Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2014

Apple’s outdated upgrade cycle starts to hit its supply chain

‘Ripeness is all’, as King Lear said, and in the smartphone business, that means achieving a miracle of coordination ‘ marketing a new device to stimulate the huge levels of demand necessary to gain share in this tough sector; and then have all the pieces in place in the supply chain, to deliver on that demand before the fickle consumer is lured away to the next big launch. Apple has excelled at this, partly because its loyal users will tolerate a delay more than most, but mainly because its scale and ‘safe bet’ sales forecasts kept its component suppliers fiercely on its side. However, there are signs that Apple’s powers in this area are not as strong as they were.

Many have stumbled in getting this balance of forecasting and timing right ‘ HTC did a high profile launch for the original HTC One, but then suffered delays and component shortages during the critical honeymoon period after the unveiling; others, of course, have overestimated and been stuck with high levels of inventory to clear, something that even hit some of Samsung’s models during the most recent quarter, the mighty vendor indicated in its recent quarterly results preview. Nokia used to be the unchallenged master of supply chain control, and that contributed as much to its success in its heyday as its actual design and promotion.

Now there are even question marks over Apple. The past couple of years have seen the iDevice maker struggle with its traditional annual upgrade cycle. With excited rumors about the next model starting up almost as soon as an iPhone is delivered, the vendor becomes a victim of its own unmatched ability to create consumer anticipation. Months before the expected unveiling of a new upgrade, purchasing of the current handset slows ‘ so if, as reports indicate, some of the hoped-for features are delayed this year, the problem will get even worse.

Reports indicate that both the iWatch and the 5.5-inch iPhones may arrive later than expected because Apple is having to adjust its supply chain to support unfamiliar components, some of them hard to make in the volumes it requires. This not only raises the prospect of new iDevice mass market sales being pushed into 2015, with negative impact on the important fourth quarter, but also shakes confidence in the once-infallible control that Apple has of its components suppliers and manufacturers. It has suffered parts shortages before, but in this intensely competitive mobile market, product delays have a far greater effect than in Apple’s heyday at the top of the smartphone tree.

Apple is widely expected to boost its holiday season revenues with larger-screen models for both its premium and ‘budget’ iPhone families, as well as introducing the long expected iWatch. However, diversifying the iDevice range has its own supply chain challenges, and well respected analyst Ming-Chi Kuo believes the iWatch will not ship in volume until late November, rather than September as originally believed.

The product ‘represents a new level of difficulty for Apple in regard to both hardware and software development’, wrote Kuo in a research note, and has involved the OEM adding new (and hard to manufacture) parts to its supply list. That will make it hard for Apple’s manufacturers to hit the volumes Wall Street is anticipating for this year ‘ analysts have touted 10m by year end, while the reality may be closer to 2m. If that prediction proves true, Apple will have missed some of the opportunity of the holiday period to shift smartwatches.

Kuo also suggests that the 5.5-inch iPhone may also be late. Apple is reportedly planning to launch two models, both with larger displays. The 4.7-inch model would go ahead as expected, this fall, if the reports are right, but the 5.5-inch version could be pushed back into next year. AppleInsider, quoting Kuo, said there may be issues with the in-cell touch panels and with the quality of color on the display. ‘The new in-cell touch panels may have issues related to touch sensitivity on the edges of the panel as displays become larger in size, making the 5.5-inch model a much greater technical achievement for Apple to accomplish,’ says the research note. The larger smartphone is expected to sport a sapphire front panel to make it scratch-resistant but Kuo suggests this is not passing the tests for being shatter-proof.

Even if both sizes make their debut in September as expected, and ship in volume during Q4, analysts are bracing for the biggest freeze ever on sales of current models, in the run-up to the launches ‘ making it even more important that Apple can meet that pent-up demand quickly during the fourth quarter, before Samsung intervenes with a tempting new Galaxy.

T Michael Walkley of Canaccord Genuity wrote in a research note that ‘our surveys indicated growing consumer anticipation for new larger-screen iPhones. Based on our analysis of global iPhone sales by region, we believe consumers slowed the pace of iPhone upgrade purchases during the iPhone 5 and 5s product cycles. We believe the extended replacement rates combined with new larger-screen iPhones position Apple with its large installed base for record iPhone 6 sales. Recent history definitely indicates that Apple’s September quarter iPhone sales will slow ahead of the iPhone 6 launch.’

