Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 November 2007

AT&T delays MediaFLO launch, eyeing EchoStar

AT&T has delayed the launch of its MediaFLO mobile TV service until early next year, a move that has split pundits. One side suggests that the decision means that MediaFLO is not yet ready for prime time, and that not enough people are taking the service already available from Verizon Wireless (which has not yet given out numbers). The other faction says that it is in fact the entire concept of mobile TV that is in the slow lane and AT&T is pushing back costs until consumer demand is more proven.

There is a third view. We remain convinced that AT&T is going to use the 700MHz spectrum that it acquired recently from HiWire to launch mobile TV services, probably using the HiWire trial technology, the DVB-H standard. This delay of three to four months would give an internal team at AT&T the kind of time it needs to plan such a DVB-H network and to make key business estimates on how long it will take to bring in revenues. The operator could then decide whether it needs to wait for DVB-H or whether it should go ahead and launch MediaFLO first, to stay in step with fierce rival Verizon, and then launch DVB-H later.

Qualcomm’s MediaFLO holds 6MHz of 700MHz channels in which to run its hosted mobile TV service, which in theory can support about 20 channels. However, Verizon Wireless only offers eight ‘ perhaps because MediaFLO is holding back bandwidth for other operators, but increasingly there are those in the mobile TV community who are describing 20 channels as ‘a theoretical maximum’, and pointing out that Qualcomm has yet to run a trial with any more than 11 channels. Given that there have been DVB-H trials around the world at 17 channels in 8MHz of spectrum, then the spectrum which AT&T has purchased can deliver at least 24, and most analysts expect it to be closer to 30 channels and rising.

If that turns out to be even close to being true, then there is not much spare capacity within MediaFLO’s 6MHz for AT&T to offer a decent rival service to Verizon, with differentiated content. It may have no option but to go it alone with its own spectrum. It might cost another $500m to build out the network, but it can at least build on the experience gained by partners in the HiWire trial such as satellite player SES Americom, Italy’s RRD – which helped integrate the 3 Italia DVB-H network – and transmitter maker DMT, will have already done a lot of planning on how to rapidly build out a network.

The jury is still out on whether or not AT&T will ever launch MediaFLO handsets, but our view is that it probably will. AT&T has an exclusive on the Apple iPhone, but still cut a deal with Napster for an online music service that will go to its more advanced handsets. AT&T may well introduce MediaFLO if it can come up with a package of channels equivalent to Verizon’s VCAST TV, but then launch the DVB-H service alongside it, and let the MediaFLO service wither on the vine. That way it has all options covered.

It might even do it with the same handset. LG Electronics is understood to be supplying handsets to the HiWire trial. If it were to work with its partner Qualcomm and use its DVB-H/MediaFLO chip, then the same device could be offered to the market with a different software footprint.

Another story that hit the news recently was the possibility that AT&T might purchase satellite TV player EchoStar, in which case we have to ask what implications there would be if the telco did buy both the 700MHz spectrum that it might use for mobile TV, and EchoStar at the same time?

Would this give it access to a bigger basket of content? Could it use the special skills of the satellite services half of EchoStar, (which will not be part of the sale), either to deliver signals to mobile TV transmitters, or to deliver regional advertising to different parts of the network? Could it even opt to use a form of mobile TV, such as Alcatel-Lucent’s DVB-SH, which is delivered from satellite, which might give it a flying start? After all, EchoStar landed the contract to offer satellite capacity for the Chinese mobile TV system, which needs to be in place by mid-2008. And ALU is the lead network equipment provider in AT&T’s IPTV Project Lightspeed, and it might find it easier to integrate its IPTV channels into a mobile brand working with that same supplier.

This analysis was originally published by Wireless Watch’s sister service Faultline, which provides weekly in-depth insights into broadband digital media markets and technologies, and the economics of the quad play. Please contact Linda Elisha on [email protected] for more information.