At least looking ahead to 2013’s smartphone market is a more interesting task than it was a year ago. Then, there seemed little doubt that this had become a two-way battle between Apple and Samsung, with other vendors looking to newer form factors like tablets for their growth, and any device without Android or iOS fading rapidly into the background. A quick look at the situation at the end of this year seems to suggest little has changed. Apple and Samsung have more than half the smartphone market in their clutches; Samsung has even overtaken Nokia as leader of the overall handset market; Windows Phone and BlackBerry are single-digit players in most areas; Android tier two players are losing share.
However, a slightly closer look reveals signs of change ‘ and there is hope from recent events in the law courts that these movements will be allowed to play out in commercial competition and product innovation, not the legal wars which have distracted the mobile device sector in 2012. The seeds of change lie in the following factors:
‘ The beginnings of a loss of confidence in Apple, which could see it failing to seize the number one spot back from Samsung in a sustainable way, and eventually becoming one of many in smartphones.
‘ The rise of importance of Google, not just indirectly via its Android partners, but as a direct shaper of the device market. The search giant is getting serious about the Nexus range and will target high volumes next year, rather than positioning its own-brand products as developer showcases. This is the main way it will seek to ensure that its own version of the Android user experience ‘ heavily centered on its own revenue streams of course ‘ will dominate the field. This has become particularly urgent at a time when China has become the world’s largest smartphone market ‘ and it has emerged that a majority of Chinese Android users do not have the Google user interface. The jury is still out on what Google will do with Motorola Mobility except continue to slash at its costs ‘ selling it on would be the sensible option, but it may morph the venerable unit into an R&D center and a focus for Nexus developments which does not compete directly with OEM partners.
‘ Amazon will continue to be a disruptive force for both Apple and Google, with its different approach to costs and margins ‘ lossleading devices which are designed to deliver maximum content and other purchasing. It is hard for the established platform suppliers to respond directly to this model, though the Nexus 7 was a good attempt. Amazon is a good example of how Google finds itself having to fight against companies which have adopted Android, but which are pushing their own user experience, one that drives revenues to them and not to Google. The rise of non-traditional device makers, whose brands center on services not the gadgets themselves, will continue to be a feature of 2013 and one which will be tough for the hardware-only brigade, even Samsung. It will foster a race by such firms to become services vendors too ‘ a goal Nokia’s undersung former CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo identified years ago, but which was lost in Nokia politics and poor execution. Belatedly, the Finnish firm has understood his point, creating an OS-neutral platform around the Navteq mapping technology, and Samsung, ZTE, HTC and others will have to think of their own take on this particular trend.
‘ Related to the above, the rising power of the Chinese handset makers, which will leverage the volumes they can generate in their home base to make an impact round the world. ZTE and Huawei are investing heavily in this process, and Lenovo will follow, with smartphones hanging on the coat tails of its big push in tablets and Windows 8 tablet/notebook hybrids.
‘ The hand of Microsoft will be seen more strongly than ever before in mobile. This will be partly because, like Google, it is injecting huge resources into making itself into a device brand in its own right, creating an integrated hardware/software experience around Windows 8. We believe there will be major risks to this strategy for both software giants, unaccustomed to the device business (and in Microsoft’s case, apart from Xbox, a serial failure there). They are entering the smartphone sector just as it commoditizes and becomes best suited to companies geared up for volume consumer electronics, and that sector’s particular channels and margins. And platform makers, of course, create significant conflicts of interest with partners when they launch their own hardware. However, Microsoft’s efforts will certainly shift the balance of power and help make it credible in mobile products for the first time, mainly through third parties’ Windows RT tablets and convertibles. These will be a genuinely new option, and will help drive adoption of Windows Phone, which is converging with W8 and so will be able to come out of its wilderness as a niche OS at last.
‘ The entry of WP8 into the mobile platform mainstream will only be accomplished, however, if Microsoft brings it even closer to W8 quickly, explicitly presenting them as a single system. The current situation where WP8 licensees are excluded from tablets is damaging to the mobile OS, and the situation needs to be addressed if Nokia is to take full advantage of growth in Windows Phone.
‘ The Finnish giant has huge challenges ahead in 2013, which is likely to be its make-or-break year in devices. It needs to:
o get into tablets and other form factors to boost margins and avoid being seen as a low end vendor;
o build aggressively on the momentum of its well differentiated featurephone/smartphone crossover range, Asha, especially in emerging economies; it needs to develop a fully fledged platform for that sector, which it still has the chance to own but where it needs to fend off low cost Android models
o a cutdown version of Windows Phone may be the answer, but a new cloud-oriented OS would be far better;
o continue to gain support for its web services, especially the Nokia Here location platform, as a back-up option should it continue to fade in hardware.
