents ‘ about 29,000 patents, many acquired with Lucent’s Bell Labs unit and valued at €5bn, according to ALU. The firm had previously considered the sale or spin-off of some of these assets as an option in improving its financial stability.
Despite a radical programme of downsizing, unit sell-offs, stepped-up patent licensing activities and new product launches, Verwaayen has failed to reduce the company’s average annual cash consumption of €700m, which has been the level since the hugely difficult merger of Alcatel and Lucent in 2006.
According to Bloomberg, more radical change can now be expected as ALU uses its cash breathing space to rethink its business. This could include the sale of assets worth €1bn to €1.5bn, with its submarine cable and enterprise business units likely to be the first to go.
Alcatel-Lucent also offered new guidance for 2015 gross margin, in the range of 35% to 37%, and adjusted operating margin of 6% to 9%. However, some analysts remained sceptical that Verwaayen would deliver on its new promises. Pierre Ferragu of Bernstein Research told Reuters: ‘We don’t believe the 2015 target presented by management is credible. It implies a significant recovery in gross margins in optics and a stabilisation of negative trends at most other business units.’
Others said that, while the new credit facilities improved liquidity and gave ALU more space to make positive changes, they did not solve any underlying problems such as weak and unsustainable profits, falling market share, poor free cashflow, and, as JP Morgan put it, ‘an overall company debt level that looks too high for a cyclical technology company’.
The development highlighted many of the problems which still continue to drag ALU down, despite strong leadership, innovative products such as the lightRadio architecture, and a multiyear restructuring program. The filings made for the firm’s new creditors provide the kind of detailed breakdown which the company does not usually offer in its quarterly results reports. In particular, analysts noted very low gross margins in ALU’s optical business (17% for terrestrial optics and 29% for submarine, compared to around 40% for key rivals in the space). That could put these businesses in Verwaayen’s firing line, or at least spark major reorganization. Gross margins in wireless are 35% while the highest figure is seen in the IP division, which includes routers and other such equipment.
The ALU saga in particular, and the Eurozone recession in general, is raising the issue of how far European governments should shore up their vendors and operators in difficult times ‘ common practice in earlier decades but frowned upon by the European Union. The latest loans to ALU have raised concerns at the French government, according to local newspapers, because the company is using its patents as collateral. This risks vital intellectual property falling into foreign hands, says Les Echos. The government is reportedly considering alternatives to IPR-backed loans such as reducing the amount Alcatel-Lucent is borrowing, or lessening the collateral, which some politicians think should include direct government involvement and financial support. Other options are said to include setting up a consortium to license rather than sell the patents.
In Germany, the government is reportedly planning, indirectly, to support Deutsche Telekom’s recently-announced €30bn investment plan in fiber and 4G. According to newspaper Handelsblatt, the government may allow the incumbent operator to waive dividend payments to state-owned investment bank KfW, and issue new shares instead. The state owns a 15% direct stake in Deutsche Telekom as well as a 17% indirect stake through KfW.