Such developments will see the big vendors redoubling their efforts to control their supply chains absolutely. That means, where possible, either taking technology inhouse, or getting exclusive or ‘preferred nation’ rights with suppliers ‘ but those moves may yet conflict with the need, for high volume devices, to have multiple sources of supply for each key component. So while Apple designs its own processors, it is using two foundries to make them ‘ TSMC just started shipping its first commercial mobile CPUs to the firm, reports say, breaking the stranglehold of Samsung over its rival’s chip production. And though Apple would certainly like to reduce its reliance on its smartphone arch-rival, it cannot break the ties with Samsung entirely ‘ TSMC has been slow to reach the quality levels required for the iDevice processors, sources say, and will certainly not achieve sole foundry contracts, especially as it refused a request from Apple to guarantee it exclusive plant capacity.

Apple will keep Samsung in its processor fold too ‘ it makes the current A7 and the vendor is expected to pitch it against TSMC for future products, introducing competition into its supply chain as well as second sources for some high volume chips. Reuters reports that Samsung, not TSMC, will make next generation 14nm processors for both Apple and Qualcomm, starting in the second half of next year ‘ an important step to keep up with Intel’s process upgrades. On a recent analyst call, TSMC chairman Morris Chang said: “In 16-nanometer, TSMC will have a smaller market share than a major competitor in 2015. But we’ll regain leading share in 2016, 2017 and onwards.’

Samsung’s strength in displays and memory chips also make it unavoidable for almost any big-league smartphone maker, though that does not stop Apple trying to block its rival’s access to other important component vendors. According to reports from Japan’s Nikkei, Apple’s deal with Sharp, one of its display providers, in 2012 included a clause to change the equipment at the Japanese firm’s, at a cost of ’50bn ($400m) to the US firm. Now, Nikkei says, Sharp is offering ’30bn to Apple to buy back that equipment as it tries to diversify its customer base and use the plant, which currently only makes Apple screens, for other purposes too. That would allow it to fill in gaps in capacity during slower quarters for iPhone production ‘ an issue which could get worse if the upgrade cycles do get more extreme. Apple is said to be open to the deal, but is ‘said to be demanding that the Japanese company not supply panels to Samsung’, according to the reports. Although Samsung makes most of its own displays, it does not have the energy efficient IGZO technology pioneered by Sharp, the main way in which the Japanese firm is looking to revive and differentiate its screen business.

Apple’s market weight and ready cash has enabled it to snap up supplies of key products, like memory chips, in the past, getting a good price by buying in bulk in advance, and also keeping the units out of rivals’ hands. However, as the Sharp example shows, manufacturers are starting to demand greater protection against fluctuating iDevice sales, if they are to continue to prioritize Apple over other customers ‘ particularly as the Chinese vendors get stronger, at the expense of Apple’s scale and influence in this segment. Sharp is said to be particularly keen to open up its plant to Chinese clients.

In memory, processors and displays, Samsung scores over Apple because it has its own products and plants, and is investing heavily in expanding capacity for mobile chips as well as memory ‘ both to attract third party customers, but also to satisfy its own handset division (which is reportedly the only customer for many of its more advanced AMOLED screens). However, for all its increasing self-sufficiency in key components such as memory, displays and processors, Samsung is still vulnerable to hiccups in its chain ‘ which only get harder to manage as volumes of its devices rise.

Last year, delays hit the launch of its new flagship smartphone, the Galaxy S4, in several markets including the US. Samsung said the delays were down to far stronger demand than expected, which landed it with uncharacteristic difficulties in achieving its usual big bang, global roll-out. ‘Pre-order demand is much stronger than expected, so it’s difficult to rapidly boost supply in the short term,’ said Lee Don Joo, head of strategic marketing at Samsung’s mobile division. This year, however, the problem hitting Q2 results is excess inventory in some markets, indicating how difficult it is to get the forecasting right in the smartphone market, where the near-duopoly of Apple and Samsung has broken down in the face of a shift to the lower end models, and the rising strength of Chinese players like Lenovo, Huawei and Xiaomi.