CEO Stephen Elop certainly recognizes the need for swift action, and the fact that there is a moment, possibly a brief one, where the winds are in favour of the challengers to the Apple-Google duopoly. He told CNet: ‘There’s been a marked shift towards this challenger mindset. We have to move with urgency. We have to have empathy and listen to our customers. How do we respond to consumer demand that we haven’t done as quickly as before? How do we take those bold steps? How do we disrupt the competition? From what I’ve seen in this organization, that shift is happening.’
Nokia is reported to be working on a Windows RT tablet, but has been discouraged by lukewarm early sales of other vendors’ devices from launching too early ‘ especially as it wants to focus resources and public attention on Lumia, and on WP8, where it has a better chance of standing out from the crowd than in tablets. However, the firm does need to expand beyond a smartphone sector which is rapidly commoditizing (though it did bring out a slate ahead of most rivals, with the Nokia 770 Internet Tablet of 2005, and followed up with the Booklet 3G in 2009). According to Taiwan’s Digitimes, Nokia also postponed its plans in order not to clash with Microsoft’s own Surface tablet launch. ‘Nokia originally planned to develop a 10-inch Windows RT tablet equipped with Qualcomm’s S4 processor in first quarter 2012, with Compal to undertake ODM production and initial shipments of 200,000 units to test the market,’ the sources indicated.
‘ Finally, what of RIM? The firm is in much the same position as last year ‘ losing share, clinging on to relevance ‘ but with the big difference that BlackBerry 10 is finally over the horizon. Probably too little too late, and RIM’s future almost certainly lies in back end enterprise services, where it can try to ride the mobile device management and BYOD waves which have been the downfall of its smartphones. However, the carriers are desperate for viable alternatives to Google and Apple, and have realized that, while HTML5 and cross-platform services may deliver that in the end, in the short term they need new native OSs to gain respectable share. Windows Phone is the main contender, but the operators’ desire for partners they can control more effectively than Microsoft or Google is seen in their unexpectedly enthusiastic endorsements during the preview phase of BB10. RIM will never regain the position it once held, but rumors of its death may prove to be exaggerated after all.
These are the trends which we believe will influence the smartphone and tablet segments next year, and will create a very different landscape when we look back again at the end of 2013. Even a few events in the dying weeks of 2012 reflect the changes which are bubbling under the surface of the Apple-Google ocean. Here are a few important ones:
Amazon’s handset to join Android crowd in Q2?
Amazon could ship its long awaited smartphone as early as the second quarter of next year, according to reports from the Taiwanese supply chain. Amazon has reportedly hired Taiwanese manufacturing giant Foxconn/Hon Hai to make an Android smartphone to join the Kindle tablet and handset range. It will run the same heavily customized take on the Android user experience, and is likely to be keenly priced in order to encourage rapid uptake by carriers and users, and stimulate purchasing from Amazon’s various stores ‘ its own Android applications shopfront, the Kindle bookstore, other digital content resources, and even the buying of physical goods.
The latest reports, from Taiwan Economic News, suggest the device will be launched in the second or third quarter, initially in the US, at a unit price of $100 to $200, well below most smartphones of its expected calibre. As with the Kindle Fire, Amazon is expected to price its handset to make minimal profits from hardware, but to drive content sales, and to include all the software and media capabilities of a smartphone, while scrimping on certain expensive parts like a top end display. The newspaper cites ‘some smartphone parts makers’ as stating that Foxconn expects to make up to 5m units during 2013. Amazon has been expected to launch a handset since the debut of the first Kindle Fire.
Supply shortages will hit all big players in 2013:
A successful launch in the Kindle range could just add to the component shortages being experienced by mobile device makers. Apple’s iPhone 5 launch was initially hit by difficulties in getting enough suppliers of important elements like screens, and now Google’s latest Nexus model ‘ the first to be made by LG – is also suffering from shortages.
The Nexus 4 has been out of stock since shortly after it went on sale last month, and Google’s managing director for the UK and Ireland, Dan Cobley, in a Q&A with users on Google+, put the blame firmly on LG. He wrote: “Dear all, I know that what you are going through is unacceptable, and we are all working through the nights and weekends to resolve this issue. Supplies from the manufacturer are scarce and erratic, and our communication has been flawed. I can offer an unreserved apology for our service and communication failures in this process.”
As reported by CNet, Cobley said orders are now in the process of being fulfilled for people who originally received a shipping estimate of 3-5 days. Those buyers will receive a credit for the cost of shipping. Released in mid-November, the handset sold out within half an hour.
Andy Coughlin, the head of mobile at LG UK, told CNet that the device “had proven extremely popular, and as such retailers have been met with huge demand.” The situation suggests that Google and its partners are not yet geared up for the challenges of high volume launches, since in the past the Nexus products have been largely targeted at developers and have achieved high profile, but limited sales levels. However, this will be a blow to LG, which has been included in Google’s inner circle for the first time, an important symbolic step forward in its bid to come out of the shadow of Samsung ‘ the most regular provider of Nexus devices, although others have come from HTC and Asus, and Google is expected to widen the circle next year, and possibly include its own handset unit, Motorola Mobility.
