Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 February 2013

Analysts question Facebook’s mobile progress

Facebook looked more convincing on the smartphone platform in its fourth quarter than it ever has before, giving a much-needed jolt of confidence in its mobile strategy. However, while CEO Mark Zuckerberg proclaimed the social net giant was ‘now a mobile company’, an analyst report has thrown cold water on such claims. Investment research firm BTIG says the company will struggle to keep users on the service for long enough to deliver as many adverts as on a PC.

Analyst Richard Greenfield wrote in a client note: “We suspect the more consumers shift to mobile, the less total time they are spending with Facebook. “We struggle to believe Facebook can continue to ramp the ad load on mobile the way they did in Q4 2012.” That would put pressure on the firm to find alternative ways to generate new revenues and cope with the transition from PC to smatphone.

In its fourth quarter, Facebook reported that mobile users had overtaken those on PCs for the first time and mobile advertising had generated 23% of its total. However, BTIG, downgrading the company from ‘neutral’ to ‘sell’, believes that mobile ad growth actually slowed down during Q412 and that Facebook glossed over the fact during its report.

According to Greenfield’s calculations, the social giant averaged $3.4m per day from mobile ads, which would be up just 12% from the third quarter when Facebook reported a figure of $3m a day. In Q4, the firm increased the number of ads in member’ mobile News Feeds and introduced sponsored posts and app install ads, so a slow rate of growth would be concerning.

It is clear that Facebook will need to keep innovating to monetize its vast mobile traffic. It aims to be the primary platform for users to discover Android and iOS apps, rather than creating its own store, as it once considered. According to recent figures from comScore, 23% of time spent in mobile apps occurs via Facebook. And while, as BTIG points out, smartphone users may spend less time with Facebook than their PC equivalents, mobile customers return more frequently ‘ 70% at least on a daily basis, compared to 40% on the desktop, says the social firm.

Dan Rose, VP of partnerships for Facebook, told the AllThingsD conference: “We have made it so if they integrate with Facebook – 200,000 mobile apps are integrated – they can share their experience on mobile apps in their News Feed. Our partners’ job is to create great content. Our job is to honor that content. We are trying to find the right balance between delivering a great user experience and creating value for partners by sending traffic to them and honoring their content.”

He said that, this year, the company will focus on apps for movies and books, as well as on sports and fitness, all of which encourage social sharing and recommendations. Gaming is also important, as one-quarter of Facebook users play a game at least once a month.
.
Rose concluded: “We talk about ‘mobile first’ in 2012, but we want to be ‘mobile best’ in 2013. We want to create some mobile experiences that simply can’t be done on the desktop.”

Facebook is not the only one struggling to translate desktop success to mobile. Google has upgraded its AdWords platform in a bid to improve the attractiveness of mobile systems to advertisers.

It says the revamped AdWords will help brands target internet searches more accurately on mobile devices, and so enhance the returns on their ads. The updated platform will allow them to target consumers based on their ‘location, time of day and device type, across all devices without having to set up and manage several separate campaigns’, says Google.

The difficulty in fully transitioning Google’s sponsored search platform from PCs to smartphones and tablets was seen as the main factor in a 6% decline in its ‘cost per click’ during the fourth quarter of last year.

Now it will see its clients rolling out enhanced campaigns from March, and all users should be upgraded by the middle of this year. ‘Enhanced campaigns represent the biggest single change to the basic structure of AdWords campaigns in the past 10 years,’ Larry Kim of WordStream, a search marketing agency, told the Financial Times. ‘Mobile search has been growing incredibly quickly ‘ it’s actually expected to outpace desktop search by next year. But Google has had a big problem monetizing that traffic.’