The US’ fifth mobile carrier, Alltel, has been the subject of acquisition rumors for at least two years, but these are now looking likely to come true. The regional carrier, which has raised its game significantly in the past year with advanced mobile internet strategies, innovative pricing and network expansion, could attract a strong valuation.
According to the Wall Street Journal, three groups of private equity firms are considering a bid – a combination of the Blackstone Group and Providence Equity Partners; TPG Capital working with Goldman Sachs’ PE arm; and the Carlyle Group and Kohlberg Kravis Roberts. Each of the companies has already held strategic meetings with Alltel’s management team, following the recent announcement to shareholders by CEO Scott Ford that Alltel was reviewing “a broad spectrum of options” for its future.
However, the rising value of Alltel may encourage some potential acquirers to hold back for a better price, especially with the US cellular market expected to get far more cut throat. Alltel’s shares have increased in value by 7.8% the year, and some analysts believe it could achieve a purchase price of $70 a share. The consensus view is that the total price is likely to be around $30m. Current market capitalization is around $22.5bn.
One of Alltel’s challenges is how to take better advantage of its balance sheet. It carries about $2.7bn of long term debt, a low figure in this sector for a company that produces roughly the same amount in cashflow each year (Sprint, for instance, carries debt of nearly twice its annual cashflow). The low debt makes Alltel attractive to PE companies, but its rising share price may stay their hands.
As well as private equity deals, the larger cellcos could also go for a direct acquisition. Verizon Wireless has been linked to Alltel for ages, and this speculation intensified when the smaller carrier dropped out of last year’s AWS spectrum auctions, leading observers to assume that it would leave the way free for Verizon to snap up the frequencies prior to a merger. Alltel would be a good match for Verizon, with which it already has roaming deals, since both use the CDMA network and it would fill many of the larger cellco’s coverage gaps. A purchase would put Verizon once more into the number one spot, which it lost when Cingular Wireless and the former AT&T Wireless merged, and would boost its recent aggressive activities in taking over small spectrum holders and buying licenses. Like other majors, Verizon wants to expand its geographical reach as its plum markets become saturated, and this means gaining direct control of some rural regions – in which Alltel is strong – rather than relying on roaming with local providers. It also wants to maximize its bandwidth arsenal to accelerate its launch of multimedia services.
Sprint Nextel would be harmed by a Verizon-Alltel tie-up, since it would put its larger CDMA rival totally out of its reach in terms of reach and spectrum ownership, and would presumably end the Sprint-Alltel roaming deal, on which the larger player is heavily dependent in rural areas, where it has poor coverage. Therefore a Verizon acquisition might force Sprint to accelerate its build-out of its new WiMAX network to gain differentiation through service innovation and margin rather than reach, and to harness the spectrum band where it has the undoubted leadership in capacity.
There is also the chance that AT&T would try to acquire Alltel, although this would create far greater integration problems than for Verizon, since the market leader uses GSM/UMTS rather than CDMA, and is still digesting the string of mergers that led to its current dominant form. Those touting an AT&T-Alltel deal point to its recent near-doubling of first quarter net income and its failure to win a stake in Telecom Italia. Outgoing CEO Ed Whitacre said on the earnings call that the operator would look for ne acquisition opportunities, but these are surely more likely to be in new territories than to gain an incompatible CDMA network in a country where it already holds such sway.
Alltel has more than 12m customers, mostly in small and rural markets throughout the Midwest, West and South, and it trying to expand from a regional to a national player despite the consolidation of power between the big four, and the rising challenge from flat rate operators like Leap and MetroPCS, and from MVNOs like Virgin Mobile.