Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 June 2008

Analysis: Responses line up to iPhone, as Apple creates new breed of walled garden

In the aftermath of the launch of the 3G iPhone everyone is trying to get to grips with just what Steve Jobs brought to the mobile party that was new. Most of the pundits have missed it, because there was quite a lot. But nonetheless, Apple may have, uncharacteristically, made some serious miscalculations, and the iPhone has certainly had its day as undisputed king of the internet phone sector, as more and more credible alternatives come to market.

This is one of the key impacts of the iPhone then ‘ to bring the best out of all its rivals, with Nokia reiterating the availability this August of the already lauded N96, which it will position head-to-head with iPhone, and Samsung, on the same day, launching its own all-touch iPhone killer, the Omnia i900, a Windows phone with many of the same features. Last week also saw Nokia unveiling the latest models in its email optimized enterprise phone range, the E66 and E71, promising ‘well crafted devices that were beautiful and trendy’ for business users, and adding features such as GPS. Whilst the E66 slider has a slick exterior without pushing boundaries on the looks front – aesthetically it echoes its E65 predecessor – the E71 is being touted as the world’s slimmest QWERTY enabled phone at 10mm thick, coming on as a slimline version of the BlackBerry, with a big RIM-style keyboard. Both phones include a 3.2 megapixel camera, front mounted for video calling (lacking on the iPhone). The phones come with auto-rotating screens and allow users to assign two different home screens, one for work and one for play. Matt Thornton, analyst at Avian Securities, reported from a Nokia management meeting that the E71 was ‘very impressive with a form factor that is thinner than the Pearl or Curve and width somewhere in between the two.’

For Nokia, the problem market remains the US, where it is trying to make inroads with a new handset for Verizon Wireless nicknamed ‘The Dark Knight’ ‘ a tie-in with the forthcoming Hollywood movie of the same name, reflecting how even Nokia, usually protective of its own brands, is succumbing to the trend to attract interest to handsets by using third party brands from the fashion or media worlds (Qualcomm says 20% of handsets will fall into this category, with LG’s Prada being the pioneer, within a few years.) The new Nokia phone will also come in a standard, non-movie linked blue-and-silver version, dubbed the 6205. The clamshell will sell for $70 after an online instant rebate and with two-year service contract and will support Verizon’s Vcast Music services, VZ Navigator, the Get It Now content store, browsing and a 1.3 megapixel camera.

More exciting to the market than N Series and E Series upgrades and US handsets are rumors of the long awaited ‘ some would say seriously late ‘ first touchscreen handset from the world’s largest phonemaker. Nokia has played it cool on this issue, claiming it has a product ready but will choose the best market timing to launch it, rather than being pushed by a competitor (ie Apple). The planned device, the Tube, is expected in the fourth quarter, coming with Java and Flash, haptics and a wealth of Web 2.0-style software features.

Nokia is also pursuing its usual line of attack against Apple ‘ that it has volumes that the iPhone could only dream of. So it is stressing that, once it does have touchscreen phones commercialized, it will push these well beyond their current high end webphone niche and into the mainstream. “Currently, the market for touchscreen products is a niche market. We always aim for a situation where we can cover all the segments with all the options,” Anssi Vanjoki, senior VP of Nokia Markets, told news agency Reuters last week. “We will introduce products from the very low segment to the highest one featuring this type of functionality.”

Nokia may not be interested in niches, but other device makers know these represent their only chance of a real position in the mobile market. Apple is one, along with RIM, Palm and HTC, and all three have their own responses to the iPhone 3G. HTC has announced its Diamond Touch, which offers many of the features of the iPhone (and more) at a low production cost, thanks to using a single-chip architecture rather than a separate applications processor. The same design choice will underpin RIM’s next attempt to keep the BlackBerry family ahead of the rising levels of competition for the user bases driven by mobile email. The upcoming Bold family will be closely followed by a more media-intensive Thunder, both using a single chip architecture ‘ from Marvell. And Palm has started selling its Centro smartphone on Verizon Wireless’s network, adding to availability on Sprint Nextel and AT&T systems. The Centro increased its market share at the expense of the iPhone in the first quarter of the year, according to IDC, having shipped one million units by the end of March, and targeting the doubling of that figure by year end.

Among the larger phonemakers, Samsung and LG are keeping their heads well above water, beating the iPhone feature for feature. And then there is Sony Ericsson, the closest to Apple in terms of valuable media brands that can drive handset sales (Walkman and Cybershot, and in future, perhaps, Playstation). The Swedish-Japanese vendor may have had one bad quarter, but it is now falling back on a number of brands and capabilities that it has either borrowed from the Sony side of its parentage, or which it has experimented with, and which are now ready for prime time.

