Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 September 2012

AT&T faces challenge over FaceTime block

Consumer and open internet groups are seeking a major test of the FCC’s controversial 2010 net neutrality rules, with a complaint against AT&T’s recent decision to restrict usage of Apple’s FaceTime video calling application on its cellular network.

The cellco plans to prevent certain subscribers from using the service on its networks, citing the usual cellco conundrum, that some of the apps which hog most time and capacity on the network also deliver little revenue to the operator.

However, three groups at the forefront of US net neutrality campaigns – Free Press, Public Knowledge, and the New America Foundation’s Open Technology Institute ‘ say these rules would break the 2010 rules, which forbid a carrier from blocking services that compete with its own. They have informed AT&T that they intend to file a complaint with the FCC.

AT&T said last month that it would block FaceTime, and certain iOS 6 updates, all of which will be found in the upcoming iPhone 5, for customers who had not signed for one of its new Mobile Shared Data plans. These tariffs are designed to match charges more closely to levels of usage and epitomize the new billing approaches with which operators are trying to gain value from third party services. The carrier said all its subscribers can still use FaceTime via Wi-Fi.

In addition to commercial justifications, AT&T also argued it was not violating net neutrality rules. It said it was being open and transparent, as required by the new laws, and it made a convoluted case concerning preloaded apps, which focused on the idea that, if the service is usable over Wi-Fi, it is not blocked. The latter seeks to set an important precedent for the whole cellular sector ‘ to equate Wi-Fi to 3G/4G and therefore allow operators to restrict services to a particular network.

But Matt Wood, policy director of Free Press, wrote in the notice to AT&T: ‘AT&T’s decision to block FaceTime unless a customer pays for voice and text minutes she doesn’t need is a clear violation of the FCC’s Open Internet rules. It’s particularly outrageous that AT&T is requiring this for iPad users, given that this device isn’t even capable of making voice calls. AT&T’s actions are incredibly harmful to all of its customers, including the deaf, immigrant families and others with relatives overseas, who depend on mobile video apps to communicate with friends and family.’

Verizon is striking a different balance in its approach to FaceTime ‘ and by extension, any data-heavy over-the top service. It says it will not block the Apple offering on any device or network, but has far more aggressive moves in place than AT&T, to push users towards its own shared data plans.