Investors grow strangely bearish on Apple:
Apple stock has been slumping ever since the weak launches of the new iPads (relative to massively high expectations of course), with many stock analysts worried about the iPad Mini cannibalizing sales of the higher end models. This has been compounded by indications from Asian component suppliers that there has been a slowdown of orders from Apple, suggesting that the firm expects weaker sales after the new year.
Apple felt compelled this week to respond to the chatter ‘ it would usually stay well aloof from it ‘ by taking the unusual step of releasing first weekend order numbers for the iPhone 5 launch in China, which with 2m units sold, hardly suggested a slowdown. Apple says that the iPhone 5 will be available in more than 100 countries by the end of December, making it the fastest iPhone roll-out ever.
Nevertheless, talk of cuts in components remain and Apple seems far less effective than it was under Steve Jobs in keeping its suppliers silent. Citigroup analyst Glen Yeung was the latest to cut his rating on the stock (to neutral from buy), taking $100 off the target for Apple’s share price, while UBS analyst Steven Milunovich also cut his estimate on concerns over sales growth on the iPhone and iPad. He told clients: ‘Our previous growth estimates seem aggressive’, slashing his earnings per share forecast for fiscal 2013 to $47 from $51.50. Apple was trading at $509 as the markets closed last week, its lowest level since February, and down 27% since its market high in September.
At least six analysts have cut their price targets for Apple in the past week, mainly because of fears of slowing demand caused by rising competition and a shift of growth to emerging markets with lower margins. As well as Citigroup and UBS, there were negative reports from Pacific Crest Securities, Mizuho Securities USA, BMO Capital Markets and Canaccord Genuity. Most agree that a far more radical device than the iPhones 4S and 5 is required to restore faith in ‘Apple magic’ and prevent its flagship becoming just one choice among many highly featured smartphones. Many also think Apple will have to abandon its one-device-per-year cycle ‘ as it already has with the iPad ‘ and produce several models per year, both to target a wider range of user bases and price points, and to avoid the boom and bust nature of its sales pattern, with users holding off on buying Apple products for months before a new one is due or even rumored.
‘Apple is feeling the heat,’ Michael Obuchowski, a portfolio manager at North Shore Asset Management, told Bloomberg. ‘There is a lot of pressure on Apple to bring new magical devices to the market, and that hasn’t happened in a while.’ And Andy Hargreaves of Pacific Crest reduced his forecast for new iPhone customers in 2013 to 62.4n from 84.3m, writing in a client note: ‘Global consumer demand for iPhone 5 is not as strong as we anticipated. Although we believe iPhone 5 remains the best-selling high end smartphone on the market and is likely gaining significant share right now, a combination of market saturation, weak global demand and incremental innovation that has surpassed consumer demand’ are probably hurting sales.
There are optimists about Apple, however ‘ and of course, all this negativity comes against the backdrop of very high expectations and performance, in both stock and sales, which most companies would kill for. Among the bullish commentators, Brian White of Topeka Capital Markets maintained his prediction that Apple’s stock will top the $1,000 mark (reaching $1,111) partly because of Chinese growth potential, while Maynard Um of Wells Fargo Securities likened the panic about the iPhone maker to the Mayan Apocalypse speculation.
RIM at highest level since May, on positive signs for BB10:
RIM has been working hard to court carriers and enterprise customers this month, with roadshows and previews for its BB10 operating system ‘ softening up its core bases before it goes after the consumer market with its full launch at the end of January. The technical preview program, available to 120 customers, is designed to reassure key corporate and government clients that the migration to the new OS will be smooth and deliver huge new functionality.
According to Sterne Agee analyst Shaw Wu, optimism about BB10 is rising on strong reception from operators, which are “increasingly leery of the growing dominance of iOS and Android and have been looking for a viable third or potentially fourth platform’. However, while the existing BlackBerry developer base has been, on the whole, positive about the new platform, it has been far harder to woo the new partners which BB10 will need to compete with the big two platforms and Windows 8/WP8.
Some US government agencies, a critical customer base and one which influences the broader enterprise market, have been abandoning BlackBerry, because of BYOD policies, and fears about migration challenges, security flaws and recent outages. However, RIM got one piece of good news in this respect before the holiday, when the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency, which had planned to end its contract with RIM in favour of iPhones, decided to give BB10 a chance after all. The department will trial the new RIM smartphones from February, along with the next generation BlackBerry Enterprise Server 10, before making its decision.
Such crumbs of comfort have sent RIM shares to the highest level they have been since May 1.