The four legs on which Sony Ericsson will build its iPhone response and its turnaroud ‘ the PlayStation, the Sony Cybershot cameras, its recent Gracenote music identification and protection acquisition and its PlayNow portal ‘ are all evident in announcements this week of new devices. In January Sony Ericsson rebooted its PlayNow portal to include 5m music tracks, many of them inherited from the now defunct Sony Connect platform, and added new record labels, a hip new edgy element called Uncut for unsigned artists, and 250 new games from EA Games, Gameloft, and others. Now it has added devices to support a web services challenge to Nokia – a new handset designed to be its first gaming device, with shadows of the PlayStation Portable in the design; a new 8.1 megapixel Cybershot branded phone; a handset that uses the Gracenote track ID system; and almost all of them with access to the PlayNow Arena portal. PlayNow has already launched in Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Finland in May and will see expansion within Europe, the Americas and Asia during Q3 and Q4 and reach 30 countries by the end of 2008 and virtually all top end Sony Ericsson handsets will be PlayNow ready.

Most important will be the emergence of PlayStation elements in the new Sony Ericsson F305 (the F stands for Fun and this is an entire new genre for Sony Ericsson). It sports a brand new Motion Gaming capability which works almost like the Nintendo Wii, and you move the phone in your hand to do things in-game, like bowling, casting a fishing rod or riding a horse, using advanced motion sensor technology.

So what of the new iPhone itself? Pundits were split immediately into two camps. Those who love the iPhone; and those whose first experiences with Apple have always meant they are negative about the company, who want anything but an Apple device, and who continue to point out that the 3G iPhone is finally almost as good as the promised N96, but still doesn’t have that wonderful complete Nokia look and feel.

There should be a third group though – developers, all sorts of developers. People may complain about the SDK and how limiting it is, and how you can’t get at some of the core phone functions, but that hasn’t stopped people taking a look see, primarily because Apple is going to give them a route to market through its own Application Store. Programmers everywhere are thinking: ‘What if I can get a paid app on the iPhone?’

One in particular which we saw last week was Sling Media, now part of EchoStar in the US. SlingBox is a device which takes TV outputs, be they DVD, the Sky+ DVR or a cable service, recompresses the program and sends it out to wherever the user is, as long as that is on a broadband line (including 3G). Apple is ambivalent about this, and is unsure whether it wants to sell lots more video from the iTunes store, or allow applications like Sling on its new device, enabling users to view their own television remotely rather than rely on mobile TV or downloaded content. So Sling is only showing a ‘concept’ version on the new iPhone, and is awaiting Apple’s approval. Sling makes its money selling the box for home and the application on the handset or PC, and we would expect that to be a hot pull for any device that has it, and Apple will soon realize that its new iPhone needs it.

Meanwhile, Apple is quietly creating a walled garden (see lead item), but not the traditional one that operators have created. A walled garden is where an operator says which applications and which services can work over its network. The new walled gardens are where handset makers decide which applications and which services can operate on their devices.

While Nokia has spent a lot of time talking about its Ovi portal, all of the applications on the portal are written or owned by Nokia and its developer Forum. In the Application Store Apple has gone a step further, and by linking all software to an issued Digital Rights Management (DRM) License the company keeps control of which applications make it onto its devices, and also keeps control of the revenue streams from applications. The difference is that Apple is showing its roots, which are firmly in the PC world, where developers are everything, and like Facebook, the 3G iPhone will find that applications spring up fresh every day, renewing the iPhone experience in a way that companies like Nokia can only copy, because it developer community is mostly internal. This is what Google’s Android was supposed to achieve, but somehow Apple has engineered a desire to develop for its device.

Nokia will continue to sell more handsets than any other company, and Samsung will continue to sell the next highest, but they will have to open their minds further to a vibrant developer community if they want to stop Apple carving out a hugely profitably existence at their expense with the 3G iPhone, especially when the full capabilities of the next generation software come out next month, to be thought of as the real iPhone 2.0. Because this will stimulate whole new genres of application, which will work equally well on the iPod Touch and both iPhones and will introduce major incursions into the enterprise with Exchange server compatibility for email, push email, and in gaming (Apple has already demonstrated some games from Sega), further threatening Nokia enterprise Smartphones, the Blackberry and devices like the Nintendo DS and the Sony PlayStation Portable.

Part of this analysis was originally published in Faultline, Wireless Watch’s sister title, which offers weekly insights into the digital media markets and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Peter White on [email protected] for more details.